4 ms·
> The PC industry has been scroogling users on I/O since the late 2000's… What does this mean? (I'm familiar with the Microsoft ad campaign, but that doesn't m
by CharlesW 4y ago
> The PC industry has been scroogling users on I/O since the late 2000's…
What does this mean? (I'm familiar with the Microsoft ad campaign, but that doesn't make sense to me in this context.)
- PaulHoule 4y agoUnfortunately it's an obscure topic because people have been so dependent on laptops and phones that few people know about the regression of desktop PCs. Here's a simple example. I found an old i3 PC from Intel in my house that was left by one of my son's friends. The CPU is artificially limited to 16 PCI lanes. You might think you could plug a discrete GPU in, it only uses 16 lanes, but no, some of those lanes are consumed by storage, USB ports, super I/O, etc. So this computer is e-waste now because it can't be upgraded to keep up. This kind of delinquency is only possible because Intel has pushed barely-functional integrated "GPU"s. Back in the 1980s and 1990s you had to know some rules about how interrupts were assigned to slots to build a working PC. Since the early 2000's, PC builders face a number of barely documented rules about how PCI lanes are assigned which boil down to "i3 and i5 are e-waste, buying a budget or mid-range motherboard is a waste of money because upgrading your machine will be a matter of 'you can't get here from there'"
- yourusername 4y agoEven with 8 lanes available a GPU should work fine. If it's a very high end GPU it won't run at full speed but this is a old i3 so probably not a issue. Some low end GPU's only use 4 lanes to begin with. Did it actually fail to work when you added a GPU?
- justsomehnguy 4y agoI think the other poster is... exaggerating his one-time experience to everything. I personally did "x16-x1 mod", ie removed the plastic from the connector so a x16 video card could be installed in a x1 slot (and free up the x16 slot for a network or RAID card, don't remember atm). Video card worked fine. It's up to PCI-E standard to actually use any amount of lanes available. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:PCIe_J1900_SoC_ITX_Mainboard_IMG_1820.JPG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:PCIe_J1900_SoC_ITX_Mainbo...
- PaulHoule 4y agoYes
- cortesoft 4y agoI think the question was more around the use of the word “scroogle”.
- CharlesW 4y agoYes! From the interesting answers I think "scroogling" was used as a synonym for "screwing" or "gaslighting". I've never seen it used outside of the Microsoft ad campaign, so it's interesting to see it in the wild. > scroogling
- jamiek88 4y agoI think it was a typo for scrooging which is a common enough word for being cheap(USA) / tight (uk).
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoIn the 80's PCs and software ate the world, and one of those reasons (apart from DOS/Windows) was that anyone could put something on a PC expansion card which more or less directly spoke to the CPU and extend the hardware. So the PC acquired a very diverse set of cards and was able to do heavy processing in a very diverse set of roles - from medical equipment, cash registers, MIDI/music composition, graphics, publishing, sound, networking, etc. No business was untouched by the PC in the 80's--the ability of anyone to make hardware for the platform was a significant part of that being as cheap as possible. PC hardware seems to be slowly moving towards being like a cell phone - everything onboard/builtin, ports picked by the manufacturer (you will get 1 USB-C port and like it), and if you want to add something, your primary option is a USB-type port of some sort - with its own world of firmware, controllers, etc. Look at a smartphone and a modern ODM-designed cheapo laptop motherboard - they're very similar. If motherboards stop being expandable it might mean the PC hardware ecosystem isn't going to be able to innovate except at the behest of high-capital firms like Intel, AMD, etc. That might be OK if we are truly at the zenith of what's possible with a PC, and really want to give the keys to the kingdom to those firms. And who knows - I know somewhere in there USB4/Thunderbolt on some level is able to move PCIe traffic, so maybe it won't be so bad.
- cbozeman 4y ago> That might be OK if we are truly at the zenith of what's possible with a PC, and really want to give the keys to the kingdom to those firms. No, we don't, and they've already shown we can't. Intel kept us at 4-core shit-tier processors for a decade, and the moment AMD managed to get a leg-up on Intel, they killed their HEDT platform because it competed with their server platform in PCI Express lanes and turned their back on all the gamers that brought their sorry ass back from the brink of death. Both of them have been shown to be greedy, opportunistic shitbags of companies that cannot be trusted.
- PaulHoule 4y agoUSB3, USB-C is no answer. Back when the USB1 spec came out it said you could plug 127 devices into a port through a hierarchy of hubs. With three different laptops and a plethora of USB 3 hubs I found the system would support only a limited number of devices in the tree. If you plugged in too many devices (somewhere between 3 and 5), plugging in an new device would cause an existing device to drop out. It's just annoying if it is a keyboard or mouse that gets dropped out but if it is a storage device data could get corrupted. I looked at the USB 3 spec and couldn't find any guarantee that there was any number of devices you could plug into hubs and have it work.