7 ms·
Which critique? I searched for bitcoin in the article and didn’t find anything critiquing Bitcoin itself.
by adastra22 4y ago
Which critique? I searched for bitcoin in the article and didn’t find anything critiquing Bitcoin itself.
- simonw 4y agoThis bit in particular was interesting, talking about the comparative security of proof-of-stake Ethereum and proof-of-work Bitcoin. > In the case of Bitcoin, I'm worried for two reasons. First, in the long term, Bitcoin security is going to come entirely from fees, and Bitcoin is just not succeeding at getting the level of fee revenue required to secure what could be a multi-trillion-dollar system. Bitcoin fees are about $300,000 per day and haven't really grown that much over the last five years. Ethereum is much more successful at this, because the Ethereum blockchain is much more designed to support usage and applications. Second, proof of work provides much less security per dollar spent on transaction fees than proof of stake, and Bitcoin migrating away from proof of work seems to be politically infeasible. What would a future look like when there's $5 trillion of Bitcoin, but it only takes $5 billion to attack the chain? I can't bold here, but if I could I would have bolded "What would a future look like when there's $5 trillion of Bitcoin, but it only takes $5 billion to attack the chain? ".
- once_inc 4y agoWhat would the absolute worst outcome of that attack be? Miners don't have the option of spending from addresses they don't have the private keys of; all they can do is rewrite history to a certain extent. Would it be bothersome? Yes. Would a globally used bitcoin monetary base layer have complete backing of nation-states using it? Yes. Would people be hesitant to transact during the attack? Probably. None of these things are of immediate consequence, while the attacker spends its funds rewriting history and getting blowback from everyone online. Then there is the issue of getting to 51% in the first place, and retaining that 51% once it is clear something nefarious is happening. Many miningpools are conglomerates of individual miners, who certainly have the option of switching to other parties at their whim. I think proof of work is the only viable way currently known to man to ensure a fair, even monetary playing field at global scale. PoS is not proven, and Ethereum does not scale because it optimized for parameters that aren't relevant for a system that is supposed to be online for at least a century, if not longer.
- latchkey 4y ago> Then there is the issue of getting to 51% in the first place, and retaining that 51% once it is clear something nefarious is happening. ETC currently has a 6.5 day deposit confirmation time on Kraken because it has had multiple 51% attacks and that hold is even after ETC implemented mitigations [1]. These are not just hypothetical issues. [1] https://coingeek.com/ethereum-classic-implements-51-attack-defense/ https://coingeek.com/ethereum-classic-implements-51-attack-d...
- beaned 4y agoThe reason this is possible for etc is because it's a small chain nobody uses with blocks that can be mined with hardware from much larger chains. There is no larger compatible proof of work chain than Bitcoin.
- latchkey 4y agoCorrect. There can only be one top algo/coin per class of hardware. Once ETH PoS happens, ETC will be the top GPU coin (at least to start) and the deposit times should go back down again. One thing ETC has going for it is that the algo is the same as ETH. Very large farms will struggle to retune GPUs for different algo workloads. There is also the issue of different power requirements too.
- once_inc 4y agoThis makes me wonder if I should speculate on the future price of ETC rising right after the merge, because most miners will switch their hashing power to that chain.
- latchkey 4y agoMy theory is the price will jump up on the speculation and then head to zero as the large miners dump on dumb retail.
- michaelwww 4y agoYes, that's a good one. He goes on to say"Of course, if Bitcoin actually gets attacked, I do expect that the political will to switch to at least hybrid proof of stake will quickly appear, but I expect that to be a painful transition." which I thought was funny because he's tweaking them a little by saying they're eventually going to have to accept PoS anyway
- once_inc 4y agoIf so, that won't be the Bitcoin my node will switch to. You can't force the network to do what you want. UASF and the many forks before, during, and after the fork wars have proven this.
- stale2002 4y agoHey, you would be free to fork of to your own little chain that nobody uses. You can always do that. But if the whole system is at risk due to attacks, I expect that you will be a bit lonely on that chain
- once_inc 4y agoI would just not do anything and continue on the original chain. Yes, if most of the world moves to the other chain, that fork will be Bitcoin for the rest of the world. The issue is if my time preference is low enough to await/speculate on the demise of the chain due to the issues I've identified and made me not switch.
- mhluongo 4y agoPretty sure node runners would prefer a UASF to hybrid PoS or at least a different PoW algo over constant 51% attacks. I love Bitcoin, but you have to be able to consider hypotheticals like this. Similarly... a tail emission should be on the table. Mentioning it used to be totally third rail [0], but these days folks like Peter Todd are speaking up. [0] - https://twitter.com/mhluongo/status/1092559017178734594?t=i2J0ez5danXjZQmxPux11Q&s=19 https://twitter.com/mhluongo/status/1092559017178734594?t=i2...
- fezfight 4y agoJust reads like a pitch? Might be valid but Vitalik has kind of a lot skin in the game so it's hard for me to take it at face value.
- michaelwww 4y agoI have the opposite attitude. I want to hear the best arguments from PoS people and the best PoW people. I'm not putting money into it until I understand it to the best of my ability, which admittedly may be never because it's so far over my head
- fezfight 4y agoThere's a famous quote by Uptain Sinclair that is applicable, if indirectly. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." If Vitalik was wrong, do you think he'd be able to see it?
- michaelwww 4y agoThat's a good point if I were forced to make a decision by only listening to Vitalik. But he doesn't strike me as a profiteering salesman trying to get me to sign the dotted line based on just what he says. It's a huge debate that will invent the future so no doubt Bitcoiners will engage in the debate and tell me why Vtalik is wrong about Bitcoin and Proof of Stake. You wouldn't complain to the judge in a courtroom that the lawyer for the other side is biased. That's essentially what some people in this thread are saying. Instead, you'd engage the opposing lawyers arguments and come up with better ones. I'm on the jury, trying to make up my mind.
- fezfight 4y agoThe court compels the lawyers to tell the truth or face consequences, so at the very least, out right blatent lies will be called as such by the other lawyers or the judge. Certainly things will sneak by so you should be weary of whatever is said in court, too. However this interview is PR, not a court.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- missingrib 4y agoThank god you can't bold.
- t_mann 4y agoI would have responded that the security of the original Bitcoin protocol will likely have been rendered void by quantum computers long before the full supply has been minted.
- tromp 4y agoThe time when the last satoshi is mined is irrelevant. The security will be in question as soon as the block subsidy drops below the level of tx fees, which will only take a few decades. In the past decade, no progress has been made on the size of numbers that can be factored by a quantum computer. From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shor%27s_algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shor%27s_algorithm: > Also, in 2012, the factorization of 21 was achieved, setting the record for the largest integer factored with Shor's algorithm. In 2019 an attempt was made to factor the number 35 using Shor's algorithm on an IBM Q System One, but the algorithm failed because of accumulating errors.
- t_mann 4y agoYoung technologies can progress exponentially (Moore's law, Wright's law,...) with the right factors in place, so be careful when extrapolating progress over the next decade using the last decade. How much progress in neural-network-based image recognition has been made in 2002-2012, and how much in 2012-2022?
- vbezhenar 4y agoIf quantum computers will ever work, by that time bitcoin will migrate to new algo, that’s not a big issue.
- t_mann 4y agoIn the same sense that moving to PoS is 'not a big issue'. The Bitcoin protocol, using PoW and quantum-vulnerable keys, is defined in the Whitepaper and can't move anywhere. People in the Bitcoin community can move to a new protocol and try to create an air of continuity (which will likely happen, multiple times, creating questions about who the 'real' successor is).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]