3 ms·
I've had to use Slack for a while, but never wanted to delete any messages --- or even edit them. On the contrary, I find it immensely irritating when others ch
by userbinator 4y ago
I've had to use Slack for a while, but never wanted to delete any messages --- or even edit them. On the contrary, I find it immensely irritating when others change/delete their messages, especially when I'm in the middle of reading them and writing a reply. However, instead of patching the official client, I just wrote (a read-only) one that uses their API to simply log all the messages/events that occur.
I wonder if it's a difference in culture/expectations. For me, once a message is sent, I expect it to be immutable, much like basically all forms of communication have been in the past. Email, IRC, etc. all work like that. If I intend to amend or otherwise change it, I'll simply send another one or use "correction asterisks". To do otherwise feels like a taboo, almost like trying to rewrite history.
Edit: seriously, immediate downvotes? What nerve did I strike this time...?
- projektfu 4y agoI think that I have that general approach to things that are relevant but it's nice to delete irrelevant messages. Not sure how often it happens in slack, but us senile 40-somethings type "Love you baby, have a great day!" into the wrong chat all the time. That, and phone numbers, search phrases, reminders. Sometimes it's better to just unclutter the thread.
- gsk22 4y ago> On the contrary, I find it immensely irritating when others change/delete their messages And yet, you edited your comment. How irritating :)
- userbinator 4y agoAnd yet, you edited your comment. How irritating :) ...with an appendix, without changing what I had previously written. But I suppose that's another difference; it seems that editing is far more acceptable on forums and the like, unlike IM.
- Nimitz14 4y agoYour opinion is just bizarre, as if editing chat messages to improve clarity is somehow a negative. Chat is not email. The point of chat is that it's fast and often a half-baked message is good enough.