3 ms·
First of all, homosexual and trans people don't require the same amount of dedication from their parents to live a half-way decent life as children with Downs s
by tsimionescu 4y ago
First of all, homosexual and trans people don't require the same amount of dedication from their parents to live a half-way decent life as children with Downs syndrome do. In fact, homosexual people don't require any extra care, and trans people barely more than that (depending on access to free Healthcare).
Second of all, there just isn't, and can't be, a right to be born. The hypothetical person who would turn out of if a fertilized egg is carried to term has no innate rights until they actually do get born (or, well, somewhere near - not trying to justify late term abortions or anything). At least, this is the case if you believe a right to voluntary abortion should exist at all.
Theoretically, I don't see anything unethical about aborting a fetus with some hypothetical gay gene, nor do I see anything unethical about aborting a fetus with a gene for black hair instead of blond.
In practice though, assuming the screening is not happening very early in the pregnancy, it would seem strange for expecting parents to throw away their excitement after a month of pregnancy because of such shallow reasons. I don't think the same strangeness applies though for more life-impacting conditions, like Down syndrome (or like severe non-verbal autism, if it could be screened for).
The fact that the born child would be a precious life that no one would have the right to attack or judge for their illnesses in no way reflects back in time to before they were a child.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> First of all, homosexual and trans people don't require the same amount of dedication from their parents to live a half-way decent life as children with Downs syndrome do. In fact, homosexual people don't require any extra care, and trans people barely more than that (depending on access to free Healthcare). This is all pretty subjective and arbitrary. Are you saying it's just a matter of degree, and if it happens to be the case for one set of "experts" or bureaucrats then fine. What happens when the next set decide a different group of undesirables is over the line? What I'm saying has nothing to do with a right to be born, or an individual's right to personally make choices about their own reproductive and medical issues. It is purely about a state eugenics campaign to systematically eliminate undesirable classes of people from society.
- tsimionescu 4y agoIf you don't believe individuals have a right to be born, then what is wrong with a state eugenics program, as long as it is not coercive or manipulative (that is, as long as it is done with the free consent of the parents)? We can probably all agree that screening for certain high-fatality conditions and terminating the pregnancy if they are found is generally better - say, Tay-Sachs disease. We can also agree that screening for other genetic traits and terminating the pregnancy if they are found is unnecessary at best and harmful to society at worst - say, aborting all female genotype fetuses. Between such extremes lies the realm of the subjective and the messy, where some will agree and some won't. A democratic state may morally/ethically encourage or discourage opinions on these matters, ideally based on the best outcomes for all its citizens.
- throwawaylinux 4y ago> If you don't believe individuals have a right to be born, I didn't say I believe it or not. This isn't going to be some gotcha about my beliefs, I was explaining to the OP why this kind of thing is controversial. > what is wrong with a state eugenics program, as long as it is not coercive or manipulative (that is, as long as it is done with the free consent of the parents)? Well coercive or manipulative are not black-and-white, and there is concern that the line is over stepped. But leaving that aside, I go back to my first post. Would you have any concerns with a government eugenics program to eliminate trans people from society using genetic screening and abortion counseling informing expectant parents about the horrible disadvantage, discrimination, and horrific physical and mental suffering that they go through at extremely high rates, and assuring them that abortions are a good treatment? You skipped the question really. It's not where exactly you draw the line with disadvantage and difficulty, and it's not about an individual making their own personal choices. I'm asking about a government eugenics program with such a goal. Well I don't want this to be a gotcha about your beliefs either, so I don't really need you to answer, the question is more to get people thinking about why the whole issue is not as simple as it seems.
- tsimionescu 4y ago