21 ms·
And it is not early days anymore. We have given it enough time to realize the claims as a Twitter alternative and it has simply failed. Twitter had tens of mil
by rvz 4y ago
And it is not early days anymore.
We have given it enough time to realize the claims as a Twitter alternative and it has simply failed. Twitter had tens of millions of users in its first 6 years. Mastodon is still struggling and considers 20 people as 'trending'.
Mastodon is a total failure, and virtually no-one is there or uses it frequently or daily other than the general hyper tech-crowd and that is the fact.
Regardless of the $48BN takeover, I'm already seeing the Mastodon circus running back to Twitter as they knew Mastodon was going the way of the Mastodon; extinction.
- dumpsterlid 4y agoMy favorite part about Mastodon/The Fediverse is people like you think it is dead and hopeless and don't come there
- TylerE 4y agoConsider the feeling mutual.
- dumpsterlid 4y agoHappily so!
- rvz 4y agoIt is dead. Even the users who 'moved' to Mastodon came back to Twitter again are still posting on Twitter. Why? Because there is no-one on Mastodon even after the Twitter 'exodus'. We are talking 6 years and even less users using it. That sounds like a total failure on Mastodon's side to be a viable Twitter alternative.
- elsjaako 4y agoI use it, and sometimes I unfollow people because the timeline gets to be too much to keep track of (so not dead). I have met people off it in real life. I also have a twitter account, that I use to follow a few (6 maybe?) accounts I care about. I scroll through that every week or two. I like those accounts, but twitter feels needy, constantly screaming for more attention. This is the website, not using an ad blocker. You say Mastodon is dead, so maybe you like a website constantly pushing you to engage more? I can understand how it would make the site feel more lively, especially for new users. Mastodon is not the same as Twitter, but there are plenty of us that prefer it. If you want 100000 followers it's the wrong platform, I'll give you that. > Even the users who 'moved' to Mastodon came back to Twitter again are still posting on Twitter. Why? Because there is no-one on Mastodon even after the Twitter 'exodus'. There have been many small exoduses, and some people stayed with Mastodon.
- rvz 4y agoIt is indeed dead. We have given it 6 years and little to no-one is on the platform. > Mastodon is not the same as Twitter, but there are plenty of us that prefer it. With the constant comparisons and mentions of Mastodon, being an alternative to Twitter even in its early days, it will be judged as so and my strict judgement is that it has failed. > There have been many small exoduses, and some people stayed with Mastodon. I'm almost certain that this year's Twitter exodus to Mastodon, that more than 90% of users who registered at the time do not use it regularly and have moved back to Twitter due to little to no interaction there. That is the fact of the matter after 6 years of operation.
- slater 4y agoTwitter doesn't have to "lose", for Mastodon to "win".
- naniwaduni 4y agoBy virtue of the incumbency and respective "business" models, it is possible for Mastodon to not lose even as Twitter wins, while the converse is ... implausible.
- lioeters 4y agoJust because you are not there, doesn't mean other people are not. > My conservative estimate of current Mastodon network totals, based on my own stats aggregation, is 3 million registered users and 250k monthly active users. > - Mastodon founder Eugen Rochko (April 2022)
- TylerE 4y agoThat sounds pretty dismal? E.g. >90% of "registered users" don't actually use the platform.
- culi 4y agoDo you think Twitter or Facebook is any better?
- TylerE 4y agoYes? Facebook's MAU is almost half the world population. Hell, their daily active users is almost 2B.
- ipaddr 4y agoFacebook claims 700+ million login daily but many are bots. It doesn't matter because you are not talking or interacting with them. You have a small list and unless you explore groups. Most of the world uses google search outside of China. I don't feel connected to them and if the volume dropped to a few hundred people using google search it wouldn't affect my experience. Facebook isn't a community site it is a social media with expectations that you consume more content than you contribute.
- rvz 4y agoIt's because it is dismal and Eugen is right as well and there is evidence supporting that [0] which it is still true to this day with the up-to-date instances that are active and with users who have logged in at least once over a week. 3,064,237 total registered Mastodon accounts and only 192,384 users using it. That is 7% of active users using the platform and 93% of everyone else not using it. There is virtually no one to talk to or interact with on the platform. This is enough to tell us that Mastodon is indeed a failure and has not replaced Twitter after 6 years of marketing itself as a Twitter alternative. [0] http://sp3r4z.fr/mastodon/accurate_user_count http://sp3r4z.fr/mastodon/accurate_user_count
- betwixthewires 4y agoIt's not a failure. This idea that it has to be huge to be a success comes from the instagram, Facebook, twitter and YouTube way of counting success. 100 million views, 10k likes in an hour, 100k followers... these humongous numbers are not normal, and they're not necessary for a rewarding social experience online. In fact I think the opposite is true. Lots of people use the network daily. I do. It's more fun than twitter. You can experiment. You can say whatever you want if you pick the right servers. And you'll see people doing that, and saying things you don't like. And thats fine. I'll never use big corporate social media again in any form.
- rvz 4y ago> It's not a failure It is a failure. Having 3 million registered users and only 192,000 using it every month in the end after 6 years is more than 90% of all users not using it. With those numbers, there is virtually no-one using the platform which explains why many continued to keep posting on Twitter, more than on Mastodon. So it is still a massive and complete failure in almost every way. [0] http://sp3r4z.fr/mastodon/accurate_user_count http://sp3r4z.fr/mastodon/accurate_user_count
- pgcj_poster 4y ago192,000 is not "virtually no one." There are a about dozen sovereign nations with fewer people.
- rvz 4y ago> 192,000 is not "virtually no one." Yes it is, when compared to the total number of registered Mastodon users as I have mentioned from the start with "virtually" meaning 'nearly', 'almost', 'more or less', 'close to'. My use of the word could not get any more accurate and clearer. 192,000 of 3,000,000 is around 6.4%, where that is closer to 0 than 94% is, meaning that approximately 2,808,000 users are still not using it regularly after registration and after 6 years of existence, it has struggled with that ever since. You can try to deny it. But the numbers don't lie.
- gargron 4y agoMastodon considers 20 people in a hashtag as trending because people don't use hashtags for new topics very often, and the hashtags that do get used often and regularly are exactly the opposite of "trending". And because trending data is somewhat limited by your server's view of the fediverse (each server calculates trends based on content from users it is subscribed to). Just 6 days ago somebody posted a poll asking people how often they log in to Mastodon [1]. 2,691 people responded to their poll, 71% answering "every day". Consider it was posted by someone with 201 followers, and people only had 6 days to respond. That, to me, is slightly more than virtually no-one. 2,859 sysadmins consider Mastodon worth running on their domain. I use Mastodon on a daily basis. I follow interesting people on it, I get more than my fair share of cat pictures through it, I find out about things happening in the world through it. I don't use Twitter. To me, it is a Twitter alternative, because it has replaced Twitter for me. Don't see what other claims there are to realize. [1]: https://todon.nl/@alternative_be/108894477425005957 https://todon.nl/@alternative_be/108894477425005957