6 ms·
Why bother with warrants when cops can buy location data for under $10k?
- thephyber 4y agoYet another example of why privacy never really existed and the Third Party Doctrine was terrible for civil rights protections. Perhaps the move towards SBOM will help us identify which libraries sell position location to which brokers so there can be more transparency and competition for privacy features. It’s sad that legislators are asleep at the wheel here and that the FTC / State Attorneys General are so slow to sue.
- xwdv 4y agoIt’s by design.
- thephyber 4y ago“By design” implies someone set out with that intention. My belief is that incentives are aligned so no state actor has significant reason to change the status quo.
- kube-system 4y agoAn SBOM doesn’t really tell you much of anything about how data is handled.
- thephyber 4y agoYeah, I suppose the data broker ecosystem is so incestuous it would be hard to know/disambiguate the path of data flow without more transparency in of the data broker APIs/contracts.
- wmf 4y agoIt would at least reveal all the "advertising" SDKs included in each app. That info on its own is not very scary though.
- rolph 4y agothe problem is LEO shouldnt be able to bypass warrant requirements by purchasing thier way around it. My opinion, if you need a warrant to perform the investigation yourself, you need that warrant regardless of how you are going to obtain that data. this is very much like a 5 year old asking parent one for something, hearing no, then quietly asking parent 2 trying to double down to get a yes answer; except its much more serious
- thephyber 4y agoRe: the child: that is frequently called “parent shopping”.
- Consultant32452 4y agoThis happens at every layer of the security apparatus. There's certain limitations on spying on Americans so the US IC just lets the UK spy on Americans and then asks the UK to give them the data. And the UK does the same vice versa. It's corruption by design from the ground up. There is no party to vote for to stop this.
- pessimizer 4y agoThe problem is that people's phone applications constantly track their locations, and that we don't regulate information brokers. It's no better for private companies to have access to that data than it is for cops. At least cops are regulated to the extent that people have the ability to ask what they're doing and maybe get a response sometimes.
- unityByFreedom 4y agoIt isn't a bypass. The data was legally obtained and sold. Warrants are needed when the requesting entity doesn't have access.
- boomboomsubban 4y agoA legal bypass is still a bypass.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago
- sys_64738 4y agoCan this data be used for prosecution? How do you prove it’s accurate and not modified? If the PII is claimed to be scrubbed then how do you connect it to the felon? Seems you’d want other supporting info to prosecute with and keep silent on this stuff.
- _8j50 4y agoIt is lawfully obtained so yes, but I can see the defense making a good argument otherwise during trial. You subpoeana employees of the company selling you the info to testify and have them maybe produce a chain of custody document for which they will be asked if it is accurate under oath. Depends on what is PII, an IP alone isn't PII for example so if it says IP 1.2.3 4 went to badguy.com at <timestamp> there is no PII there but they can subpoeana the ISP once the traffic is deemed to qualify as probable cause to prove their guy had the IP. The difference being they either obtain the IP with some other means and buy data associated with it or use some destination (could be their trap) and buy all info about traffic to it with very specific parameters without a warrant. But I am neither LE or a lawyer.
- anfilt 4y agoA lot of times information like this is used with parallel construction. So they never need to defend the accuracy of the data in court cause it's mainly used to direct the findings that will presented at trial. Let me give a hypothetical example, witness says the see a Ford Bronco leaving a murder scene. Police use this data to find all people in the area at the time of the crime. They then look to see which of those people in the area at the time are registered owners of a Ford Bronco. However, instead of presenting this data they used in court court to see was in the area they will then for instance search for instance traffic camera footage. Moreover, since they have detailed location information now know what traffic cameras to check or what gas stations to subpoena for camera footage ect.. Then they probably get a warrant for that persons car and house or start watching that person ect... However, what gets presented at trial is the Witness saying they saw a Ford Bronco and the camera footage. Nothing about the detailed phone tracking information. Basically parallel construction allows the LEO and the prosecutor avoid what is colloquially called fruit of the poisoned tree. Wiki article on parallel construction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruit_of_the_poisonous_tree
- thephyber 4y agoI believe this Ars Techica article (covering an AP News + EFF project) may be describing the same product/service: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/09/cops-wanted-to-keep-mass-surveillance-app-secret-privacy-advocates-refused/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/09/cops-wanted-to-k... What is most distasteful to me is that both the vendor and the police try hard to hide the fact that they are using it. Why hide it if it’s legal? Odds are because they don’t want to be a squeaky wheel that gets greased.
- epgui 4y ago> Why hide it if it’s legal? Legal and moral are two different things, and the police is a public service. Public trust and perception are important because they give legitimacy to government.
- srcmap 4y agoAlso PR problem. Public opinions can trigger state/congress to make service illegal or limited.
- thephyber 4y agoMy rhetorical question was more a play on the common refrain by police supporters “why not X if you have nothing to hide?” But perhaps was too dry to notice without body language. Agree with your statement.
- TylerE 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction
- wmf 4y agoCell site simulators such as Stingray were challenged in court and rather than explain how they work the evidence was withdrawn. Perhaps they aren't reliable. Gunshot triangulation systems like ShotSpotter aren't reliable either. This tool may be in the same boat.
- moralestapia 4y agoBecause you have to build a case.
- midislack 4y agoIf you want to avoid this just don't have a cell phone. It's that easy.
- kazinator 4y ago> Why bother with warrants when cops can buy location data for under $10k? If we take this as a non-rhetorical/actual question: to use the evidence in court it may be necessary for it to have been obtained under warrant. "Why bother with search warrants when people don't bother locking their front doors before going out?" I, ANAL and all that.
- bongoman37 4y agoI used to work for a company that did this. The amount of location data out there and how easily it is available is mind boggling. And turning off GPS location on your mobile phone doesn't save you. You can get location data from telecoms directly though it is coarser. If you have a mobile phone on you, you connect to a cell tower, and boom, your location is known to a few hundred feet. This is sometimes preferred because you can fake your GPS data but this comes from the cell towers so no way to fake it. If you repeatedly visit the same places, which most people do, with some ML models so you can localize it further down. Every app that asks for location data sells it. That includes every single weather app. In some cases, it is a bigger revenue stream than the ads they show.
- anm89 4y agoOnly in the world of the taxpayer's money is 10k for a single task cheap
- j16sdiz 4y ago(I am not from US, if that matter) I wonder why every news on privacy issue in the United States try to make connection with abortion. Won't this make the privacy argument more fragmented?
- LatteLazy 4y agoI am not a lawyer but... Abortion rights in the US were originally based on privacy (the government's right to tell a woman what she could or could not do with her body). Overturning that widened government authority not just over abortion, but 1001 other issues linked to the same core finding. Laws banning sodomy were struck down on the same basis: what two consenting adults do behind closed doors that doesn't affect third parties are a violation of the "right to privacy". The same for interracial marriage. The same ruling has implications here because the data in question "belongs" to the phone company. But government buying it might violate individuals' right to privacy. Only individuals' right to privacy is now very curtailed. People think Roe vs Wade was an abortion ruling, but it was really a privacy one, and by overturning it SCOTUS has opened a very large number of social issues to be re-litigated. I agree it's a stretch to tie it to abortion (and maybe an appeal to emotion/politics?). But there is a link. I wish more people thought about all these issues (plus NSA spying and social media and 101 other things) in terms of one overall right to privacy. It's sort of the issue of our times (which I think West Wing predicted 20+ years ago)
- probably_wrong 4y agoI think abortion is a particularly interesting case. Up until now, it was very difficult to show how bad tracking is - common arguments are "I have nothing to hide", "No one can show me a concrete example of something bad happening", or even "I like ads that are relevant to me". But now that the publicly available data of women seeking abortions can be used to send them to jail, arguments 1 and 2 are easier to disprove. I'm not aware of any previous pro-privacy argument with such clear connection between cause and consequence.
- rayiner 4y ago
- 4y ago
- datacruncher01 4y agoI don't have an issue with police being able to request information from companies for their investigations. I do have an issue with our public tax dollars being spent to purchase this information. In the absence of a financial incentives companies will be less willing to hand over that data and the traditional requirement of a warrant will be utilized as it should be.
- antifa 4y agoThey're bypassing warrents and spending your tax dollars to do it.