7 ms·
Poland plans to seek $1.3T in reparations from Germany for WWII
- RicoElectrico 4y agoI would not read into it much more than international policy for internal propaganda. They know it's not gonna succeed. Why do they come up with this right now? Their poll ratings are slipping, following Odra river ecological disaster and huge inflation - and these are only their latest screwups. Many social groups traditionally in favor of PiS are becoming mad at the government. They have their "iron electorate" that will vote them no matter what, but this does not give them majority.
- fenek 4y agoThey didn't come up with this now. The report has been in the works for years.
- JanSt 4y agoThe same group presented a report asking for $1tn in 2019. They come up with this whenever they need a distraction or same angry voters.
- nindalf 4y agoI guess every political party has a reliable, ready-made distraction for their mistakes. In India the classic distraction is Pakistan. Why are you complaining about potholes on the street outside when our soldiers are fighting on the Siachen glacier? You don't see them complaining! I thought it couldn't get dumber than that but the Polish version seems worse.
- m0llusk 4y agoNo, there is a political party that has put this forward as part of its campaign preparations. There is no broad or publicly demonstrated support for reparations demands in Poland.
- parasense 4y agoThe reparations for Poland has been ongoing since the end of WW2, however since Poland went into the Iron Curtain, the reparations they did receive were given to the soviet union, who didn't provide them to Poland. And by now the memory of the 6 million dead Polish is distant or non-existent.
- SapporoChris 4y agoI was in Poland for eight months recently. I saw evidence all around that they very well remember their holocaust. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Poland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Holocaust_in_Poland There are plenty of crowded museums with long lines of people waiting to get in. There are plenty of monuments, and there is plenty of anger. However, please enlighten me. I would be interested in evidence of a distant or non-existent memory of 6 million dead Polish.
- 988747 4y agoI think they meant "in the West". Which makes sense: US and UK sold us to Stalin in Jalta, so they had to wipe the memory of Polish participation in WWII (or at least downplay it), so their societies could feel good about themselves.
- jll29 4y agoHaving lived in the UK for many years, the Polish contribution to winning WWII are not publicly acknowledged enough. For example, I have not heard mention of the Polish fighter pilots that helped the UK on (radio reports of) memorial occasions, and they are not officially invited. The one place where this was rectified is Bletchley Park, which after a major refurbishment/re-design now features a statue of codebreaking pioneer Marian Adam Rejewski - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_Rejewski https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_Rejewski It is unfortunate that the reparations paid to the USSR were not actually used to Poland's benefit; however, that is the USSR's fault, not Germany's, and many Poles acknowledge that. The present government had strong support by conservatives and by anti-communist people because they promised to rid public offices from leftover communists or their puppets (which - true to their word - they did, but in a very bad, anti-democratic way, which ended up breaking more glass than they could have saved). This past support is eroding, but going back to the previous, "communists & puppets" won't solve anything either... It is regretful that Poland's location in between two much larger, powerful countries made its people suffer as a "buffer zone" of sorts. Of course geography itself doesn't harm people, but people get harmed because of geography.
- causi 4y agoSeems fairly likely the FSB is behind this. What better way to fracture unity for the two European states most involved in the Ukraine war?
- RicoElectrico 4y agoThis particular one? I doubt, but there are theories in major newspapers (Polityka, Gazeta Wyborcza, Newsweek) that Antoni Macierewicz (former defence minister, a major PiS politician) is a Russian agent or otherwise connected with Russia, as such connections pop up all around his circle of friends.
- myth_drannon 4y agoThe point of disinformation is not to out someone but to destroy trust in all information. So you actually can't decide is it a truth or not, is it Russia that is trying to saw discord or is he truly a Russian agent.
- 411111111111111 4y agoSo people still trust any information? Personally I've lost mine ages ago. There is no way to discern truth from propaganda without investing an unsustainable amount of time researching. The internet ceased to be a source of truth when the people with motive realized that the populous get their information from it. It's fine for technical learning and easily proven facts, but any political information or any with significant economical impact should be considered propaganda, as for every person that actually knows anything about the topic there will be 10 that are paid to spread some agenda
- myth_drannon 4y agoI lost trust too. Disinformation won.
- soco 4y agoI guess looking at the persons/parties spreading a certain kind of information/policies could help a bit clarify their goals and assess their trustworthiness. "Follow the money" is a classic already.
- tarakat 4y agoHow does one decide which countries owe reparations? Poland could equally demand reparations from Russia [1], as could most of Eastern Europe, while South-Eastern Europe could demand reparations from Turkey. Yet one never sees headlines about those. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territories_of_Poland_annexed_by_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territories_of_Poland_annexed_...
- ethbr0 4y ago> How does one decide which countries owe reparations? It's not decided, it's declared. The tricky bit is enforcing it, which usually requires having just won a war with the other party, and getting it in the peace treaty they're forced to sign.
- pmontra 4y agoPoland is in a row with the EU, that's why they are asking money IMHO. They have other kind of problems with Russia. Furthermore I think that they have little expectations about Russia paying reparations. They'll get laughs instead, at best.
- dehrmann 4y agoRemember that time Germany paid reparations after WWI? It experienced hyperinflation to combat it and elected a nationalist leader.
- shakow 4y agoRemember when France paid even more in 1815 and 1871 and didn't went on a genocidal rampage on their neighbors?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dmichulke 4y ago> The last payment of the indemnity was paid in early September 1873 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_indemnity https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_indemnity Not sure you're comparing apples with apples here.
- microtherion 4y agoThe French indemnity was $342B in 2011 dollars, according to Wikipedia. The Versailles reparations were formally $389B in 2011 dollars, but apparently the way the treaty was structured, only $147B were actually expected to be paid. The difference was that the French paid promptly, and the Germans did not.
- Alupis 4y agoThe Germans (if I remember my 8th grade history class correctly) printed money to be able to afford the reparations - which led to the hyperinflation and famous pictures of folks with literal wheel-barrows full of Marks going to buy basics like bread and newspaper. The inability to afford the reparations outright, and the "solution" which led to hyperinfaltion is part of the catalyst that allowed extreme resentment over handling of the treaty, and ultimately the rise of fascism.
- orangepurple 4y agoThe Polish government is being pulled in a few interesting directions. For instance, as of 20 Sep, 2021: Poland must pay a daily penalty of €500,000 ($585,550) for ignoring a previous order from the European Union’s top court to cease operations at the Turow lignite mine, with its CEO slamming the fine as “bizarre”. On Monday, the EU’s Court of Justice (CJEU) confirmed it was enforcing the financial penalty against Warsaw, stating that Poland must pay the European Commission the daily half-million euro fine until it sees compliance with the earlier order. Judges from the Luxembourg-based court said that the fine is “necessary… to deter that member state from delaying bringing its conduct into line with that order.” https://twitter.com/EUCourtPress/status/1439940814046744581?s=20 https://twitter.com/EUCourtPress/status/1439940814046744581?... The Czech Republic took legal action against Poland in February over activities at the mine, which also sits close to the German border, claiming that it spoiled its citizens’ drinking water. After Warsaw failed to obey the court orders in May to “immediately cease lignite extraction activities at the mine”, Prague asked the court to fine Poland €5 million per day. Poland is widely hated by its neighbors for the existence of this mine. The mine is also in a hilarious geographic location if you look it up on the map. It's BARELY within the country.
- buscoquadnary 4y agoSo it looks like this mine produces coal which I am assuming is used for power generation. Don't know if I can blame them for not shutting it down while the message coming from the rest of Europe is that everyone's going to be doing an IRL game of Frostpunk this winter.
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agowhat do you expect? The european union is widely known for strange and impractical decisions. A few of its members basically drag the rest along for bad decisions and the smaller guy follow because they need that sweet sweet eu money.
- p_l 4y agoIn this case it wasn't "strange or impractical" decision - the mine endangered water table on Czech side of the border. Czech Republic protested expansion unless Poland funded some minor work to ensure access to water was unimpeded. The incompetents in the government decided that negotiation, or the way lower than the dien cost of fixing water pipeline for few villages, was beneath them. The ECJ injunction was about stopping the expansion when, as matter spanning the border, the case was taken to court. Once again politicians decided to... Ignore the injunction, which resulted in a fine, and finally the fine was taken from funds that would otherwise go to Poland.
- mercy_dude 4y agoThere is something interesting going on here from a geopolitical angle. EU is being sued for providing recovery fund because some senior German EU officials don’t like their right wing government.[1] This is even though Poland is housing millions of Ukrainian nationals. A senior EU official has been quoted they won’t get this fund till till this government stays in power. [1] https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2022/08/29/eu-council-sued-for-approving-polands-35-billion-covid-recovery-fund https://www.euronews.com/my-europe/2022/08/29/eu-council-sue...
- forinti 4y agoGermany might want some change from the land they ceded to Poland.
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agoww2 all over again "hey guys lets make germany pay more than we should reasonably ask for a long time, that never went wrong before."
- robocat 4y agoI wonder how much that land is valued at? Perhaps Poland owes Germany some Marks/Zloties?
- cromka 4y agoPoland was reshaped without having anything to say and without asking for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yalta_Conference#Eastern_Bloc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yalta_Conference#Eastern_Bloc And also lost whole lot of land in the process.
- cromka 4y agoThat would open another can of worms, though. Different issue altogether. One thing is that Poland had nothing to say in this (Yalta Conference), two is that Germany started that war in the first place, and three that Poland was forced to ceed a lot of land, too, cities of which weren't as damaged as the grandfathered German ones. Not that I defend that government, but let's stay coherently on the topic.
- myth_drannon 4y agoGermany paid reparations to Israel which had a lot of Polish jews (that can include western Belarus as well).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cromka 4y agoHow did that help Poland, though?
- tester756 4y agoI've been hearing this for years just google: "poland reparations before:2022" what has changed this time?
- advisedwang 4y agoThe rise of the polish right wing, which uses this as part of a victimhood narrative.
- julienreszka 4y agoSo nothing new
- number6 4y agoNext Greece will demand reparations.
- acidioxide 4y agoA big, three-volume report prepared by 30 specialists has been published. https://straty-wojenne.pl/ https://straty-wojenne.pl/
- sampa 4y agojust Poland being Poland
- talideon 4y agoJust PiS taking the piss.
- farseer 4y agoOr else they would carve up Western Ukraine with Russian approval.
- enahs-sf 4y agoAnd here I am still waiting on my 40 acres and mule they were supposed to give my great great grandfather.
- dylan604 4y agoif that's what you're waiting on, then you're selling yourself short. at this point, you should be able to capitalize on any income/wealth that that mule and 40acres could have generated in the time between the agreement and the agreement not being fulfilled.
- demetrius 4y agoIt's funny how Poland and Belarus are doing the same thing: https://www.belarus.by/en/government/events/belarus-material-damage-due-to-ww2-estimated-at-500bn_i_0000132634.html https://www.belarus.by/en/government/events/belarus-material... Not sure what to make out of this
- seba_dos1 4y agoThe current ruling party in Poland came into power after publishing eavesdropped recordings of previous government officials from a restaurant with strong ties to Russian intelligence. I don't know whether they're Russian pawns, but they're certainly stupid enough to be unwittingly realizing Russia's interests even if they're not.
- xhkkffbf 4y agoWhy just Germany? Russia invaded the country at more or less the same time. (Stalin dragged his feet for a week.) They even took up more square miles. And after the war, they did horrible things like keep Buchenwald running for their own purposes. A good place to understand this is to read _Bloodlands_ by Timothy Snyder. Send a bill to both of them I say.
- permo-w 4y agowhy just Germany? because there’s political benefit for PiS in sticking it to the big guy in Europe, but no political benefit in having Putin laugh in your face
- JanSt 4y agoThis comes up every few years (2017, 2019,..). PiS loves anti-german sentiment and it seems to help them with internal politics.
- blueflow 4y agoThe same contract (2+4) that excludes any further reparations is also the contract that says that reunified Germany will not make territorial claims to Pommerania and Silesia. I'm not sure if Poland has the high ground in this.
- baq 4y agocan you tell elections are near?
- ohiovr 4y agoConfederacies don't last long.
- jarek83 4y agoDisclaimer - I'm Polish. This is a product of the currently ruling party, and the elections are coming. While Poland still should get some kind of support from Germany for the damage it caused in many aspects of life here, I don't believe that reparations are what we should and what we could get. The issue has been closed and that fact has been confirmed by Polish government most recently in 2004. The only country we should and could get reparations from is russia, as they actually made Poland to pay (by forcing it to buy subsidized coal many years ago) instead of be paid, and apparently USSR made a promise to pay the reparations. So currently ruling party is not really about getting something for Poland in regards of WWII disaster, but it's only about winning the next elections and seemingly weaken the country once more. Please keep in mind that we have a prime time for russian trolls here and it might take some time if we could ever get rid of them from the politics. To weaken Poland means to empower russia influence here, but sadly many supporters of the ruling party don't connect the dots this way.
- smitty1e 4y agoI'm not Polish and cannot judge the merits of this WWII claim. However, I seem to recall WWI reparations being levied against Germany as among the drivers for the instability of the Weimar Republic[1] that helped inform political drift of the 1930s. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weimar_Republic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weimar_Republic
- acidioxide 4y agoRegardless of whether Poland can obtain this money or not, it is very important for historical reasons to know how big were the losses caused by Germany. Poland never gained any help, neither from the Marshall Plan, nor Germany.