3 ms·
He's right, PoS or PoW never were related to governance in Ethereum: the governance process has always been entirely controlled by the Ethereum foundation in a
by littlestymaar 4y ago
He's right, PoS or PoW never were related to governance in Ethereum: the governance process has always been entirely controlled by the Ethereum foundation in a centralized way.
but his argument about “bitcoin civil war”, is disingenuous at best, concluding that miners are “powerless” about governance process is really a strange way to analyze this event (which illustrated that they where not in fact “all powerful” which is quite different from being “powerless” …)
He's also making a common, but misleading claim here:
> A block that violates the protocol rules (eg. if it tries to print more coins than the protocol rules allow) will not be accepted by the network, no matter how many miners or stakers support it
He's separating “miners and stackers” from “the network” which is a common position trope, but in reality a blockchain is a node of validators (miners, or stackers) with optional spectators, most of which don't even have enough data to take positions on whatever the validators are doing. Only the (scarce) full nodes can see that something fishy is happening, but they actually have no control on what happens on chain, all they can do is blow the whistle.
What makes a blockchain work is the game theory incentives alignment which helps making sure miner/stakers don't collude together, not because “the network” (miners/stakers aside) can do anything to prevent malicious actions from a cartel of validators.
- PretzelPirate 4y ago> the governance process has always been entirely controlled by the Ethereum foundation in a centralized way. The EF has little to no say in the protocol nowadays. One of the reasons that multiple protocol teams exist and all decisions are made in the open is so decision making can be transparent and criticized.