2 ms·
I mostly agree with your rules of thumb, but an incremental spelling reform should also (1) not leave native speakers guessing as to what you're trying to say,
by zozbot234 4y ago
I mostly agree with your rules of thumb, but an incremental spelling reform should also (1) not leave native speakers guessing as to what you're trying to say, and (2) preserve morphological relationships as far as practical. So wrt. your examples of reformed spellings, I think I'd prefer *givve (compare gave, given etc.) and *menye - which is even an attested spelling, if only in Middle English. (The -ye ending is a bit weird, but is arguably the best fit for the final /i/ in /'mɛni/. -y and -ie just seem too confusing.)