4 ms·
I have to be the voice of unpopular opinion here, and say that the reasoning behind the sentiment "It's only a tool. The tool can be used in a bad way, but that
by ghusto 4y ago
I have to be the voice of unpopular opinion here, and say that the reasoning behind the sentiment "It's only a tool. The tool can be used in a bad way, but that doesn't make the tool a bad thing", glosses over some nuance which would otherwise make it suspect reasoning.
A hammer is a tool. You can use a hammer to kill somebody so effectively, that you could argue to an alien who knows nothing of hammers, that they're actually murder weapons. That doesn't make hammers inherently bad.
An Airtag is also a tool, but it is different in an important way for this comparison; it works by using the internet, thereby providing one degree of separation from the user and the victim. This single degree of separation has an important psychological effect on the user; that of a false sense of security.
Some proof of this, is the fact that people continue to use Airtags for stalking, despite the fact that they know they can be caught easily. It's a psychological safety that they allow to trick themselves with, rooted in how we work as human beings; "physical things are real, screens and ephemeral things aren't".
So yes, the Airtag is also a tool, but it's likelihood to be used by people (so inclined) for stalking, is higher than somebody using a physical object inappropriately (and illegally).
- mgoetzke 4y agoThe likelihood of them being removed from the stalker pool is also higher.
- mschuster91 4y agoAssuming that the cops recognize the danger and actually do their goddamn job. Unfortunately, many cops barely know how to operate a computer, way too many outright disregard cases where women are the victims (just look at the various rape kit backlog scandals to see how little the cops care), or have the knowledge on how to correctly request data from Apple, Samsung, Tile or whomever, and then how to use these data to get to the identity of the stalker. On top of that, way too many people reflexively remove the AirTag or whatever tracker on their own - the correct way is to call the police which can at least use a sealed evidence bag so that fingerprints and DNA remains aren't compromised.
- yieldcrv 4y agoOk but use per capita is more important to sway me