10 ms·
Keith Davis was protecting the oceans, then he disappeared
- Waterluvian 4y agoWhat’s the fatality rate of those monitors vs. the rest of the crew?
- phantomathkg 4y agoBad I would imagine. Not only can the watchman be killed, but also slavery as well. https://thecounter.org/new-technology-helping-identify-human-rights-abuses-seafood-industry-forced-labor/ https://thecounter.org/new-technology-helping-identify-human...
- dieselgate 4y agoDang that’s sad, I’m not intimate with the industry but commercial fishing just seems like (no pun intended) a net negative on the world. I do love watching deadliest catch though
- jacknews 4y agoCommercial fishing at sea should be banned IMHO. It's unsustainable, and even if quotas could make it sustainable, they are all but unenforceable.
- lupire 4y agoAre you going to go to war with the Chinese Communist Party to stop them from fishing world seas?
- superchroma 4y agoYeah, looking that way. Biggest contributor to plastic in the ocean, directly killing it too.
- uppt 4y ago
- User23 4y agoBanning is just setting a quota of zero, which you've already agreed is effectively unenforceable. Obviously control has to be on the demand and not the supply side. Banning the sale of fish, or punitively taxing it, would be two options to make commercial fishing economically unattractive.
- ceeg 4y agoA full ban, or "a quota of zero" is much more observable and enforcable than keeping track of individuals' permits and catch limits. Not here for enabling more violence on behalf of the enforcer class, but this argument didnt make much sense to me
- jacknews 4y agoI think indoor/raceway farmed fish is the future, once we work out sustainable food sources, eg insects. I'm not sure how credible that is for marine species, but I'm sure it's possible for some, and we don't have to completely cut fish from our diets. In the meantime, I agree, we should be banning the sale/import of some species of fish.
- ars 4y agoWhy insects? Tilapia eat plants, and other fish eat tilapia.
- jacknews 4y agoThen that should work too. I think current practice is often to feed larger carnivorous fish with smaller wild-caught fish, which doesn't really solve the problem.
- jxramos 4y agoWow a vegetarian fish, I never contemplated such a thing. What kind of plants do they eat anyways?
- ars 4y ago
- ars 4y agoIt's already slowing going away anyway, being replaced by fish farms: https://ourworldindata.org/rise-of-aquaculture https://ourworldindata.org/rise-of-aquaculture I can't seem to find any source with data past 2015. Aquaculture is already cheaper than wild caught. In stores (judging by labels) wild caught is already becoming marketed as a "premium" product, with prices to match, which will reduce demand.
- philliphaydon 4y agoI would never eat Norwegian farmed salmon. Norwegian fish farming is on par with US pig farming.
- therealdrag0 4y agoMost Americans eat farmed pigs, so I guess they can eat Norwegian farmed salmon! Problem solved :)
- philliphaydon 4y agohttps://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/141028-hog-farms-waste-pollution-methane-north-carolina-environment https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/141028-ho... https://youtu.be/ayGJ1YSfDXs https://youtu.be/ayGJ1YSfDXs
- therealdrag0 4y agoI wasn’t defending it. I’m just saying (short term) converting the median eater, who doesn’t care about pig welfare, to factory farmed salmon will be easier and more environmentally impactful than trying to make them vegetarian.
- vegardx 4y agoIs it any different from other farmed fish? And what is the danger here?
- 4y ago
- dukeofdoom 4y agoOceans have been terribly overfished, but people need to eat. Many poorer countries rely on fishing to help then feed their populations. Banning commercial fishing would be like banning commercial chicken. A huge loss of a major cheap source of protein, and nothing to replace it with.
- zozbot234 4y agoCommercial chicken is not hunted in the wild, so I'm not sure how that comparison makes any sense. The oceans are already being depleted of fish in a highly unsustainable way so if you care about that protein source, shutting down large-scale fishing altogether is exactly what you should do.
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThe logistics of what you are proposing is just not there, unless you're cool with committing another man made famine like the Holodomor. I actually find it disturbing with the ease you're willing to starve the poor of the world. Ocean fishing requires very little energy input, but provides huge amounts of ready to eat food output. You can't replace that in many parts of the world. Not every place has good farm land for one, or the technological infrastructure, or even political stability. Give you and example. Egypt went from a population of 8 million to 80 million in the last century. Do you think they can grow all that food in the desert? or do they rely on fishing and on global imports of food items...like grain from Ukraine. How will the poor do when you take out one of their sources of food. While simultaneously the price of energy is sky rocketing and global trade is under threat do to conflict and as countries begin to hoard fertilizer and food for their own populations, in anticipation of the the coming winter.
- wumpus 4y ago> Ocean fishing requires very little energy input So all of those studies pointing out that most ocean fishing only happens because of subsidized fuel are wrong?
- m00x 4y agoI used to live in a lobster/crab fishing town near the Atlantic. Crab fishermen would meet First Nations people halfway to sell them the crabs that were over quota at a cheaper price since they don't have a quota, and they would sell it bootleg at the reserves. We used to go down and buy 12 lobsters for $40 when I was a kid (20 years ago). It was the best deal ever. When I left town, the fishermen started attacking First Nations boat because they realized they(FN) could just do it themselves and just cry colonizer oppression if they got caught. Crab supply got extremely scarce and the gov started cutting down licenses and lowering quotas. Many fishermen lost their 1-2M/y for 3 month of work businesses. There's still violence to this day, some FNs and some fishermen get killed every once in a while, and boats get burned.
- yieldcrv 4y agoHuh never heard the precolonial societies on the Atlantic side referred to as First Nations Does all of Canada use that terminology now? I think that term only bleeds over across the border into the US in the Pacific Northwest, since some tribes there overlap borders and have a special cross border ID that allows employment (some cross border tribes in New England but theyre just split in two)
- Beltalowda 4y ago"First nations" is the common term in Canada to refer to the people living in the area now known as Canada before Europeans arrived, similar to "Native American" in the US.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI think we’re saying the same thing, just had not confirmed it was all of Canada saying this for all pre-european civilizations within Canada.
- shafyy 4y agoThere's no sustainable amount of large scale commercial fishing. Quotas are a joke. Labels are a joke.
- jfim 4y agoHopefully the availability of fast IP networks at sea will help with observers disappearing without a trace in the future.
- rl3 4y agoPerhaps live streaming mics and cams designed to be affixed inside quarters and to one's person. Local relays designed to be hidden to facilitate both buffering and redundancy in cases of transmission difficulties due to inclement weather or tampering. The whole thing could be issued as a standard kit for a few thousand dollars. Maybe add some picture booklets for the crew explaining how fucked they are if they try anything, and include a copy of Captain Phillips for good measure. Of course, such a scheme would just increase the need for observers to have their own tamper-proof food and water rations as well. At that point, industrial "accidents" are about the only thing remaining.
- neodypsis 4y agoIs anybody here working on remote sensing applications for identifying illegal fishing?
- ryanwashburne 4y ago[dead]
- neodypsis 4y agoCosta Rica has been affected before by vessels that illegally exploit its marine resources (near the Cocos Island, particularly), as reported in a study that used remote-sensing [0]. [0] https://www-crhoy-com.translate.goog/nacionales/pesca-ilegal-de-barcos-extranjeros-golpea-isla-del-coco/?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-US https://www-crhoy-com.translate.goog/nacionales/pesca-ilegal...
- sunsunsunsun 4y agoYep, I work for and there are several companies working on this problem. I specifically work for a company creating USVs to fight the issue on the water but there are others working on solutions from the air and space.
- upwardbound 4y agoHere is some more detail about the ongoing human slavery that Keith spoke of and which phantomathkg linked to as well. https://www.ap.org/explore/seafood-from-slaves/fishing-slaves-no-more-but-freedom-brings-new-struggles.html https://www.ap.org/explore/seafood-from-slaves/fishing-slave... Fucking sad. I can't believe literal chattel slavery is this widespread. If you're considering becoming vegetarian or at least eating less meat and fish, maybe this is another reason to consider it. Either way, I hope we can find ways to crack down on abhorrent crimes like these in food supply chains.
- upwardbound 4y ago> The men left their impoverished homes years ago full of hope and headed to neighboring Thailand, promising to send money back from good-paying jobs. Instead, they were tricked, sold or even kidnapped and put onto boats that became floating prisons. They then were trafficked thousands of miles away to the isolated Indonesian island village of Benjina, where the AP first found hundreds of captive fishermen, including some locked in a cage simply because they asked to go home. They were beaten and routinely forced to work up to 22 hours a day. The unluckiest ones ended up in the sea or buried in a company graveyard under fake names — their bodies will likely never be recovered. > The AP story prompted the Indonesian government to initiate a rescue. It also traced fish tainted by forced labor back to the supply chains of many major U.S. companies and pet food brands, including Wal-Mart, Sysco, Kroger, Fancy Feast and Iams. > Once, after coming ashore, Prasert asked his captain for more money. As punishment, he says he was tossed into a tiny, muggy cell with about 20 other men. > Myint’s freshly shaved head reveals two large scars he received during his years in Indonesia. One is from a motorbike helmet, the other from an iron rod — both blows from angry fishing captains. > The memories are still raw of Myint collapsing into his wailing mother’s arms on the same dusty road just feet away from where they sit now in southern Myanmar. That day was tinged with both joy and sorrow for all the time lost — ending 22 years of separation after Myint was taken to Indonesia and nearly beaten to death by a captain who refused to let him go home.
- kurthr 4y agoBeing Shanghaied is still a thing. I wish this was TIL, unfortunately I already did. The world is a much more brutal place than many in the developed world realize.
- santimoller66 4y ago[dead]
- simplydt 4y agoTime to pass a law to force these ships to carry starlink with cctv cameras whose footage is processed by AI. Of course, although possible, this won’t happen any time soon.
- ehnto 4y agoIt isn't possible, you're talking about hundreds of countries, across international waters, and some level of complicity from various authorities. Technology can only help when it has cooperation. The human factor is often the hardest part of technology solutions.
- m00x 4y agoThis could be easily scanned by satellites, although I have no idea what's more cost-effective. It takes a long time to bring back those lines and to load up the catch.
- homonculus1 4y agoTime to pass a law to force simplydt to wear a stiff leather collar that administers a painful electric shock every 30 seconds. Of course, although possible, this won't happen any time soon.
- jwilber 4y agoOutlaw Ocean is an absolutely amazing book with chapters on different crazy occurrences in our legally-ambiguous oceans (slavery, mobile abortion ships, mercenaries, repo-men, activists , etc.) Definitely worth a read if this interests you: https://www.theoutlawocean.com/the-outlaw-ocean-by-ian-urbina/ https://www.theoutlawocean.com/the-outlaw-ocean-by-ian-urbin...
- spookierookie 4y agoSo, everybody knows that almost certainly the crew killed him, and the crew and their company and their vessel just walks? And that keeps happening... I'd propose in any subsequent event of a missing observer captain does time, ship seized, company closed and that's done even before police starting asking questions. I bet there wouldn't be any missing observer after that.
- skrebbel 4y agoI’ll never understand how passionately people will argue for a society without any form of civic justice, just because they’re angry about something they read on the internet. Just lock random people up without due process! That’ll teach them!
- spookierookie 4y agoDoes what happened seem just to you? That form of passion that you disapprove comes from failing to serve justice in the first place. Do you have any better proposal than to just keep going like this and be sorry for the observers that end up at the bottom of the sea? If yes I'm eager to hear about it. Also, unless I'm very rusty with the legal system, if you're the captain, by definition you're responsible for anyone on board. Coming back to port with anyone missing should be a HUGE problem for you. I don't get that impression here.
- FpUser 4y ago>"Coming back to port with anyone missing should be a HUGE problem for you." After proving ( in the court of law) that it was because captain's neglect. If sailor A kills sailor B just for the fuck of it (and this happens or the true reason might be unknown) do you propose preventively punish a captain before establishing causation and guilt? And most of injustice happens because our laws are constructed in fucked up ways and almost never punish politicians that are the ultimate reasons for such system. The example - asymmetric laws when it is easy to declare person dead by mistake with all the consequences and then it takes years for a person to get their rights back. And many other laws are like this. You want justice - go after politicians first. Here is the idea - if any person is harmed as the result of such asymmetric laws every politician immediately gets 10% salary cut until the law is fixed. Suddenly you'll find politicians busy doing nothing but fixing law system. This of course will be a problem on its own.