3 ms·
It isn't a concrete example, there are too many relevant details to put in a HN thread. We can't really discuss his exact circumstances, he isn't on hand to ask
by roenxi 4y ago
It isn't a concrete example, there are too many relevant details to put in a HN thread. We can't really discuss his exact circumstances, he isn't on hand to ask what alternatives he & his striking workmates actually considered. And you're asking me to work with the premise that there is literally no alternatives when that is really the fact that is up for debate. If the only option is to destroy wealth then sure, do that. But he isn't going to get wealthy that way.
> It's not his preferred plan. He'd prefer not to have his pay slashed and would prefer to dedicate his energies to doing his best work.
Those are 2 bad plans.
I suppose I'll ask anyway - how many alternatives has he seriously considered? Has he seriously considered any alternatives that might get him a good outcome? What were they? There have to at least be some that he considered before giving up and saying there is no alternative. This presents striking as Plan B.
> Despite your early protestations, I think you're ideologically opposed to the idea of striking.
Yeah. I'm saying that if the best decision is to strike then he's screwed up some decision in the past really badly, that is fundamentally an ideological take. Having a coherent ideology is an important tool for wealth creation. Most of the wealth creation from the industrial revolution onwards has been due to ideological innovations. Capitalism is an ideological position; it just happens to work a lot better than people who think striking is a practical way of securing a lifestyle.
If he is using striking as a tool, he's going to stay poor.