7 ms·
This is an intriguing idea, possibly much more convenient and ergonomic for productivity than a fully fledged VR headset. But the fact that these are 1080p int
by crazygringo 4y ago
This is an intriguing idea, possibly much more convenient and ergonomic for productivity than a fully fledged VR headset.
But the fact that these are 1080p internal displays suggests it's a "fixed" 1080p screen that moves with your head, not a "virtual" screen that appears to stay in place as you move your head.
Does anyone here have any experience with how usable that is? When I start up my Oculus Quest 2 and it has the fixed startup screen logo before it switches to head-tracking mode, it's rather disorienting, since visual cues are totally mismatched with my sense of balance.
I'm not sure whether I could get used to a big screen "tethered" to my head angle like that, or if you get used to it?
Also I wonder about the brightness here -- the Quest 2 isn't very bright at all, but it's OK since virtually all surrounding light is blocked out and my eyes adjust. Whereas this device is basically large sunglasses that lets in tons of surrounding light -- does the screen brightness compete?
- gokuldas011011 4y ago> But the fact that these are 1080p internal displays suggests it's a "fixed" 1080p screen that moves with your head, not a "virtual" screen that appears to stay in place as you move your head. Check [nimo](https://www.nimoplanet.com/ https://www.nimoplanet.com/), a start-up working in the same segment, i've tried on their product and it does have a virtual screen fixed to position and it allows upto six 1080p. screens at a time pinned at any angle.
- rwxsh 4y agoI have the Avegant Glyph, which is fixed, and I it is uncomfortable. It's natural to move your head to change your view, but that doesn't work with these devices. In practice I use a Quest instead, but even Daydream was more comfortable for media consumption.
- gfodor 4y agoI would be surprised if it’s fixed - gyro based head tracking is very well established tech now. It’s probably 3dof tracking. (So no translation, just rotation.) the Oculus GearVR and Oculus Go took this approach which works fine for most people for sit and watch theater use cases. Edit: oh, yeah so I think you’re referring to 3dof. I could imagine these being fully tracked but thought you were suggesting entirely untracked.
- crazygringo 4y agoThese do suggest being entirely untracked from the specs. Otherwise the 1080p internal OLED, if tracked, would result in a usable effective virtual screen resolution of more like 320x240, unusable for much of anything. Since the field of view would need to be significantly wider than the virtual screen to avoid clipping, and then there's effective resolution loss from resampling during virtual screen placement on top of that.
- Someone 4y agoIf the tech allows making the display see-through on a per pixel basis, they could simulate seeing the full display as a monitor hanging a meter before your eyes. Turn your head, and the virtual monitor would move out of view, with the outside world showing up.
- gfodor 4y agoIf it’s untracked entirely it’s garbage and rather shocking a company would release it.
- Maursault 4y ago> This is an intriguing idea It is an obvious idea. AR/VR is hard. Dumb displays are not. I think we should have had similar products a decade ago, and if I'm not mistaken, these exist in cheaper SD versions from noname manufacturers. That said, I want this, and not Meta's thing or whatever Apple is cooking up, because I knew ahead of time that no one is going to get the VR part right initially. They are barking up the wrong tree, because as far as I know, no developer is paying attention to proprioception. From what I can tell, they're focused on the eyes only, and proprioception is essential for VR. AR is different, maybe they're getting that right. I'm just not interested in AR. It's great for a futuristic technology in a film, but in practice, it seems silly to me. But I don't know everything, hardly anything, really. What is the metric called that is the distance to where the display appears to be? It is not focal length, and I need really a word for what that is called. If the display appears to be, say, 10' away, I probably don't want it. It would be awesome if this apparent distance was adjustable. I am near sighted, hate contacts and correctable lenses cause me migraine. Thus, I prefer to view displays quite close, no more than 2', or to appear no more than 2' away when it is actually much closer to the eye and using a magnifying lens. Pads have worked well for me for consuming media because I can hold at the right (close) distance for comfort. Really hope I get what I want, have wanted it for about 25 years and been confused why HMDs had only mostly been used for military purposes, for insane prices. It is about time someone has ignored the difficult to get right AR/VR tech, and just gave us a high quality, personal, wearable display.
- kfarr 4y agoYeah these have been around for almost a decade as cheap VR knockoffs for the unsuspecting, albeit I haven't seen the direct USB c output option before. Not until you take it home and turn it on do you realize the resolution of 1080p strapped to your eyes is a pixelated mess and the lack of even basic 3DOF makes these things uncomfortable for most people.
- Maursault 4y ago> Not until you take it home and turn it on do you realize the resolution of 1080p strapped to your eyes is a pixelated mess Well, that sucks. Thanks for the clue to never purchase without a personal demonstration. I figured SD would be like that, but really hoped that 1080p would be satisfactory. But doesn't this depend on pixel density? If the displays approach the pixel density of displays of high end smartphones, I'd probably be satisfied with that. Even though those pixels can be seen (at 10x magnification), at high enough pixel density, pixels can be ignored when focusing on the video content. I used to sit really close to CRT televisions, which have huge pixels, so there is bound to be some improvement from the way it was in the dark ages.
- trafficante 4y ago>When I start up my Oculus Quest 2 and it has the fixed startup screen logo before it switches to head-tracking mode, it's rather disorienting, since visual cues are totally mismatched with my sense of balance. Since you already have a Quest, you might be able to approximate the fixed AR experience using a media player and a 1080p video file. Moon VR[1] is free and has a passthrough mode to overlay the video on your external surroundings. I haven’t personally used it but I’d be surprised if it doesn’t have a head-lock option for making the video track your head (if it doesn’t, Skybox VR does, but it’s a paid app) - in theory this should be fairly close to the Lenovo glasses experience only much heavier and with a grainy B&W passthrough. [1]https://www.oculus.com/experiences/quest/4304774742883035 https://www.oculus.com/experiences/quest/4304774742883035
- lukeschlather 4y agoTrying to move around while you've got a screen like that active in a VR headset is a bad idea, but I love watching Netflix VR like that. Just find a comfortable position and chill.
- mungoman2 4y agoIn a random video on YouTube the demonstrator person says that the screen can be fixed in virtual space, so that you can look away from it. https://youtu.be/6uOoS2EF4CI https://youtu.be/6uOoS2EF4CI
- Duralias 4y agoWell, all they would need is a gyro (because it doesn't seem to have cameras), it wouldn't be as good 6dof, but better than fixed.
- Closi 4y agoIt would need more than a gyro - if it's fixed in space the optics are very different and much simpler, and the required screen resolution is completely different.
- jefftk 4y agoYou can do it with just a gyro, if it's sufficiently large: by fixing the user's head in space you don't need any sort of position tracking.
- fsiefken 4y agoYes I walked around with a 640x480 monocular display tethered to a compactflash card in my toshibia e750 pda with usb host controller, around 20 years ago. Of course I didn't do desktop work with it, but I looked up offline wikipedia entries (in tr3/tomeraider3 format), read books, watched slideshows and played interactive fiction. I could do that lying on my bed or sitting in public transport. The only problem was that when I was walking I noticed that I was walking in a sinus wave. I never noticed that as I never had something to read so close attached to my eyes . The problem with this is that my right eye clear real world vision merged with the left eye 640x480 display vision creating an transparency effect on the virtual window. So in essence when I was moving I struggled to read the sentences on a moving background. If it was sideways it would be less of a problem, but it was up and down. Obviously you don't have that problem on a bike, but then it could be dangerous. But sitting and worknig should be ok, it would just take a little bit getting used to, but I guess it would a bit be less ideal then a fixed in space desktop like with the Oculus or Hololens. For brightness, I used it in broad daylight, I could still see the virtual screen brightly. Some time later I did the same with a eMagin800 HMD which had a 800x600 screen for the left and a 800x600 for the right. I used that for winamp stereoscopic visualisation. So for these types of applications it's for sure great.
- NonNefarious 4y agoThis product has essentially existed for years: https://moverio.epson.com https://moverio.epson.com They're about $1000 and show the potential of this indeed seemingly obvious product. They do suffer from a lack of sufficient fit adjustment, and the image should be larger. I don't know why almost no one has explored this product category. One company stands above all others in failing to see the potential: DJI. Not only has DJI failed to put HDMI inputs on its FPV goggles, but it has released a string of drones that aren't compatible with them. Yes, most DJI drones are not compatible with THEIR OWN GOGGLES, despite having wireless video transmission that allegedly uses the same protocol.