3 ms·
> BEV vehicles are 5x more efficient than ICE vehicles. I've seen this figure before. It ignores the efficiency of the generation of electric power to charge t
by WalterBright 4y ago
> BEV vehicles are 5x more efficient than ICE vehicles.
I've seen this figure before. It ignores the efficiency of the generation of electric power to charge the EV.
A much more realistic figure is 2x.
- stefan_ 4y agoWhich then ignores the efficiency of the generation of gasoline, which takes lots of energy input to refine it into the form useful for ICE vehicles.. You can play this game all day long, depending on which figure you want to land on. Efficiency is nice but the reason it hasn't mattered at all is that it is more about what is readily available and cheaply exploited.
- WalterBright 4y agoMy google doctorate says that energy efficiency of refining is 90%. And you ignored the energy efficiency of mining coal. > You can play this game all day long And you should, to be serious about CO2 emissions reduction. Otherwise, we're all just fooling ourselves.
- CraigJPerry 4y agoBut only around 30% of the refined fuel’s energy transfers into useful work done with the ICE vehicle. If the BEV is running with their 2kw heating turned up full blast in addition to running down the road, and there was a heat loss of around 2-5% while charging the car then We’re still at around 3x more efficient in the BEV vs the ICE. Then there’s the electricity supply which ranges from 0 refinement loss and 50% thermal efficiency (natural gas fired power plant) to NaN% for nuclear, wind and solar. A BEV charging right this minute in the UK is consuming energy originating from 25% gas, 25% nuclear, 25% wind, 5% solar (its 6:30pm). It could be more than 5x when you compare with ICE fuel supply / refinement / storage / delivery.
- WalterBright 4y ago> But only around 30% of the refined fuel’s energy transfers into useful work done with the ICE vehicle. Right. Now factor in the losses in thermodynamic electric power generation to fuel the EV. > We’re still at around 3x more efficient in the BEV vs the ICE. Don't neglect the losses from generating that electricity, which is about 70%.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoIt's 10% or less for solar, wind, nuclear, etc...
- CraigJPerry 4y ago>> Don't neglect the losses from generating that electricity, which is about 70% What? There’s 70% loss in the process of generating electricity? Where does that occur?
- WalterBright 4y agoThermodynamic efficiency. Google says coal electric power generation is 33% efficient.
- CraigJPerry 4y agoBEV’s run on coal power?
- josephcsible 4y agoThere's no magical barrier in the electrical grid that prevents charging BEVs from coal-fired power plants.
- CraigJPerry 4y agoParent is alleging 100% supply from coal since they claim there’s 70% thermal loss in the charging of BEVs Coal is circa 20% of the supply in the US. About the same as nuclear or renewables.
- CraigJPerry 4y ago>> A much more realistic figure is 2x That sounds well off. How much energy is required to refine fuel suitable for use in an ICE vehicle? Gas and oil fired power plants use a far less refined fuel. How much energy is required to get the fuel to the vehicle? Gas and oil plants are usually connected via high efficiency transport mechanisms like pipelines rather than ships or road transport. Vehicle engines are only in the region of 20-35% thermal efficiency but the average across all gas fired plants in the uk is 50% and drops to 42% for oil fired. I don’t know for sure but only 2x smells to me.
- WalterBright 4y agoSee my other reply.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWhat other reply? You talk about refining. There's 10% lost in refining. X% lost in extraction and Y% lost in transmission (shipping, pipes, etc). Solar => Grid => Car Battery is less than 10% lost usually. Obviously it can vary a lot - so can oil extraction, shipping and refining... This means Solar => Grid => Car battery is >5x as efficient as Oil in ground => Pipes => Refinery => Pipes => Gas Station => Car. Once the energy is in the car, we know the BEV is 5x more efficient. We also know Solar => Car is SUBSTANTIALLY more efficient at transferring BTUs into the car than the gasoline infrastructure. In reality, it's probably closer to 10x as efficient than 2x.
- WalterBright 4y agoSolar and wind have so far not been nearly adequate to charge existing EVs, let alone what would be necessary if we all converted to EVs. Given the reluctance to expand nuclear power, we're going to be charging EVs with fossil fuels for a long time.
- CraigJPerry 4y ago>> we're going to be charging EVs with fossil fuels for a long time Even if you never used wind, solar, nuclear, hydro, etc. then you’d still be ahead in the BEV case. An oil power plant has around 42% thermal efficiency. A gas one 50%+ an ICE is only up to 35% but in the US it’s significantly lower on average. Neither of which have tailpipe emissions in populated areas unlike ICE. But we do also use wind, solar, nuclear etc as power sources for BEV.
- zbrozek 4y agoThat's about right from my arithmetic, assuming you charge from a fossil fuel grid. I charge from onsite solar. Still, 2x is a big improvement.
- adrianN 4y agoYou can either pump a kWh of oil out of the ground, or you can collect a kWh of solar energy with a PV panel.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoBeing EXTREMELY generous to gasoline and ICE - and realistic that most BEVs aren't charging using 0% fossil fuels - you can get to 3.14x. To get to 2x, you'll need to assume the average BEV is substantially less efficient than a Tesla - that all gasoline is refined at the most efficient refinery - that all ICE cars get Prius mileage - that it takes 0 energy to extract and transmit / ship oil - and probably that the majority of your electricity is coming from coal.