5 ms·
I don't like making people write code live. Some really good coders just don't work well with people looking over their shoulder. I prefer giving people a tak
by kube-system 4y ago
I don't like making people write code live. Some really good coders just don't work well with people looking over their shoulder.
I prefer giving people a take-home with an original problem to solve. Then, follow that up with a live call where you ask them some questions about it.
- rabuse 4y agoYep, that's me. I feel like an experiment when people are watching what I'm doing, even if it's something as mundane as browsing the web.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoI used to do a lot of work in an electronics lab that had a whole bunch of windows on one wall that looked out onto a hallway. That hallway was more or less the main passage through the building, so it was fairly high traffic. I used to tell people I felt like I was working in the engineer exhibit at the zoo.
- em-bee 4y agoi feel uncomfortable when people watch me browsing or worse reading email or the like, but not when coding. especially not when it's colleagues, since it is their project too
- rockemsockem 4y agoYou can still be coached through a take-home and follow-up though. I like to ask a very easy problem to start (some candidates spend the full 45 minutes on it) and then ask a similar problem after to build on it. If you work for a company there is some expectation of being able to work while people watch you. I don't like asking crazy dynamic programming problems, etc, but something simple and something slightly harder should be fine for someone who's good at their job.
- actually_a_dog 4y ago> If you work for a company there is some expectation of being able to work while people watch you. I don't know what kind of company you work for, but, in spite of the fact that every single technical interview I've ever had involved live coding, I've literally never had to write code in front of anyone at work. By "write code" I mean "write code that's expected to compile and run." I've done plenty of whiteboarding at work, but never anything like what happens in a technical interview.
- em-bee 4y agoyou never had to work through some piece of code together with a team mate? to get help or to explain to them how something works?
- actually_a_dog 4y agoThat's not in any way comparable to live coding in an interview, for multiple reasons.
- em-bee 4y agook, you are right. i brushed over this bit, which makes the critical difference: write code that's expected to compile and run for what it's worth, i never had an interview where this was required (except in a coding test, but that was without being watched while i worked on it) and to me it totally does not make sense especially for a whiteboard. making sure every semicolon or brace is in the right place would just be a colossal waste of time.
- kube-system 4y ago> You can still be coached through a take-home and follow-up though. Of course. Anyone who lacks the ability to complete the assignment can submit a solution written by someone else and be told how it works. Where they’ll fail in follow-up questioning is when you dive into their decision making process. I have only found one person to have cheated in an interview, and they were exceedingly easy to identify as a fraud when questioned in person.
- irvingprime 4y agoPersonally, when a company asks me to do a take home, I say no.
- nomel 4y agoWhat’s your approach? I don’t like giving take home because it’s too easy to cheat, and ends up being an exhibition in how much excessive effort someone will put in. But, I think it’s great if you can have a second discussion so they can explain what they wrote.
- kube-system 4y agoWhat do you prefer?
- ralphael 4y agoI've found that candidates have little or non appetite for take home problems. If they are busy interviewing, putting aside 2-3 hours (which is not much really) per interview, limits how many they are willing to do per week. As its still a candidate driven market. Keep in mind, people have to find the spare time while doing their jobs and living life. If they have a family - good luck finding spare time :-) The best win/win I've found is to pair with someone for about 30 minutes. You help each other, just like you do in real life.