3 ms·
We live in a city. We had a BMW i3 with about 250km effective range in the summer, and a tad under 200km during winter. It got totalled (rammed in an intersecti
by magicalhippo 4y ago
We live in a city. We had a BMW i3 with about 250km effective range in the summer, and a tad under 200km during winter. It got totalled (rammed in an intersection) and we had to get a new car quick, so ended up with a 2017 Leaf. It has all the battery bars remaining, yet only gets 150km during summer tops, and less than 100km during winter.
For us, we noticed that the 250km was a minimum. The drop to 200km was manageable during winter, but we noticed it. The Leaf's 100km during winter is barely enough for daily use, and the 150km really isn't fun when we want to go to our cabin.
We knew the Leaf would have less range, but it really drove home that the next car must have at least 250km, but we don't really need significantly more than that. When going to the cabin or visiting family it was usually enough to just charge midways, which fit well with a short break for visiting the bathroom and grabbing some food or refreshments.
That said, after about a couple of days with the i3 it was clear our next car would not have an ICE. Just the lack of engine sounds when driving slowly (like in traffic or residential areas) and lack of exhaust fumes was enough for that.
- vba616 4y agoAs a rule of thumb, I believe that a plug-in hybrid typically has 1/10th the battery of an EV, and a non-plug-in hybrid has 1/100th. This is something I don't think people take into account when they say or assume that having two power sources is wasteful and that anyway, batteries are getting cheaper. You could also infer the relative cost by the unsubsidized price, but there are many rationalizations that blind people to that. The paradigm where an EV must have enough battery range for the maximum daily trip is like the paradigm where an ICE must have enough HP for the maximum daily acceleration. The virtue of hybrids is that they don't have to have either. Regarding exhaust fumes, you perceive any difference with a catalytic converter operating?
- magicalhippo 4y agoFor someone like us, which "only" needs 250km range, a hybrid just doesn't make sense I think. For someone who needs to regularly drive long distances it might be different, though there's something to be said for the reduced mechanical complexity of a BEV. > Regarding exhaust fumes, you perceive any difference with a catalytic converter operating? It's better when it's operating, but it's still noticeable in my experience. After a couple of years of being used to not smell fumes when sitting in the car, it becomes very noticeable when there's even just a tiny bit. If I lived up north where 250km is a short trip, I'd probably have a different view on things. But given that there's plenty of BEVs that fit our need, we definitely won't go back.