3 ms·
Sure, that makes sense. But it's completely irrelevant: the point is that kids identity with cultural moments, and that we shouldn't mistake that for what they'
by woodruffw 4y ago
Sure, that makes sense. But it's completely irrelevant: the point is that kids identity with cultural moments, and that we shouldn't mistake that for what they're actually going to do when they grow up.
For the record, I wanted to be a dinosaur.
- adastra22 4y agoIt does affect what they focus on though, and what interests them later in life. The Apollo effect is very real. There’s a lot of boomers and Gen X folks who went into technology and science because of the Moon landings. we should be doing things and making cultural choices that inspire the next generation of scientists and engineers.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe Apollo effect is real, and so is the Scully Effect[1]. Entertainment stars with no particular relation or expertise in the roles they play can have an outsized effect on children and young adults' professional goals. There is no economical scheme in which 25% of all Gen-Z-ers actually become social media influencers, so I'm not going to spend my time actually worrying about that. For the ones who do, the content they produce matters much more to me than their mere job description. [1]: https://fanlore.org/wiki/The_Scully_Effect https://fanlore.org/wiki/The_Scully_Effect
- adastra22 4y agoI’m not worried about them becoming social media influencers. I understand that there’s a limited pool of positions here. It’s just that the kid who wants to be an astronaut or involved in the space program in the late 60s early 70s grows up to be a tech entrepreneur in Silicon Valley in the 80’s and 90’s. We got that generation to thank for this website and websites in general. I don’t know what the profound effect of Gen Z or Gen A will be, but I suspect a future in which they are inspired by a revived Moon and Mars exploration program will be better than one where they mostly aspire to be “influencers.”
- woodruffw 4y agoHere's what I'll point out: the generation that grew up to be astronauts didn't have astronauts to look up to. They looked up to silent movie stars, army generals, and Depression-era daredevils. Neil Armstrong was born in 1930 and flew in a "Tin Goose" as a child; he probably admired barnstormers a lot more than the rocket scientists who eventually paved the road for his flight to the Moon. It's of course good to have good role models. But I don't think those role models need to be technical experts or "heroic" in some socially beneficial way to be good. They can also be good public speakers, or educators, or just plain entertaining.