3 ms·
I wish I could agree with you, but I can't. It looks like the "conservative" doctrines were mostly held in bad faith, used almost solely as verbal cudgels, rath
by bediger4000 4y ago
I wish I could agree with you, but I can't. It looks like the "conservative" doctrines were mostly held in bad faith, used almost solely as verbal cudgels, rather than as ideals to aspire to or guide policy.
I'd also like to gently point out that you're doing a "no true scotsman" argument here.
- mindslight 4y agoThat seems markedly less charitable than what I said. You seem to be implying that there is no merit whatsoever in any conservative values. This may be great for rallying your own mob to fight, but isn't useful for convincing others or critically refining your own thinking.
- bediger4000 4y agoI'm all for refining my own thinking, but over the last 6-8 years, when I've tried, I've gotten a lot of insults. The most memorable was "latrine level liberal". I hadn't done anything to indicate my biases, merely asked a question about apparent contradiction. The closest I've come to a decent conversation, when trying to understand current conservatism, was a DM conversation on Reddit. I didn't learn a whole lot, the dude was basically operating on reflexes and subconscious. I'd really like to understand, but if repeated attempts end up with me getting explicitly insulted, I have to conclude uncharitable things.
- mindslight 4y agoI had the advantage of doing this earlier, after the Iraq War. I was taking a cross country trip, obviously talked with a lot of people who were pro-war, and learned to just let it pass over me and accept where they were coming from. The sharply insulting reactions you're getting are due to the hypocritical hysteria currently gripping the Republican Party. I don't think you will be successful at discussing philosophy at this time, especially online. The current energy is driven by hypocrisy and shallow thinking. The people that haven't been swept up by it are somewhere between being aghast where the party has gone, or sitting back and hoping for collapse. My ultimate conclusion was that the pro war middle of the country is just driven by a different emphasis on issues and values, but still a core of ultimately wanting to be left alone (ie freedom). The Iraq War was not their issue, and the people on TV said to support it, so they did. Seeing this pattern also helped me critique my own bubble's politics for it. Unfortunately, that "TV" has now turned into Facebook, where the message is not even curated by the US's power structure but rather whatever narratives play to people's biases. Narratives pushed by malevolent foreign power structures whether bona fide countries or just non-allegiant capital looking to loot. Still, I have to believe there is a core of conservatism that won't be swayed by the reactionary populism, and will eventually succeed at ousting the destructive elements from their party or at least leaving themselves. The alternative is collapse.