4 ms·
Lobbying is a particular kind of speech directed at lawmakers. It is difficult to imagine what kind of law can ban lobbying without having some sort of even wor
by jerf 15y ago
Lobbying is a particular kind of speech directed at lawmakers. It is difficult to imagine what kind of law can ban lobbying without having some sort of even worse unanticipated side effects.
It's a category error to think of "lobbying" as a distinct thing in itself that could somehow be banned, unfortunately.
- tomlin 15y agoIn my mind, it would be as simple as stating, "unless you're a single human being, your request will not be reviewed.". If you're representing a group of people, or a group of entities, you are disqualified from having an opinion on record. I know it sounds utopian and probably not "realistic", for whatever reason, but it would certainly even out the playing field.
- jerf 15y agoSo, when going to write laws on $TECHNICAL_TOPIC, it is now illegal for anyone in $TECHNICAL_FIELD to even try to advise the Congressperson. That's not progress. Oh, and before you answer that one objection, that's one I choose from many. You've killed way too much necessary speech with that restriction.
- tomlin 15y agoIt's hard to agree that my ideal world is without flaws, but towards the point you made, it wouldn't be hard to create an avenue for $TECHNICAL_FIELD to advise, not lobby, on $TECHNICAL_TOPIC. I'd imagine all sorts of restructuring would occur in the event that lobbying was banned. There is a clear and definitive difference between those who are grinding an agenda down your throat, and those who are offering expertise.