3 ms·
If you're interested in traditional ironmaking, Christopher Roy filmed a documentary a few years back on the techniques used up to the beginning of the 20th cen
by kragen 4y ago
If you're interested in traditional ironmaking, Christopher Roy filmed a documentary a few years back on the techniques used up to the beginning of the 20th century in Burkina Faso, From Iron Ore to Iron Hoe: Smelting Iron in Africa: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RuCnZClWwpQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RuCnZClWwpQ
It's amazing to see how much work the traditional technique required. Though I don't know how much the techniques developed over the last 3000 years, none of the materials or manufacturing techniques exhibited in the documentary seem to require anything more than Neolithic products: leather, clay, wood, rope. (With the exception of using the cast-iron knife to carve the sluice, the same is true of Plant's video.)
So it's particularly surprising to realize that the Neolithic started 12000 years ago and the Iron Age only started about 3500 years ago (the Painted Gray Ware culture in India). For 8500 years people all over the world had the tools at their disposal to make iron, but didn't know it. That's 3000 years longer than all of recorded history! It's similarly amazing to realize that from 3500 years ago until 2600-2100 years ago all iron was made by hugely inefficient processes like these rather than with blast furnaces, and that until 1000-500 years ago blast furnaces were only used in China. And it wasn't until Bessemer that they could be used to make steel.
What similar opportunities are under our noses today? (More examples in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32697419 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32697419.)
If you're interested in this sort of material culture unbootstrapping, you might also be interested in the unbootstrapping efforts for software described at http://bootstrappable.org/ http://bootstrappable.org/.
- jbay808 4y ago> What similar opportunities are under our noses today? Material science is really hard, even though we already have at our disposal pretty much all the elements we're likely ever going to have! There are so many combinations and conditions to try. I'd guess that if a room temperature and pressure superconductor is possible in our universe, it can likely be made in small amounts using today's technology. High-entropy alloys are another exciting space to explore. Materials science deserves a lot more respect than it gets. It's hard to appreciate how much hard-won materials advances, like neodymium magnets, enable the variety of technologies we have today.
- kragen 4y agoIt might be more practical to change the temperature of the room! That's what they did for JWST. There might be more elements to draw on: antimatter, obviously, but also strange matter and metastable nuclear isomers. And although quantum dots aren't actually new elements, in many contexts they act like it. And don't assume that, just because the surface of a material is at atmospheric pressure, the material 10 microns below the surface is at a lower pressure than the core of the Earth. Really, though, as fascinating as materials science is, I think the biggest advances are elsewhere, at least for now and maybe for centuries. Better materials than 50 years ago weren't needed for Apollo 13, Linux, Stable Diffusion, seL4, Uber Cab, the WWW, AlphaZero, Z3, Hypothesis, Falcon, covid vaccines, or even 5G. (Better materials were used, but Linux displaying on a CRT with ten times bulkier chips would still be Linux. I mean, it was.)
- jbay808 4y agoQuantum dots, which can be manufactured with today's lab equipment from the elements on our periodic table, are a good example of why it's likely that the revolutionary materials of the future will also likely be something we can make with sufficiently clever application of today's tech. The stress in a pressure vessel goes as Pr/t, so for P=365 GPa and t= 10e-5m, the effective tensile strength of the surface would either have to be thousands of times higher than carbon fibre or else the total size of the superconducting particle would need to be microscopic. I'm not sure that a material with such stored energy wouldn't rearrange itself in short order to relieve that stress. Of course better materials than 50 years ago are not necessary for the Apollo missions, which took place 50 years ago. But there's also a materials reason why they didn't have quadcopter drones. We do still use most of the same structural materials today as back then, although materials science is one of the major limiting factors for rockets (especially reusable rockets) and metals that can survive high temperature oxidizing environments are a big step since then. And some of our most amazing materials, especially polymers, either were developed for or found their first applications in the Apollo program. For the internet, one of the greatest materials science revolutions in that period was the improvement in optical fibers, where losses dropped by something like 13 orders of magnitude. This was not initially even suspected to be possible. A good deal of semiconductor advances are arguably materials advances, and today silicon carbide power electronics are leading the way. Your smartphone has a flatscreen with a colour display thanks to the blue LED, another materials breakthrough of recent decades, which meant we could do away with bulky fluorescent backlights. It's not at all clear that we would have AlphaZero without the advanced materials driving today's semiconductor, magnetic, and optical materials, which enabled data storage and compute power to be cheaply available. Without this, it may have been only possible in the same sense that Da Vinci could design but not manufacture a helicopter in renaissance Italy.