4 ms·
That's really frustrating. I'm currently selling power on to the grid, but it's capped at the rate my solar panels produce, probably by policy. So, even if I
by hedora 4y ago
That's really frustrating. I'm currently selling power on to the grid, but it's capped at the rate my solar panels produce, probably by policy. So, even if I was eligible for this rate, it wouldn't give me any meangful credit.
They need a rate that is proportional to marginal carbon emissions. Then, I could set my battery to that. It could look at the forecast for tomorrow, and make a killing by doing the obvious thing.
Grr. The legislation around here is decades behind the technology.
- tims33 4y agoSafe to assume you’re getting net meetering? That is likely more valuable.
- hedora 4y agoI am, but I could make $40-60 in the next few hours by dumping the batteries' charge into the grid in the next three hours. That's much less than what I'd get normally. Basically, I want net metering to be proportional to carbon (and therefore peaker plant use). It's less about the amount of money I get back. In related news, my batteries aggressively charge themselves during the morning CO2 peak because power is cheap then. They should sell solar production into the grid during those hours and start charging at ~ 10 am.
- tims33 4y agoI love net metering, but long term it isn’t an entirely fair system. I imagine once they move off of that they’ll be able to have better incentives for those on solar with batteries.
- colechristensen 4y agoThe cost structure for power lines and grid connection doesn’t really reflect the added feature of net metering. Some jurisdictions give you a much better deal than they ought to, some much worse. It probably won’t stabilize into something more reasonable until people who both use and produce power are much more common.
- colechristensen 4y agoDo peaker plants produce any more carbon? I thought a small amount less because theyre usually natural gas. The problem with peaker plants is it’s expensive keeping them around when they only operate for a short time, and bigger peaks mean more capacity needed.
- hedora 4y agoIn California they do, since we have hardly any coal plants.
- colechristensen 4y agoMore than what?
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>Basically, I want net metering to be proportional to carbon (and therefore peaker plant use). It's less about the amount of money I get back. Maybe I don't understand. Then you would receive very little compensation for the useless solar you send to the grid at mid day and pay very high prices for any power you use from the grid at night.
- hedora 4y agoI'm OK with them not paying for the useless power that I dump on the grid at noon. I have 12-24 hours of battery backup, so I can get through the night on it. Plus, they should pay more for peak usage hours (4-9pm and 6-10am) than they charge over night (the overnight power produces less than 70% as much carbon as peak power in the morning and evening), so I'd still end up selling back at a profit vs. storing electricity for my own use. Also, the cost minimizer in the battery would then charge the battery at noon, when electricity is worthless (unlike what it does now). I want to set the battery to "minimize atmospheric CO2". The details of my power bill are rounding errors vs. the ongoing damages I am already incurring from climate change.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoCan you find a single day in the CAISO records where the net grid demand (so not including home solar, grid solar or grid wind) is below the amount produced by their nuclear and hydro? If you can't, and I don't think you can, why do you claim his solar is useless? I'd guess a early-spring/ late-fall weekend might be the best place to find such a day. (Weirdly, just checking this myself and his complaint that the battery charges at 9am seems to actually be the best time for a battery to charge as net demand is lowest then) There's been lots of headlines over the last few years about negative prices and too much solar, but any time I checked, they generally still have fossil generation running. Here's some modelling suggesting 120 Billion saving from distributed solar and batteries: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5f4637895cfc8d77860d0dbc/t/60fb265c64858d2713dea3b3/1627072097936/California+Local+Solar+Roadmap+final+2.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5f4637895cfc8d77860d0...
- s1artibartfast 4y ago
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoPeople often claim that, because they like to portray net metering as a pointless subsidy for rich folks, but I'd say in California it's probably short changing the benefit of solar/batteries to the grid. Value of solar tariffs that work this out in detail get pushback from grid operators for being too high, same as net metering. It's almost as if they don't like paying a fair rate for energy and their excuses are exactly that.
- xyzzyz 4y agoHow much are you selling for? What’s the price? How is it determined?
- hedora 4y agoMy power bill is opaque, but its something like buy/sell for $0.31 per kWh off peak and $0.39 on peak. Peak is 4-10pm. I have no idea how it is determined.
- xyzzyz 4y agoSo you're already heavily subsidized by legislation. Power plant operators sell electricity for something like $0.05/kWh on average, which is 15-20% of what you're getting for it. They'd love to be able to sell it for $.30/kWh. The power company also would love to not have to lose a whole lot of money on buying extremely expensive electricity from you. Nevertheless, you're the one getting a sweet deal here, and you need to thank legislators for subsidizing people who can afford to install residential solar.
- hedora 4y agoI'm not complaining about the free money that they send me. I'm complaining because they set the incentives wrong, and the incentives control the (closed source) battery software's policy. Therefore, the equipment I bought is offsetting way less carbon than it could. Now, multiply that waste by the number of home batteries in California.
- sand500 4y agoThat's interesting. Is it because the wires into your house cannot safely take it if you dump your batteries's contents in a few hours.
- bombcar 4y agoIf your house is rated for 200 amps in, you can deliver 200 amps to the grid. If setup correctly you could possibly deliver 200 amps to the grid whilst also consuming 200 amps yourself.
- hedora 4y ago30kWh / 3 hours is 10kWh per hour, or 10 kW. 10kW at 240V is 41 amps. Our connection to the grid is hundreds of amps. There are two reasons I can't do it: This is a Tesla pilot, and it is not a Tesla system. More fundamentally, this is a weird emergency response program. They should just set the rate structure so that people always have a financial incentive to minimize CO2 and also stabilize the grid. The rate structure does neither of those things, so we end up with lots of idling home batteries during peak demand events like the current one. On normal days, the batteries idle while peaker plants uselessly spew CO2.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.tesla.com/support/energy/tesla-virtual-power-plant-pge-2022 https://www.tesla.com/support/energy/tesla-virtual-power-pla... (Have to be in PGE territory I believe unfortunately)