3 ms·
Any details on efficiency vs other common forms of hydrogen production? "We don’t need any energy input" That's not really true. There's tons of engery used t
by giantg2 4y ago
Any details on efficiency vs other common forms of hydrogen production?
"We don’t need any energy input"
That's not really true. There's tons of engery used to mine, refine, and mill those metals. It's interesting that the gallium can simply be reused. I wonder what would be done with the oxidized aluminum.
- PaulHoule 4y agoI'd imagine you could mix it in with bauxite ore and process it back into aluminum.
- ecpottinger 4y agoWhich requires lots of electric power.
- jjk166 4y agoThere might be some situations where it isn't economical to recycle aluminum scrap where this could potentially be an alternative. In such cases the energy would already be a sunk cost. It also might be more practical to transport aluminum over long distances than hydrogen, given hydrogen's low density and propensity to pass through container walls, especially with existing infrastructure. A standard freight train or bulk freighter could easily haul aluminum one way and aluminum oxide back. Perhaps it's a good way of integrating islands like iceland or hawaii into a hydrogen economy.
- adrian_b 4y agoMaking aluminum from aluminum oxide by electrolysis, than reacting it with water to make hydrogen must have a lower efficiency than making directly hydrogen from water by electrolysis. Gallium is inert in this application, its role is to prevent the passivation of aluminum that happens normally when aluminum is exposed to air and water. An amalgam of aluminum (i.e. an alloy of aluminum with mercury) would produce hydrogen in the same way. The advantage of gallium in this application, and also in other applications where gallium is used to replace mercury, is that gallium is not toxic (because being trivalent, it forms insoluble compounds, unlike mercury, which forms soluble ions). This method of making hydrogen is useful only for portable hydrogen generators, intended to be used in places where you could not carry a hydrolysis generator or compressed hydrogen.
- giantg2 4y agoInteresting. Are there any situations where carrying water would be better than carrying compressed (or hydride) tanks? I would think there wouldn't be much, if any weight benefit, especially with the recent advances in lightweight design for aircraft tanks.