4 ms·
What happens if they really want someone but to get them to move it would require breaching the maximum advertised?
by robertlagrant 4y ago
What happens if they really want someone but to get them to move it would require breaching the maximum advertised?
- scrose 4y agoThe ranges aren’t a legal min/max. Just a reasonable range.
- mlyle 4y agoRoughly: You have to post the pay scale for the position. So, if current employees in that role make $100,000 to $120,000, and you expect to hire whomever responds at ~$116,000, you would post $100k-120k. Later, if you hire someone for $125k, the pay scale now includes $125k. You must provide this info to current employees on request, and would have to include it in subsequent listings.
- robertlagrant 4y agoI imagine it will be simpler to just higher a $10k/yr cheaper alternative than do this all the time, even if that alternative ends up being half as good as the more expensive alternative. I can't imagine all the interpersonal issues caused by this being requested after every hire!
- mlyle 4y agoAlternatively, transparency could make things more fair and eliminate a lot of jealousy, etc. It's this weird not-very-transparent place we are that's unstable.
- robertlagrant 4y agoWhat do you mean, unstable? If someone will leave if they don't get a pay rise they should get one without management (who all need paying for, lowering the useful salaries) getting together to figure out if it's worth all of the cost of giving everyone that pay rise, or the hassle of uprisings and complaints if they only give that person one.
- mlyle 4y ago> What do you mean, unstable? I mean, the lack of transparency and partial information makes the situation unstable. Employers enjoy an information advantage. Times that this information advantage are breached --- whether by people selectively sharing information, leaks, etc --- cause big disruptions to morale and big movements of people. Partial information is known to distort markets and cause wide variability in outcomes (and to create less stable equilibria than markets with better information flow).
- robertlagrant 4y agoEmployees have all the job market information too, and they have info personal to them that the employer doesn't know (e.g. "I would've taken the job for $20k/yr less"). There's no obvious asymmetry. Each side has different information, but not asymmetric. This law will remove an aspect of the employee's secret information - what they're currently on - so their next employer will be able to calculate precisely how little to offer them.
- mlyle 4y ago> Employees have all the job market information too Employees absolutely do not have the information that there are people in the same role earning 5x what they do. When they find out, it tends to get really messy, too. > Each side has different information, but not asymmetric. This is a definition of asymmetry that I am not familiar with. > This law will remove an aspect of the employee's secret information - what they're currently on Actually, the law explicitly prohibits employers seeking this information about employees-- their specific comp. In the past, employers would pay data brokers for this information. In turn, the playing field was very tilted: you could see the person's current comp and know the entire set of comp you pay in that position and the total history of offers you've made and their acceptance rates... whereas employees know just what they've gathered through informal, unreliable means (glassdoor, friends, etc).
- robertlagrant 4y ago
- hedora 4y agoJust add a position / pay band for them (or move them up a rung into an existing band). In many companies, org charts are public, but comp bands are secret, so this can be done without messing up manager/IC relationships.