3 ms·
> One thing I don't like about Apple's approach to security is locking the user out, making the OS like a black box. If we're talking about prevention of execu
by bayindirh 4y ago
> One thing I don't like about Apple's approach to security is locking the user out, making the OS like a black box.
If we're talking about prevention of execution of unknown applications, that's not existent. Right click any application, click open, and it'll show you the same warning with "Open" added. So, you can always override Apple's warning.
I like how macOS makes you read the warning box before making a decision, tbh. Yes, it's no Linux in terms of flexibility, and freedom, but I like the OS nevertheless.
- behnamoh 4y agoPeople have been talking bs about Windows for a long time, but I think Apple will do even worse than what MS did to Windows. As something gets more popular (in this case, macOS), unfortunately it falls victim to corporate greed (telemetry, forced updates, etc.)
- xenospn 4y agoto be fair, microsoft has been awful at this from the very beginning and got progressively worse.
- dlivingston 4y agoIt depends on the profit motivators. Windows fell victim to telemetry and forced updates because Microsoft’s business model might not be what you think it is. Apple has a simple business model for macOS. It exists solely as a vehicle for selling Macs - premium computers with (most importantly) a fat profit margin. Keeping the customer wanting to buy new Macs (and maybe that new iPhone…and that Apple TV+ subscription…) is what drives their OS to be, generally, much less user-hostile than Windows. The user is the customer; whether through direct hardware sales or through the subscription purchases those hardware sales lead into. Microsoft, in turn, sells Windows to OEMs and the business world via bulk licensing. You, the consumer, buying a Windows 11 license is not what’s funding Satya Nadella’s new private island. It’s Initech Corp. buying 5,000 PCs with Windows because “no one ever got fired for buying IBM.” Disclaimer: this is largely all speculation, and if I am off the mark, do let me know.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- itsoktocry 4y ago>It exists solely as a vehicle for selling Macs First, Apple now has a vast ecosystem which they are trying to promote, be it music, movies, TV, advertising, some of it requiring or optimized for their hardware. It goes beyond selling Macs. Second, Microsoft is also trying to sell PCs. I don't buy the idea that they can be explicitly anti-consumer and get away with it. Backlash against the OS would hurt MS's bottom line perhaps more than Apple.
- majormunky 4y ago> Second, Microsoft is also trying to sell PCs. I don't buy the idea that they can be explicitly anti-consumer and get away with it. Backlash against the OS would hurt MS's bottom line perhaps more than Apple. https://www.windowslatest.com/2022/08/30/former-microsoft-engineer-criticizes-windows-11s-new-start-menu-design-ads/ https://www.windowslatest.com/2022/08/30/former-microsoft-en... Having a start menu filled with ads with Microsoft, yet again, reminding everyone that Edge exists, is a bit anti-consumer in my opinion.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoOutlook on IOS pushes Edge every time one clicks on a URL. It's easier to uninstall Outlook than to get rid of that ad.
- cma 4y agoGmail wastes 10% of your mobile inbox screen real estate on a large bar at the bottom of the screen that's only function is to let you switch between email and their attempt at a Zoom competitor.
- vetinari 4y ago> Gmail wastes 10% of your mobile inbox screen real estate At least that one is easy to disable.
- selcuka 4y ago> So, you can always override Apple's warning. Sure, but the OP's comment is about Apple in general, not macOS. Try overriding the warning on iOS, for example.
- bayindirh 4y agoThe thing is, iOS's security and application model was like that since the beginning. Tech-minded people buying into Apple ecosystem knew these details from the get go. I personally accepted these terms before getting my iOS devices, for one. It's not like the Android ecosystem, which started as an open source free for all mobile OS, which iteratively locked and closed down, starting from Google integration to OS and boot loader level. Now, Google is preparing to throw Linux kernel out of Android for a even more tightly controlled Fuchsia kernel. I'm hoarding my popcorn and wait for the day when the hardware vendors stop building their Fuchsia drivers to control how they deprecate their hardware, and fine-tune their bottom lines. The response from the community will worth a watch. Also, in pure irony, Apple is preparing to allow application sideloading. Interesting times, indeed.
- GekkePrutser 4y ago> Also, in pure irony, Apple is preparing to allow application sideloading. Only because the EU is preparing to force them. Apple is still very strongly against it. Recently they listed a bunch of reasons why they think it shouldn't exist. But they know this is coming from the EU so they're probably trying to do it on their terms while they still can. Give as little as possible to the users to keep the EU off their back.
- mlindner 4y agoThat's just not true. Try to modify any system software and see what happens. (i.e. install a kernel extension). You're only talking about user-level modifications.
- jolux 4y agoYeah for that you have to boot into recovery and turn off SIP but then you can still do it.
- bayindirh 4y agoWindows is not at a different place. The boot chain is incrementally locked down. Also, due to unfettered access throughout Windows API, adding extra kernel modules was not widespread under Windows. Just because you can modify Windows, it doesn't make it a better place overall. We have witnessed what happened to it over the years. At the end of the day, I'm a Linux guy and strong GNU proponent. The reason I use Mac laptops because of the hardware & software integration they provide, plus I always keep a virtualized Linux installation at top of it. If macOS was not interoperable with Linux, I'd not be using it.
- scq 4y agoWindows also has a bunch of protections against modifying the kernel. Ironically this wasn't done to defend against malware but to defend against _antivirus vendors_ patching the kernel and making the system unstable.
- bayindirh 4y agoAh, thanks for reminding that. They've removed a bunch of hook redirection facilities IIRC, and all hell broke loose. I'm not using Windows as an operating system close to a decade, so I forget (or don't know) things like that.