3 ms·
No-one thinks we need lots of storage, except people who used to think renewables didn't work, and would never be cheap, and we didn't have room and they'd kill
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
No-one thinks we need lots of storage, except people who used to think renewables didn't work, and would never be cheap, and we didn't have room and they'd kill all the birds and now need another way to put off facing being totally wrong for a short while longer.
- jackmott42 4y agoI'm not sure if you think this requirement is not actually necessary, or if you are thinking of using nuclear to make up a large percent of the base. The latter is certainly an option.
- MezzoDelCammin 4y agoIt's generally not necessary in the quantities and timeframes used in some anti-renewables arguments (those often being "now" and "all the capacity the renewables are generating"). It sometimes comes to people as a surprise how little solar / wind is actually installed and that the production mostly follows the peaks in daily consumption. Basically, the idea is that if we go installing new renewables at current speeds, we won't need any real battery storage for years.
- xienze 4y agoOf course you need storage. The sun doesn’t shine all day and the wind does stop blowing every now and then.
- sidewndr46 4y agoWhen it's the dead of night, no wind, no solar, and the ambient temp. is 85 F here in Texas how are we going to power everyone's AC without an energy storage solution? Texas isn't really a state known for building hydropower.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agohttps://www.wartsila.com/energy/towards-100-renewable-energy/atlas-of-100-percent-renewable-energy#/country/US-TX https://www.wartsila.com/energy/towards-100-renewable-energy... Well here's a prediction of how they'd do if they could store a small amount of hydrocarbons made from green energy. 3 hours of battery storage. And if they can't handle the flexible gas, a few more batteries would do it. 12 hours. I mean they could just run a gas plant and capture the carbon as the oil industry has been claiming they will, but that would be cheating wouldn't it. We need that last watt of power to be pure and green or else the massive amount of money saving renewables that Texas has already installed doesn't count.
- sidewndr46 4y agoMy question was not "how to store power" but how to generate power in the dead of night in Texas with no wind and no power storage.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago3 hours worth of batteries charged by solar and wind and if that runs out a turbine burning green hydrogen. The link I gave you goes into extreme detail on this and is based on historical data of exactly how often such windless nights occur and what the Texas grid demands overnight. It then works out the cheapest combination of solar/wind/battery/etc.
- sidewndr46 4y agoSure sounds like we need lots of storage then for those windless nights?
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> need to come with gigantic storage projects. Was what I responded to. Do you think Texas has anywhere we could store some hydrocarbons? I don't even think that report is optimistic enough, Green Hydrogen production and EVs as demand response and some grid connections will solve the issue cheaper, but I don't want to blow anyones mind, so you've got to meet them halfway with an in-depth accounting of how the vast majority of Texas energy use could be renewable with ease at a low cost.
- sidewndr46 4y agoLow cost won't cut it. It needs to be cheaper than existing technologies. Citizens don't vote for candidates with a pitch of "what we're going to do is change policy to require significant capital expenditure that is coming out of your pocket". Failing that if you can find a way to line some politicians pockets in the process, that could work.