2 ms·
There's lots of anti-EV FUD / hand wringing on social media about "how will the power grid handle all those electric cars?!" Meanwhile... few similar statement
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
There's lots of anti-EV FUD / hand wringing on social media about "how will the power grid handle all those electric cars?!"
Meanwhile... few similar statements about air conditioning. Which in my house -- and that of everyone else I know with an EV -- uses many times the amount of energy that charging a car does. Even when I was commuting 100km a day.
Air conditioning is the cause of pretty much all brownouts where I live here in southern Ontario.
Grid resiliency is obviously important on both fronts. And AC is critical. But it's also really expensive from an energy POV.
- JamesBarney 4y agoHmm that's weird I haven't seen any anti-ev fud. If anything it should stabilize the grid especially if they're smart about when they charge each night, and can feed a little energy back when needed.
- wincy 4y agoI’m pretty conservative compared to most HN posters and can see the immediate benefits of electric cars. Older conservatives drive me crazy, the FUD makes them seem really stupid. My uncle (and a friend of mine in his 50s) is constantly posting stuff about how much pollution EVs cause and I’m confused because the guy lives in LA. “Didn’t you live through smog? Don’t you think even a coal power plant with million dollar scrubbers producing your cars fuel is going to be cleaner than your combustion engine?” My line of thinking is, even if EVs DID create more pollution like he seems to think, it’d be better for the entire population of LA or any other city that the power be generated away from the city in a power plant and not from a million tiny poison spewing vehicles in LA! He just tells me I “need to do the research” and it annoys the crap out of me. For cities with pollution problems it’s so obvious that EVs are a win it hurts.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoClearly you don't spend any time on Facebook or in article comments sections. It's currently a barrage of two FUD and misinformation talking points "they're actually worse for the environment cuz [rare earth metals|lithium mining|they actually run off coal]" and "they're going to destroy the electrical grid." It's a remarkably effective campaign, and I suspect ultimately the propagation of these points were financed. I suspect a lot of the incredulity about energy use and EVs at this point comes down to people's inability to grasp that they're spending so much money on gas [cuz ICE vehicles are inefficient], but the equivalent milage on an EV at regular electrical rates charging at home is so much less. It's inconceivable to people how badly they're currently being ripped off. "There has to be a big catch." There really isn't. Hence I've been told I'm full-of-it when I make the entirely truthful point that AC costs way more than charging an EV for most commutes. People don't want to believe they're being ripped off that badly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nomel 4y ago> Meanwhile... few similar statements about air conditioning. I think this is an easy one. For people who live in hot climates, not having an AC can be a significant health/safety issue. Same with heat in cold climates. Having a ICE car over an EV car poses no immediate health risk, like this potentially does.
- twblalock 4y agoIf the power grid can't handle everyone running AC, how will it handle everyone running AC and also charging cars? EVs adoption adds stress to an already overstressed power grid. The grid needs to be improved if we want EV charging to be available to the masses. It's not FUD, it's just obvious.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThe grid needs improvement constantly always anyways. My point is that the specific grid related needs of EVs are not the roadblock to their adoption. My point is that: A far more serious problem for the grid is increasing temperatures and heat waves and the demands that increased AC puts on it. So in terms of emphasis ... "the grid" as a talking point about EV adoption is mostly thrown up as a smoke screen to discourage their adoption. And it is intellectually dishonest.