9 ms·
Getting things down is obviously far less of a problem than getting things up. The hope is a long run situation where industrial activity is self sufficient en
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
Getting things down is obviously far less of a problem than getting things up.
The hope is a long run situation where industrial activity is self sufficient enough up there that less stuff has to go up. And most things are just coming down into the gravity well. That's the only way it could ever be economical, or ecologically sensible.
But I'm pretty pessimistic about our ability to execute to get there from here.
- ericbarrett 4y agoI think the problem with getting things down will be political. Any entity capable of precisely delivering enough mass to survive reentry from lunar orbit is now in possession of a weapon of mass destruction, equivalent to a small nuke. In the late 50s, the U.S. Air Force considered deploying "rods from God," essentially tungsten telephone pole satellites that could hit silos or other hardened targets at near-orbital velocity. Since they weren't inherently explosive, they skirted the Outer Space Treaty. Ultimately they were considered too provocative to deploy. Imagine a man-made asteroid with several times that mass, coming in from lunar orbit. I'd guess about 10x the energy of a tungsten rod in low orbit, if it wasn't aerobraked or what not. No state which lacks the capability would be happy about it!
- ryandrake 4y agoHeinlein explored this in The Moon Is A Harsh Mistress. Anyone with the ability to "violently land" small asteroids and/or large rocks on Earth with location precision will have enormous political power.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoTANSTAAFL. And it led the Moonies to a rebellion. And the AI Mike basically kills itself. No happy endings there.
- Thrymr 4y agoThe Moon Is a Harsh Mistress.
- rbanffy 4y ago> equivalent to a small nuke Not necessarily a small one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ericbarrett 4y agoPlugging some numbers into wolfram alpha, a 90,000 kg object (about 12 cubic meters of iron, for example) moving at the reentry velocity we'd expect from lunar orbit (10 km/s) would have about the equivalent kinetic energy of a 1kT nuke, which is quite small. You'd have to lob a really big rock at those speeds to get to the megaton range. (Or from interstellar distances, since energy scales with v^2.) Seems infeasible for a near-future lunar mining op. But it also demonstrates how powerful nuclear weapons are.
- rbanffy 4y ago> at those speeds It all depends on how fast it can be pushed by the mass driver, but the weapon would need to ingest ~4e+15 Joules to impart a megaton of energy into something. I wonder if there wouldn't be a point where the impactor would be squashed enough to fuse some tritium, but, then, it's no longer just a kinetic weapon.
- LatteLazy 4y agoI mean, that is already the case for anyone who can launch a satellite. So US, Russia, China, the EU, Iran, India, Israel, both Koreas and Japan. Which helpfully are the only people who could mine in space. So I don't think this is really a limit...
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYes, and in practice dropping such a death rock would be viewed the same as using a nuclear (or mass chemical) weapon, and the response from nuclear powers, etc. would be commensurate.