5 ms·
I seems to me that Rome is more of a Rorschach test than anything else. Because there was no single cause that definitively ended the empire. Ask 20 historians
by somenameforme 4y ago
I seems to me that Rome is more of a Rorschach test than anything else. Because there was no single cause that definitively ended the empire. Ask 20 historians to tell the prioritized story of Rome's decline, and you'll get 21 largely distinct tales. If you want to blame moral decline, you can. If you want to corrupt political systems, poor monetary policy, immigration, disease, war, social dis-integration (hyphenated only to emphasize the meaning), wealth inequality, or even self inflicted accidental poisoning - you can.
And the worst part of all is that even if we had complete and absolutely perfect information on the decades leading to the end, you probably still couldn't find "the cause." Empires fail long before they collapse - inertia. One can easily argue that the Soviet Union failed decades before 1989. But for anything so monumental, inertia was enough to keep the corpse of a system moving forward for decades to come. And in the time of Rome, when the speed of dictate was that of carriage, sail, (and on rare occasion - pigeon) - this effect would have been magnitudes greater, which is difficult to even begin to appreciate the implications of.
Perhaps the most interesting, and telling, thing of all is how empires towards their end tend to share not just one of the "symptoms", but many.
- tomcam 4y agoI believe we're watching the USA collapse as you describe, and that despite much wider coverage our understanding of its collapse will, too, be more about the beholder.
- jaza 4y agoHow fitting, then, that so many of the USA's capital city buildings boast heavily Roman-inspired architecture.
- bmismyname 4y agoFirst it's slow, and then suddenly it's all at once. We're still in the slow phase, for the time being.
- throwaway6734 4y agoHow many SPY puts are you holding?
- bmismyname 4y agoPuts aren't a good way to hedge against this because in the event the US empire does collapse, your US dollars won't be of much use. In fact, I'd bet that the stock market will actually shoot up to insane levels because the government response will be more money printing to fund military endeavors. Probably better to invest in land in places with a (relatively) stable climate, good fresh water supply, and far enough north and high enough in elevation to be protected from the most obvious effects of climate change.
- thegabriele 4y agoWhat structure of USA will collapse in your estimation? Since we're talking about a democratic federation and not an "empire".
- tomcam 4y agoRed-blue split, roughly. Our federal bureaucracy has become a legislature with no accountability. In that regard we are a late stage empire.
- rnk 4y agoMost states are not clearly red or blue. Most all of the big cities are blue, most of the countryside is red. Even texas is not 65% conservative on voting; less than 5% shift and it would be a tossup or democratic. Maybe a few states like wyoming would go clearly one way but a vast amount of states would not be able to all go one way (think of california). So the outcome of a real us split would be chaos, terror, mixed states. I'm in a very blue state, but the rural population (30% maybe) is a different world of wealth, education, politics, population density. We subsidize their economy by building infrastructure there they can't afford (like roads and bridges). This causes endless arguing at the state level. I think a lot of the states are like this with varying % in the two groups.
- UIUC_06 4y agoYou left out lead poisoning (unless that's included in "self inflicted accidental poisoning"). Yeah, everything that could go wrong did go wrong. We can't run a natural experiment where everything but that one thing goes wrong, and see if Rome survives. Kind of like a very old organism whose health just goes off the cliff.
- sassy_quat 4y agoIt takes the same time for an armored division to travel from coast to coast as it would for a legion to march across the Roman Empire, at least a week. Inertia isn't the problem, failure to take responsibility is. Although it does seem like inertia, a cornucopia of policies that can't be coped with, such as wastage that everyone turns a blind eye to, gradually increasing deficits of supply versus demand (for the Soviets it was grain (somehow Russia is now a grain exporter), for the Americans it is potholes). Numbers are worthless, most Romans were illiterate, and they didn't have Arabic numbers. Bafflingly illiterate workers and automated machines are economically equivalent, otherwise there wouldn't be such a difference between high school dropouts and graduates in work productivity. "The cause"? A failure to tolerate ambition, even when society converts into a fishbowl where everyone is neighbors. Unless ego is abolished and the most horrifying of social engineering programs could be enacted, the problems of late empire are simple: men like Robert Moses, condemned by equally corrupt later generations, are no longer permitted to ensure things run smoothly.
- nerdponx 4y agoRobert Moses isn't condemned for being corrupt, he's condemned for bad urban planning decisions that we are still paying steep prices for, decades later.
- sassy_quat 4y agoI suppose Robert Moses is the wrong man to bring up, though maybe my argument is flawed and should be totally ignored. I take it that you're taking that approach. Given the direction this argument is heading, perhaps urban planning could be simplified, pedestrian only neighborhoods with nearby parking garages provide a great incentive for people to shop at local small businesses instead of supermarkets being a one stop shop with everything from fresh starbucks to factory made bread. The French subsidize their local businesses and from what I hear, their communities are better for it. Naturally so many factors go into urban planning, and how to live in a dense community is something that will always be considered to be unexamined.
- hardwaregeek 4y ago
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe single smartest take on this that I have heard is that none of these disasters (or poisoning) destroyed Rome. The thing that finally did the Roman empire in was that there was nobody left who wanted it to continue as it was gradually taxed by crises. Nations and empires can go through crisis after crisis, and Ancient Rome did so for practically 300 years, since the end of the rule of Marcus Aurelius, and the corresponding end of the Pax Romana. Crisis after crisis and civil war after civil war wore away at the empire. Each time, regional governors accrued more power, the central command structure got weaker and weaker, and finally provinces started to break away from the empire. This is why the fall of Rome is at different times for different people: there wasn't really a clear end of the empire and a move toward fiefdoms and regional governance. The title "emperor of Rome" continued long past the end of the Roman Empire, well into the 2nd millennium AD. EDIT: I believe that what we are looking at in the USA now is closer to Rome in 180 AD than it is to 470 AD. The Pax Americana and the era of globalization that it enabled (globalization is not a modern phenomenon - Ancient Rome under the Pax Romana had a form of globalization, as did the English empire with the Pax Britannica) is clearly coming to an end. There is still a long way to fall before everything unravels - and a lot more pain, tyranny, and bloodshed. It is unclear to me that the big boogeymen of US foreign policy - China and Russia - are poised to take over from the US. Russia clearly does not have the economy to support this. The CCP is likely hoping that the US tears itself apart without a foreign war, since China would likely suffer heavy losses in one.
- labster 4y agoHonestly to me the USA seems to be closer to 79 BC than 180 AD. After a close call, we have a few good years as a republic yet, and are far more powerful than our peer competitors. American influence is expanding right now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trashtester 4y agoEntropy destroyed Rome, the rest are just symptoms.