5 ms·
Movements and institutions need to jealously guard their own interests, and not spend their political capital on unrelated movements. When they don’t do that, t
by rayiner 4y ago
Movements and institutions need to jealously guard their own interests, and not spend their political capital on unrelated movements. When they don’t do that, they undermine their own supposed priorities. When public health officials made an exception to their Covid position to support protests in 2020, they revealed that they’re willing to put their personal political views ahead of “the science.” And when you do that, that shreds your credibility. It’s a really dangerous thing for scientific institutions to signal to people that they have an agenda beyond their specific field.
- thrown_22 4y agoThis puts into very simple words my opposition to orgs like Mozilla making outreach for women, minorities and whatever else the flavour of the month is in California a part of their goals. Doubly so since they have been loosing market share every quarter for 10 years. Stick to doing the one thing you're meant to be doing. We don't need a dozen organizations to be chasing whatever is popular right now - poorly - we need organizations that follow the course regardless of what happens.
- autoexec 4y ago> This puts into very simple words my opposition to orgs like Mozilla making outreach for women, minorities and whatever else the flavour of the month is I don't think this is really a problem as long as they aren't being hypocritical. If a web browser company wants to make "outreach for women" (whatever that means) something they strive for that's perfectly fine unless it undermines their other goals. Telling people in the middle of a pandemic to gather in large groups for chanting and screaming is a bad look for an origination whose purpose is to promote people's health. If Mozilla went around looking for ways to encourage women to take an interest in open source browser development that could easily support their interests.
- thrown_22 4y ago>I don't think this is really a problem as long as they aren't being hypocritical. There isn't a problem if the violence to women orgs start spending half their budget on building a good open source browser. Otherwise there is very much a problem.
- verall 4y agoExcept that 2020 protests didn't cause short term upticks in case numbers the same way some (not all) political and entertainment events did, most likely because they were mostly young people and they were outside. The biggest risk factor for transmission is bad ventilation and the biggest comorbidity is age. So they weren't really wrong, and people at the time encouraged other political and entertainment events to be held outside to reduce risk.
- rayiner 4y ago> most likely because they were mostly young people and they were outside. Except that public health experts, at least on CNN, didn’t run with “outside activists involving young people are pretty safe.” They could have done that, but instead they framed the carve-out expressly in terms of “we think protests are really important.” This was early in the pandemic, when we were still ragging on Florida for not shutting down beaches and shutting down school sports.
- verall 4y agoMost epidemiologists that I remember were discouraging all gatherings. Some CNN talking heads, said that protesting for your right not to be discriminated against by police, is more important than not gathering, which is more important than entertainment events. Given they were liberal, that is not in any way surprising. CNN/mainstream media have so many people on that say different things and get re-reported by other stations. Plenty of people on TV at the time were discouraging protests. I think you just remember what made you feel angry.
- rayiner 4y agoIt was definitely notable enough for liberal outlets like Politico to take note: https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/06/04/public-health-protests-301534 https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2020/06/04/public-hea... See also: https://www.upworthy.com/public-health-experts-defend-antiracism-protests https://www.upworthy.com/public-health-experts-defend-antira... (“More than 1200 public health experts, infectious disease professionals, and community stakeholders have signed onto an open letter explaining why they support anti-racism protests happening across the country despite the potential risk of coronavirus spread.”)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]