3 ms·
Ever since I became aware of this study I was on the lookout for this with my dog. There was no expressed clear preference of NS and an avoidance of EW. On leas
by vlovich123 4y ago
Ever since I became aware of this study I was on the lookout for this with my dog. There was no expressed clear preference of NS and an avoidance of EW. On leash / off leash doesn't matter.
Obviously I didn't do this methodically so I could be mistaken. However, without any replication and the note about potential p-hacking of another commentor, I'm going with BS for now.
- ElijahLynn 4y agoGood on you for validating the study! FWIW, the study says they only do it when the magnetic field is calm, which was only 20% of the time (it says).
- vlovich123 4y agoAh. That could also be it as I obviously didn't control for that and missed that critical piece. So maybe this study is legit after all. Hard to say.
- nomel 4y agoPerhaps there was some selective pressure, where the owners, who could accurately use this new form of poovayance, had a higher chance of survival, especially in northern climates where it can be more difficult to find North. These owners went on to survive, along with their gifted dogs. Maybe your dog is of southern descent. Or, perhaps an insightful breeder realized that their dog was throwing directional lots [1], after looking for their bag of bone lots that had be eaten in secret, and capitalized on it. Or..yeah maybe it's DS. :) 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleromancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleromancy
- matt-attack 4y agoWho’s to say that our classification of “dog” lines up with whatever this effect lines up with biologically. I mean the variation alone in size and shape is pretty broad within the category of “dog”. Is it unreasonable to think that other properties like poop alignment don’t also vary across breeds?