3 ms·
>So, now, to the Fermi paradox: where are they (the intelligent extraterrestrial life we should have met by now)? Stuck, perhaps, in a gravity well? Why should
by bluGill 4y ago
>So, now, to the Fermi paradox: where are they (the intelligent extraterrestrial life we should have met by now)? Stuck, perhaps, in a gravity well?
Why should we have met them by now? Even if they have a planet significantly smaller than earth, they still need to escape their star, and then spend years in space - without any breakdowns or hitting anything. There are only a handful of stars within 5 light years -that is 5 years at the speed of life (relativity gets interesting if you can actually get that fast), but realistically they can't get going that fast with rockets, so we are talking thousands of years to make the trip. Assuming they are very advanced they left when they first detected life on earth - a bit over 100 years ago radio signals from us would have reached them. Even if they are only 5 light years away it is impossible that we met them yet.
Once you look at some alien more than 10 light years we cannot really establish meaningful science communications as our advances mean anything we are interested in we probably figure out already. (we can still exchange culture) At 50-60 light years out, they can't even get a message back to us now that they know we are here. Once you get to a bit over 100 they don't know we are here yet no matter how sensitive their radios are.
In short there is no Fermi paradox: there might or might not be life out there, but they don't even know we are here, and it they couldn't reach us if they did.
- walnutclosefarm 4y ago> In short there is no Fermi paradox: there might or might not be life out there, but they don't even know we are here, and it they couldn't reach us if they did. All that assumes two things for which there is no strong argument. First, that an extraterrestial intelligence would only be interested in traveling to another planet because it detected signs of intelligent life there. But why would that be? Why wouldn't a "life friendly" planet be almost as interesting? Suitability for life, and likely even the signal of the presence of life, is something you can get from spectral observation. And second, intelligent life may or may not care a great deal about the time of travel. No reason intelligent "iife" elsewhere should not be self-constructed to be indefinitely patient and repairable.
- bluGill 4y agoThere are still a lot of stars, with little reason to suspect any one has a life capable planet. While you can get a lot of information from spectral observation, most of the universe isn't close enough to observe it. The earth is young enough that even if we assume infinite magnification most of the universe cannot observe it as no light from earth has reached them yet.