9 ms·
A hormone may boost cognition in Down syndrome
- swayvil 4y agoHow high could we boost it? I think I saw this scifi movie.
- hoppyhoppy2 4y agoAnd could it come crashing back down later, à la Flowers for Algernon ?
- inawarminister 4y agoIts important to mention that Algernon's disorder is Phenylketonuria, the inability to break down an amino acid that damages the brain and blood as infants. We can test babies and avoid the disorder by making them eat special diet for a while. But not those who sadly experienced brain damages first. Such treatment may hopefully help them too. But the action mechanism must be separate than this drug, I think?
- djmips 4y agoHave you ever heard of a so-called 'mild' Phenylketonuria that can escape diagnosis? I've heard of it mentioned here and there but I'm not sure if it's really well known (or if it's even proven - I don't know much about it). I know someone who I have a possibly far fetched hypothesis that they might have something on the Phenylketonuria spectrum. That is they are grew up relatively normal but suffering from some severe mental disorders as they age. When they were young they had the characteristic mousey smell that is mentioned in Phenylketonuria.
- mkarliner 4y agoI'd like to think someone has asked a Down's Syndrome person what they think of this.
- zzleeper 4y agoSadly, you'll probably need to give them the hormone before they answer, so people will take seriously
- mkarliner 4y ago'Normal' people have not exactly covered themselves in glory in how they have been running the world lately. It's just possible that Down's Syndrome people have got it right and we are the abnormal ones.
- vnchr 4y agoIf you truly believed that, you’d choose to have Down’s Syndrome given the opportunity. Somehow, I doubt your commitment to that platitude.
- ralusek 4y agoYou would've been really cool when I was 14.
- type0 4y ago> and we are the abnormal ones. Speak for yourself, Down Syndrome isn't just a cognitive or genetic condition, they have a lot of physiological problems where the organs malfunction, hence the usual premature deaths and suffering.
- DanBC 4y agoLeDeR tells us that premature death is overwhelmingly from poor access to healthcare and substandard healthcare when it is accessed, and it not an intrinsic feature of Down's.
- mjfl 4y agoOne shouldn't generally expect the application of a single chemical hormone to improve cognitive performance. The brain is a computer, and doing this is roughly the equivalent of hooking up either side of a microprocessor with jumper cables and expecting it to "compute better". However, there could be an exception if the reduction of GnRH is one of the only significant effects of the duplication of chromosome 21, which is probably not true - but maybe.
- gavinray 4y agoNoopept and some of the racetams measurably improved my cognitive performance. I've tried most everything under the sun and used my body as a walking science lab. Most things don't have a noticeable effect, but there are a handful of things that do. (Also, YMMV, personal chemistry)
- heavyset_go 4y ago> The brain is a computer As an aside, there are tomes of literature, research and arguments for and against the computational theory of mind. I don't think it's as clear cut to say that the brain is a computer, as physiologically it certainly doesn't work like a computer at all.
- natpalmer1776 4y agoI think the sentiment of the analogy was "the brain is a tightly integrated complex system" which would support the 'multiple changes should be required to accomplish an increase in throughput'
- agumonkey 4y agoIt's important not to apply simple tricks and hope for magic results but it's not absurd to consider that some brain subsystems are so vital and foundational that an improvement their cascades on other higher level cognitive centers.
- stephc_int13 4y agoBrains are unlikely to be simple machines that can be made better by changing a simple variable… Unless this variable is able to boost learning, which can have a huge compounding effect on cognition.
- gavinray 4y agoIf anyone's curious, for a period of several months I administered a GnRH daily for health purposes (Triptorelin) Don't have down's syndrome. Likely on the autism spectrum. Didn't notice any significant cognitive benefits.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AussieWog93 4y ago
- m1gu3l 4y agoWe can do better than lame “derp you post here you must be autistic” replies.
- AussieWog93 4y agoMaybe, but not every post has to be the best. Some can also be lighthearted jokes.
- bendbro 4y agoNo "we" can't
- somewhereoutth 4y agoAre you (we) an engineer because the other kids didn't play with you, or did they not play with you because you were an engineer??
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eyelidlessness 4y agoWe certainly experience interaction with people who don’t have much regard for our neurodivergence. I don’t think “neurotypical” means much other than as a lambast, but that isn’t to say it can’t appropriately describe a lot of my experience here.
- GordonS 4y ago> Six out of seven patients improved their cognitive tests by 20 to 30 percent My 9 year old daughter has Down's Syndrome, and this is the most exciting paper I've seen! I know we're a long, long way off any kind of treatment being available for people with Down's, but still, I can't help but feel some hope. BTW, you can AMA about Down's here if you want!
- adamm255 4y agoYeah the summary made for great reading. This kind of research (and the fact it could help alzheimer's as well...) should be funded to high heaven.
- ahupp 4y agoWhat are your thoughts on ISRIB as a potential treatment for the cognitive effects of Down's Syndrome? https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2019/11/415946/down-syndrome-mouse-model-scientists-reverse-intellectual-deficits-drugs https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2019/11/415946/down-syndrome-mouse...
- GordonS 4y agoAh yes, I read that paper when it was first published - it also shows great promise! As these 2 approaches are different, it would be interesting to see if there was a cumulative effect if both were performed.
- dmix 4y agoIs it true you can detect these sorts of thing before birth or is it still a shot in the dark?
- trhway 4y agoi wonder whether it makes sense to do a diff across all hormonal production in normal and Down person and try to correct that diff by regular injections, etc.
- cercatrova 4y agoI remember reading a story the other year about Iceland having eliminated almost completely Down's Syndrome from their populace by aborting those fetuses which have the syndrome. Much as some parents are happy with their children who do have it, I would not wish anyone in this world to have such a syndrome. Somehow, this attitude seems controversial, and I do not understand it.
- grog454 4y agoWell it sounds one step closer to eugenics, which you can easily find discussion and controversy on.
- cercatrova 4y agoI cannot equate eugenics to aborting medically maligned fetuses. The former is based on superficial features of people that do not impact their physical or cognitive development, such as race, gender or sexuality, while the latter does, and it does so with increased suffering for the individual.
- stephenhuey 4y agoEquivocate does not mean what you think it does. More importantly, many times in history those “superficial features” have been associated by people, rightly or wrongly, with superior cognitive or physical abilities and used as an excuse for eugenics. Even more importantly, having known many people with Down’s I would caution you against saying that they have greater suffering and therefore would be better off not existing. Countless people feel differently about that.
- cercatrova 4y agoThey feel differently because they are already born. However, if they never existed in the first place, they would not have the capacity to feel that way, or feel any way at all actually. It is the same argument as the abortion debate, where those against it appeal to the people already born that might have been aborted, but that is a false equivalence.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Scootwilli90 4y ago[flagged]
- savryn 4y agoDid anyone have a weird 'throwback' feeling seeing this on the front page? (This might not make a lot of sense...) Thinking about Down's syndrome in today's world somehow doesn't 'fit', like existentially and culturally feels like a holdover from another era (except that in reality it's not) Somehow a few days of Dall-E/diffusion posts in a row and it's jarring to 'go back' in time to 80s or whatever of worries about Downs--- rather than mRNA, autism, current medical zeitgeist. stuff like this really makes me think about the twin-nuclei (atom and cell) problem/ idea of Eric Weinstein. It indicates a weird unspoken tension, a tether between the last moments of old world and the first moments of a new world. "The Twin Nuclei Era began in the space of four months in 1952-3 with the first test of the Teller-Ulam fusion device in early November of 1952 followed by the discovery of 3D structure of DNA in late February of 1953." For over 70 years we've already have lived in a world reshaped around the tech of the atom bomb for a while, but because it's been slower going, we still don't know what a world reshaped around the tech of the cell will be. And culturally we've mostly just avoided it like a giant dysfunctional family taboo that makes everyone tense. Barely any of our movies or cultural products have helped reckon with it seriously. Usually cultures grab onto an idea and go through an entire 4 seasons cycle/obsession with it, cross pollinating in multiple genres, recycling tropes, high and low brow versions, etc. But somehow it feels like we jumped to the fun of AI and space instead. One occasional Gattaca or an organ-harvesting clone sci-fi, very very few works of depth. Like genetic engineering of individuals and populations is just too close and real and grimey to handle, too explosive. "Demographics is Destiny" as a saying has been haunting me since I read it, but there's so little to explore /dive into regarding visions of the future, fictional or non-fiction takes. (And hell, I feel we barely have a grip on basic anthropology of how our current society regarding works, power, elites, etc) Everything feels on the cusp of a decade or so (cloning, crispr, ivf, stem cells, demographic planning of sex ratios, aging and healthspan stuff, surrogates, artificial wombs etc), but there's this huge silent inertia tension feeling of researchers working in the shadows before some nation officially shoots the starting gun starts the race and forces every society into a headlong rush towards the biomedical musical chairs/ the next balance of power.