3 ms·
> [A school teacher] told me, "I find this idea offensive—that kids who come from poverty areas need a more structured and disciplined approach to learning than
by zozbot234 4y ago
> [A school teacher] told me, "I find this idea offensive—that kids who come from poverty areas need a more structured and disciplined approach to learning than middle-class kids do. They may need more time on the decoding skills. But why shouldn’t they be exposed to the same kind of enjoyment about reading as other kids?"
You find this kind of attitude across many subjects, not just basic literacy and it's always been quite puzzling. My own guess is that the idea of "structured and disciplined" teaching is a lot more offensive to teachers than students at the proper level. In fact, it can introduce a sort of enjoyable 'gamification' to the task of building up competence in any skill.
- GavinMcG 4y agoThat quote doesn’t oppose structure and discipline. It opposes focusing on it rather than focusing on particular needs, when it comes to teaching students with a lower existing degree of skill.
- zozbot234 4y ago> That quote doesn’t oppose structure and discipline. Of course it does, that's what the teacher is claiming. Expressly endorsing a less-structured approach, hoping that it will boost enjoyment among students who have yet to develop the basic skills of literacy. Even though the exact opposite is in fact more likely, with students being frustrated by an overly obscure, everything-goes approach.
- GavinMcG 4y agoWhere are you finding “overly obscure, everything goes”? Saying “I oppose X as a solution to a particular problem” isn’t the same as opposing X.
- funstuff007 4y ago
- polygamous_bat 4y agoYou do understand that for most IDs you have to pay some money? So how is what you are proposing not a poll tax? The way this could ever be equitably implemented is with probably a decade long push for a sensible national id project that is free for everyone, but generally I've not seen proponents of this idea be willing to do the legwork that's necessary to get this to work.
- funstuff007 4y ago> So how is what you are proposing not a poll tax? It's not a poll tax because in the post 9/11 age / post pandemic age, you need an ID to do most anything. In NYS, the driver's license fee can be as low as $6.50.
- sophacles 4y agoWhere in the constitution does it say a poll tax under a certain value is OK? Where does it define a minimum value to be considered a tax? Where does it say "some things requiring ID is an exception to poll taxes?" The government requiring money to be paid in order to vote is in fact a poll tax.
- baremetal 4y agoso then subsidize government id's. still should have to show id to vote.
- kevingadd 4y agoThe kind of voter fraud that would be stopped by ID checks is a fantasy. Now you're proposing the rollout of an expensive nationwide government program to stop something that basically doesn't exist? I'll link this random source here, but there are dozens of them out there. There is no evidence to support any claim of widespread voter fraud that would merit the introduction of a poll tax or a nationwide free ID program + combined ID requirement. https://www.brennancenter.org/issues/ensure-every-american-can-vote/vote-suppression/myth-voter-fraud https://www.brennancenter.org/issues/ensure-every-american-c... Your proposal also ignores the fact that in some cases getting an ID is very complex and expensive - some people don't have birth certificates, for example, and getting one printed requires going to a specific location and paying a fee. Sometimes it's still not possible, because the records facility keeping your birth certificate burned down (there's at least one case of this I read about.) Making IDs free would be a cool measure for equality! Not sure where the funding would come from though. In some places like Washington State people keep trying to defund the DMV entirely by getting rid of car taxes, so I doubt you'd get away with funding it that way.
- kurupt213 4y agoThe kids all have the same potential in kindergarten and 1st grade. Sure, a few precocious kids are reading and doing basic arithmetic already, but most kids, even from affluent intact households, are just ready to get beyond recognizing sight words.
- feet 4y ago>kids all have the same potential in kindergarten and 1st grade. This statement is false. By this point, children have already been exposed to a large portion of their parents' vocabulary even tangentially rather than directly. The amount of attention that kids receive can vary depending on their parents' schedules. The amount and quality of nutrition has a large impact on brain and cognitive development. That's not even accounting for base genetic differences, but these differences do impact the epigenetic control of expression of proteins.
- mistrial9 4y agoyou need to get out more -- this is beyond 'not true'
- watwut 4y agoCause "disciplined approach" is euphemism for "deadly boring stripped of anything fun or even punitive". Kids are not offended by these approaches. But they tend to check out and get bored. I am arguably middle class. I did put a lot of effort and money into making reading fun and interesting for my kids. They do read a lot now. The parents that made it about discipline (I know some) have kids that don't read voluntary. Go figure.