5 ms·
I feel like we need a better metric to use when something "kills" people. When heat waves kill people, the vast majority of the time it means these people alrea
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
I feel like we need a better metric to use when something "kills" people. When heat waves kill people, the vast majority of the time it means these people already had major health problems that (a) let the heat do more damage and (b) prevented the person from seeking help in the first place. To be clear, I'm not saying that heat wasn't the final cause, but I think it's a fair assumption that most of these people didn't have much healthy life ahead of them regardless.
Compare that to, say, a tornado that wipes out a family with 2 young kids and 2 middle-aged adults. That to me feels orders of magnitude worse, both in the violent manner of death, and the fact that these people had years and years of healthy life left.
And, to hopefully kill this anticipated straw man, I am not making the assertion that "it's no big deal" if elderly or sick people die. I am only commenting on the comparison to other forms of death, and arguing that I think it's fair to think those other forms are death are much worse if you look beyond just "number of people killed".
- robertn702 4y agoWe do have a better metric. It’s “years of life lost” (YLL) and it is a commonly used metric for the exact reasons you mentioned. My guess as to why you rarely see it being used outside of the scientific community is because “number of deaths” drives more clicks. https://www.who.int/data/gho/indicator-metadata-registry/imr-details/159 https://www.who.int/data/gho/indicator-metadata-registry/imr...
- umvi 4y agoI remember COVID deaths being compared to WW2 deaths by the media a few years ago. If YLL were used instead I think (but don't know for certain) that WW2 would be much more egregious.
- watwut 4y agoWW2 happened to kill significantly more civilians then soldiers. And among those, old, sick, poor and weak died the most. Babies and small kids too, so it is not entirely clear how exactly it would cut.
- bombcar 4y agoThe majority of covid deaths would be toward the elderly range. Almost every soldier death would be 18-25. I suspect the civilian would lean older but I don’t think it would entirely offset it.
- t0bia_s 4y agoYou would be surprised, but most of those 6 millions that died in concentration camps was not soldiers.
- watwut 4y ago> Almost every soldier death would be 18-25. Absolutely not true. The age at which countries recruited were up to 45 normally (united states) or even 60 (Germany UK) and in Germany every able bodied male eventually ended in some kind of unit - if only home defense. Starting with 14 actually. The ration of civilians to soldiers killed is 3:2 to 2:1.
- bombcar 4y agoBritish average was 27in ww 1. I was off by a few years. http://wp.lancs.ac.uk/greatwar/ages-of-the-dead/ http://wp.lancs.ac.uk/greatwar/ages-of-the-dead/ Certainly lower than 55+, though ww2 could be moderately higher than 27 I doubt it.
- watwut 4y agoAverage being 27 and almost all being in 18-25 range are massively different statements. The civilian to soldier death ration in wwi was different. The civilians were not directly targeted the way they were in wwii. The ideologization was lower and population itself was not the enemy the way it was in wwii. Also, both Amrica and UK sent soldiers away to fight. UK was bombed, but did not had large displacement of population or ethnic cleansing or retaliation for those going on in their territories. Modern wars kill more civilians then soldiers.
- dasudasu 4y ago
- serial_dev 4y agoOne more, pretty sad, reason that extremely hot and extremely cold weather don't get that much attention that (at least my assumption) it mainly kills the poor, whereas hurricanes and tornadoes do not "discriminate" based on income to that extent. If you and your family are well off, you can be reasonably sure that hot or cold weather will not affect you so dramatically.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s like any other risk management problem. We’re wired to respond to a crisis that comes upon us. Most city fire departments try to target a 5-10m response time to a fairly rare event. We’re not good at responding to longer term or complex cause and effect issues.