3 ms·
> net benefit of such projects to the society If by “net benefits” you mean “helps in many cases but sacrifices a few people due to false positives”, then I se
by z9znz 4y ago
> net benefit of such projects to the society
If by “net benefits” you mean “helps in many cases but sacrifices a few people due to false positives”, then I see your point.
But you never really said why the author was wrong. You just expanded your critique of the author himself.
The author has valid concerns, and one doesn’t need to be an AI researcher to know that content analysis AI is woefully unreliable thus far. We see examples nearly every day here on HN where these systems (often Google’s or YouTube’s) have made wrong judgements that defy explanation.
- deltree7 4y agoYou don't have proof that AI is woefully unreliable, especially the ones used by the Isreal government
- z9znz 4y agoThis topic was about Google providing AI logistics. There is ample evidence of Google's AI of flagging false positives.
- deltree7 4y agoOnce again you have zero access to the AI that was provided to Israel Government, just like you have zero access to Google's AlphaGo or AlphaFold or Imagen to make a judgement
- jjulius 4y ago... as do you. Yet you seem convinced - dead certain - that the author is wrong, to the point that you're a bit belligerent. What happened to that "complex, nuanced" discussion that you referred to? Step back and breathe before posting.