7 ms·
American policy is splitting state by state into two blocs
- jleyank 4y agoYup. Follow the money. Will be interesting if the blue states ever decide to stop forwarding income taxes to Washington, claiming they're tired of paying for the red states. They can use the rhetoric of Alberta and Quebec if they wish... Perhaps compromise might be possible in future generations, cuz it's not a useful word today. Political polarization is pretty impressive worldwide at the moment.
- RichardCNormos 4y agoIt will be interesting if the red states stop selling food to the blue ones. There are plenty of buyers overseas.
- tayo42 4y agoPretty sure most of our human food comes from places like Mexico. Red state America mostly just grows stuff like corn. Idk if alot of that corn is even edible for people iirc
- nebula8804 4y agoIts commercial corn for feedlots and "bio-fuels": ie converting 1 gallon of diesel into 0.9 gallons of bio-fuels.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoNope. America's a strong net exporter of food.
- tayo42 4y agothat's not really how this works. just because a country export doesn't mean the country doesn't rely on imports see stuff like this https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/13/dining/fruit-vegetables-imports.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/13/dining/fruit-vegetables-i...
- spywaregorilla 4y agohttps://www.wlj.net/top_headlines/americans-consume-mostly-u-s--made-food-produce/article_a76f95f0-5857-11e8-8922-47f84163101f.html https://www.wlj.net/top_headlines/americans-consume-mostly-u... Or if you want the latest raw data from the USDA Economic Research Service, you can grab it here: https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/international-markets-u-s-trade/u-s-agricultural-trade/u-s-agricultural-trade-at-a-glance/ https://www.ers.usda.gov/topics/international-markets-u-s-tr... It's true, many fresh produce foods are imported, but the majority (~80%) of food consumed in the US is domestically produced / grown.
- tayo42 4y agoI think we're talking about different things. That 80% includes things like candy, beer, cereal. America isn't going to collapse if that disappeared.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoI'm not sure what that is supposed to mean. 80% reduction in food would be catastrophic and its puzzling to imagine otherwise. Not to mention the fact that a lot of that same food supply is exported to food insecure countries. It disappearing isn't on the table though. Candy is not a large part of the American diet so it's not really that meaningful to call out its inclusion. American agriculture is going to be more important than ever in light of the coming (present?) gas crisis. I'm not well informed enough to make a comment on Mexico but I would wager they're likely in a pretty good spot too.
- tayo42 4y ago
- jleyank 4y agoThe red states might grow it, but who owns the farms? I'm willing to bet there's not a lot of family farms left, and the conglomerates will go wherever the cash is best. Same with oil, as it's fungible.
- bediger4000 4y agoThere are hardly any family farms left. That way of life got swept away in the economic changes of the 1950s - 1990s.
- nebula8804 4y agoWould probably improve the diets and health of the union since all they produce is government subsidized corn garbage anyway.
- luma 4y agoAnd the blue states have plenty of money to buy food from wherever they like. The minority of America picking this fight are going to have a difficult time dealing with the results if they ever get their way. The country doesn’t need this line of thinking and it benefits nobody but Putin.
- bmismyname 4y agoCalifornia is the biggest producer of food in the US, by a huge margin (about 50% more than Iowa, the #2 producer). https://data.ers.usda.gov/reports.aspx?ID=17844 https://data.ers.usda.gov/reports.aspx?ID=17844 I would like to see how it breaks down by red vs. blue, and I suspect there might be a slight edge for team red, but California in particular fills an important niche of supplying most of the non-grain foods, and can produce food year round. However California is probably going to lose its status as #1 as aridification continues.
- silisili 4y agoThis argument doesn't hold much water when the people in California making the food are overwhelmingly red themselves. What happens if they leave, or decide to make their own little state? We shouldn't be bragging about punishments of blue vs red at all, because should such a thing occur everyone is going to have a much worse quality of life, blue or red.
- nostrademons 4y agoThe land makes the food, the people just tend the land. If the people move out new people move in to fill that vacuum. That's exactly what happens now with migrant labor.
- dmitrygr 4y agoDo you also think that factories make widgets, and the people working there just press buttons? Text editors make software, and programmers just mash on keyboards? There’s a lot more to farming than tending to the land. Crops don’t magically grow. Your simplistic view of it is both insulting to those who farm and dangerous.
- nostrademons 4y agoOnce labor gets commoditized, yes. The factories do make the the widgets, with the people working there pushing buttons. That's why there's all this hand-wringing about immigration, cheap foreign competition, unions dissolving, worker bargaining power, and capitalist abuses. If the workers made the products they'd just find new factories and this wouldn't be an issue. Programmers for now do make the software, in that there's a dramatic difference in the ability of a good programmer vs. a mediocre programmer to actually complete a project, and they're compensated accordingly. That'll likely change in a decade or so, though. Then the software will be largely already written, and it'll be maintained by management structures with commodity programmers slotting into roles in the org chart. It's already happening for many roles. It's a perspective shift from "here's a laborer making a product" to "here's a role for how the product is made, and any number of different laborers could slot into it", and it happens when there are enough people with the skills to make the product that any one of them can slot into it.
- danaris 4y agoHi, blue state New York here. I have no idea what actual percentage of the state's land is farms, but...I'm certainly surrounded by them. Many miles of farmland; plenty, at least, to supply the people around here, if used efficiently. The idea that "blue states are urban" and "red states are rural" is just plain wrong. There are cities in red states (though some red states don't have any large cities in them), and there's plenty of rural land in blue states. Welcome to nuance.
- bfgoodrich 4y ago
- itsoktocry 4y ago>Will be interesting if the blue states ever decide to stop forwarding income taxes to Washington Thinking of it state by state is a mistake, though, isn't it? Are "blue" states net contributors to federal tax if "red" citizens move out?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- somehnacct3757 4y agoI've seen this meme a lot, with wildly different calculated values and outcomes. (But always confirming the political biases of the bubble it was shared in, of course.) I'd really like to see a rigorous calculation and explanation behind the decisions, because I think this could be a useful stat for comparing states' fiscal success relative to one another. For example should the calculations include federal spend on federal employees? It's not really a reflection of the state's actions if the federal government happens to have a big agency headquarters there inflating the 'federal spend'.
- mrguyorama 4y agoI don't expect this kind of thing to happen. The very ideology of democrat's platform is : be generous and kind and help people. The Democrats in office can barely agree on even basic moves to get public approval, good luck ever getting them to agree on directly harming millions of people just because they don't agree with how they vote.
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> Will be interesting if the blue states ever decide to stop forwarding income taxes to Washington, claiming they're tired of paying for the red states It will be even more interesting if the red states then stop sending the blue ones things like food, water, and energy. It may turn out that those things are more important than simulated pieces of green paper.
- aaronbrethorst 4y ago“I think Mississippi has led on social and cultural issues for years,” says [Mississippi Governor Tate Reeves], and he plans to keep that lead. Though he declines to say which policies he and the Mississippi legislature will target next, “there will certainly be opportunities for us to do [more].” Meanwhile, one area that Reeves and co is most definitely not leading on is making sure that the capitol city of his state, with a population of almost 200,000 people, has potable, running water. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/us/mississippi-water-climate-change.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/01/us/mississippi-water-clim...
- metacritic12 4y agoJust observing neutrally: The lead that Tate Reeves is talking about is definitely in the opposite direction of what your implicit political stance's definition of taking the lead is. It's not the classic left definitions like minimum wage increase, or potable water, or expected age, or access to a public defender. I'm guessing it's things like having strict abortion control (or he would term it life preservation), or gun rights, or ability to reverse the Trump election results. Or, perhaps shockingly to the left view, "leading" in pushing laws so towns don't have the obligation to give potable water (and can avoid getting sued for doing so)!
- Ferrotin 4y agoIs the state responsible for the municipal government? Or would that be Jackson, MS’s voters?
- bequanna 4y agoBingo. Jackson’s inept local government failed to fix a known issue because they didn’t want to raise taxes to risk re-election. Now Federal taxpayers will be on the hook to bail them out. So… I guess mission succeeded?
- aaronbrethorst 4y agoInteresting way of spelling "white flight" there. https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a41043065/jackson-mississippi-white-flight/ https://www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a41043065/jac...
- bmismyname 4y agoCall me a "doomer" or whatever, but I think the inevitable demise of the US empire starts with balkanization (i.e., the states splitting into their regional factions). Basically like a second civil war, except it will look quite different and probably won't involve actual warfare. More like a slowly escalating defiance of laws at a regional level. Without wading into the trap of specific examples, I'd say we're already seeing this play out.
- sfvegandude 4y agoI would recommend reading up on American history a bit more. The US has always been a regionalist country, with a weak federal government. As for the decline of the US empire — not sure what you mean here, but if you mean the waning of American influence abroad, that’s already happening and it’s voluntary. If you mean the decline of the country internally, such as reduction in quality of life and decline in GDP/output, this is already happening with the demise of globalization, but the US will be the least impacted, not most, owing to strong demographics, variation in climate, rich natural resources, and ability to integrate immigrants.
- jgust 4y agoI interpreted the OP's statement as the literal breakdown of law and order. As in "Neat law your side created, but I'm not following it." The cracks are forming in things as simple as traffic laws. Tons of egregious, selfish actions and little-to-no enforcement.
- bmismyname 4y agoDon't get me started on traffic laws. People lost their minds on the roads around the time the COVID lockdowns started. I've always been anti-car, but the kind of insanity I see all the time now (people running red lights, driving on the wrong side of the road to go around traffic, driving on the shoulders on the freeway to bypass congestion) happens almost every single time I get in a car now. In particular, people here run red lights and drive on the wrong side of the road to make left turns constantly. It sounds anecdotal, but there's plenty of data to back this up: https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/early-estimate-2021-traffic-fatalities https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/early-estimate-2021-tra...
- MoscMob 4y ago
- paulv 4y agoAbortion bans impact liberals and others who didn't vote for Trump in red states. The majority of the country wants abortion to be legal. Making people suffer for the bad decisions that their states make is...disgusting.
- homieg33 4y ago> I want there to be natural consequences for people's actions. Like bearing a child after choosing unprotected sex?
- bediger4000 4y agoLike bearing an anencephalic child, when you are married and have a financially stable relationship? Because that happens, too.
- Fellshard 4y agoScathing contempt, dripping bile, and caustic blamecasting mark those with no awareness of their own culpability. Mind your response with great care, lest you find yourself to be at the root of the problem.
- algoatecorn 4y agoWell said.
- yardie 4y agoJust a reminder that the north and the south have always been in contention since the very founding of this country. We have a bicameral congress as part of the great compromise between high population northern states and low representation (enslaved didn't count) southern states. So you have 1 legislative body that closely matches the will of the voters and you have the other legislative body who matches the will of landowners. 1 voter in Wyoming has almost the same influence as 200 voters in California. And for a representative government, in the long run, this is unsustainable. Due to this and the impending climate change crisis I believe the US won't exist as we know it in the 22nd century.
- akshayB 4y agoThe real issue is that each party wants to blame other side and for all the problems. Negotiations and compromise are non-existent, and this is the real reason why progress is people feel that their progress is getting stagnated.
- alphabettsy 4y ago> Negotiations and compromise are non-existent This isn’t completely true. There are some high profile issues that are deadlocked on ideological grounds, but there’s legislation passed every session through compromise and bipartisanship.
- mindslight 4y agoI really wish people would stop using "conservative" as a synonym for "Republican". In 2022, the Republican party has no claim to the term conservative - about the closest thing one can say is that it used to be conservative, but as the world still continued to change it has now became frustrated and regressive. Conservatives respect institutions and customs - they most certainly don't reject and undermine them. I personally have always been intrinsically libertarian to my core, occasionally shifting perspective between left-libertarian and right-libertarian, but always wanting to disrupt existing institutions in favor of individual freedom. In 2020 I found myself voting for mainstream federal candidates for the first time in my life, arising from a sense of genuine conservatism. I had taken our institutions for granted, and now they seem to be under coordinated attack - by forces that aren't looking to reform and liberate, but rather to destroy and subjugate. I haven't been able to tease out how much is simply due to me getting older, but unfortunately I see this trend continuing. In 1973 Roe v Wade was decidedly radical. Five decades and nearly two generations later, women's right to reproductive medical care is an integral part of our society. True conservatism respects that.
- bediger4000 4y agoI wish I could agree with you, but I can't. It looks like the "conservative" doctrines were mostly held in bad faith, used almost solely as verbal cudgels, rather than as ideals to aspire to or guide policy. I'd also like to gently point out that you're doing a "no true scotsman" argument here.
- mindslight 4y agoThat seems markedly less charitable than what I said. You seem to be implying that there is no merit whatsoever in any conservative values. This may be great for rallying your own mob to fight, but isn't useful for convincing others or critically refining your own thinking.
- bediger4000 4y agoI'm all for refining my own thinking, but over the last 6-8 years, when I've tried, I've gotten a lot of insults. The most memorable was "latrine level liberal". I hadn't done anything to indicate my biases, merely asked a question about apparent contradiction. The closest I've come to a decent conversation, when trying to understand current conservatism, was a DM conversation on Reddit. I didn't learn a whole lot, the dude was basically operating on reflexes and subconscious. I'd really like to understand, but if repeated attempts end up with me getting explicitly insulted, I have to conclude uncharitable things.
- anonAndOn 4y ago"Mr Reeves boasted of his state’s other bans: on vaccine mandates; on teaching critical race theory; on transgender students taking part in school sports on the basis of the gender with which they identify. “I think Mississippi has led on social and cultural issues for years,” he says, and he plans to keep that lead." Let's not gloss over being the poorest state in the union also qualifies as leading the poverty rankings. Also having the lowest life expectancy is another. Oh, and dead last in public education. Way to lead Mr. Reeves! You're the best at being the worst!
- mrguyorama 4y agoI love that you're being downvoted for a very basic fact: The governor of this state cares more about making sure trans kids can't feel comfortable in school than actually making sure school provides value to those kids.
- somenewaccount1 4y agocounter opinion: forcing states to decide on abortion will turn the tide in democrats favor nationwide, creating a different sort of unification. While in the short term overturning RvW looks awful, and has terrible consequences for people in the present, in the long term the states will one-by-one elect politicians which protect that right. Some of it will happen in the next election, but even more will happen as the consequences of all these unwanted babies becomes clearer to both the woman bearing them, and the men forced to pay child support. The most common argument to my argument above is that some conservative states are deeply rooted in religion and wouldn't allow that. My counter to that is, you are discounting how many "pro-life republicans" have hypocritically obtained abortion while also railing against it. They will go to the voting booth and be just as hypocritical, likely criticizing in public the very same 'liberal' they voted for in private. My crystal ball says it's tired now, till next time.
- jandrewrogers 4y agoThis is an overly simplistic model of the politics. Roughly a third of Republicans are pro-choice. Roughly a third of Democrats are pro-life. And half of the country identifies with neither political party. Some parts of the country are socially conservative and politically libertarian, with a cultural norm of not legislating personal beliefs. These groups are not uniformly distributed throughout the country.
- somenewaccount1 4y agoRight. But the democrats that are pro-life will still vote democrat, because they are democrats. The independents are typically pro-choice precisely because they do not like government over-reach...and then it's those 1/3 of republicans that are going to turn the tide when they privately vote counter to their public identity.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoThere are further nuances. While a majority favors legal abortions in early stages, there is a very substantial group (across the political spectrum) that disapproves of late stage abortions (except in unusual situations, such as to save the mother's life). The issue has been polarized into two groups: 1) a single cell is a human being 2) a nine month fetus isn't a human being until the last foot has emerged from the birth canal. Many, perhaps most, think both of these positions are utterly ridiculous.
- bumbledraven 4y ago> … in the same session that it overturned Roe the court also struck down a New York gun law. There seem to be rights the court’s Republican majority wants the states to have and others it is less keen on. The article makes the Court's decisions here sound like a matter of personal preference. It doesn't mention their stated reasoning (even if only to argue against it), which, IIUC, is something like: the states have to follow the Bill of Rights, and the Bill of Rights explicitly lists the right to bear arms. In contrast, nothing in the Bill of Rights – or anywhere else in the Constitution for that matter – mentions abortion.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's not just state by state, red states were overriding their blue cities a lot with regard to COVID: https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/31/politics/red-states-blue-cities-coronavirus/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2020/03/31/politics/red-states-blue-... But also, most states are purplish and the ones that are purer red are very sparsely populated: https://purplestatesofamerica.org/ https://purplestatesofamerica.org/