3 ms·
I actually enjoy gruber's posts most of the time, but this article is incredibly stupid, for exactly the reasons he posts about. If you include the iPad number
by notatoad 15y ago
I actually enjoy gruber's posts most of the time, but this article is incredibly stupid, for exactly the reasons he posts about. If you include the iPad numbers, the numbers for all other tablets become meaninglessly small. So if you want to write an article about the number two tablets, the only way to do it is to exclude the ipad. The article isn't about how successful the iPad is, no matter how desperately John wants to be reminded of that.
- mechanical_fish 15y agoAs John points out, this analysis also excludes the Nook. if you want to write an article about the number two tablets, the only way to do it is to exclude the ipad. Not at all. You can show, and write, exactly what you just said one sentence earlier: "The iPad has 90% market share, and the other companies split the remaining 10%, with five companies each taking 1 to 2 percent of the market." What about that is so difficult for mortals to understand? Even if you never mention Apple more than once, it's important, when (e.g.) pointing to the fact that HP has almost twice the share of unit sales as Motorola, to recognize that you're comparing a 2% share with a 1% share, not a 20% share with a 10% share. There's a big difference between 1% and 10%, both qualitative and quantitative. For example: Smaller numbers are closer to the noise level, and therefore more subject to fluctuation. 1% could really be 2%, and could easily jump to 2% in the next quarter, but it's unlikely that 10% is really 20%. And, lo and behold, this turns out to be relevant to this very case, because in fact HP's numbers have probably been goosed by a one-time money-losing giveaway of Touchpads. That's a fluctuation.
- notatoad 15y agoThe analysis excludes the nook because it is an e reader, not a tablet. And yes, that matters. We talk about tablets because they are a platform for third party stuff to run on, nook is not a platform for anybody but B&N. "Why is this so hard for mortals to understand" No need to be an asshole
- dereg 15y agoDo you understand the audience for these NPD reports? NPD releases their research to paying (usually corporate) customers. The press release is a small portion of what's actually in the reports. Furthermore, don't you think a financial analyst would already know Apple's numbers? The target audience is not some Kid Biz article. Just saying.
- jamesrom 15y agoThe only point that Gruber disagrees with is the contention that PC manufacturers are dominant in the tablet space.
- A-K 15y agoWhich I think is the article's salient point. I can see how some might think otherwise if they didn't bother to read all the way till the end.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoThis might be true if the phrase "pc manufacturers are dominant in the tablet space" weren't included in the report.
- idspispopd 15y ago"but this[gruber's] article is incredibly stupid, for exactly the reasons he posts about" Gruber's article is a counterpoint on "PC manufacturers are dominant in the tablet space", and the idea that NPD were incorrectly attributing the "number 2" player to HP. Naturally the iPad comes into discussion (and yes it's smart to remove the iPad when trying to look at the rest of the market.) However NPD were publishing conclusions that aren't reasonable in light of the fact that the Kindle Fire and B&N Nook are selling very well in addition to the dominance of the iPad. By some reputable estimates the Nook is selling well in excess of HP. (To the tone of 15x the sales of HP.)