3 ms·
> But public health authorities in the US prioritized access to vaccines to racial minorities (who indeed had higher age-adjusted mortality rates than white peo
by pessimizer 4y ago
> But public health authorities in the US prioritized access to vaccines to racial minorities (who indeed had higher age-adjusted mortality rates than white people), while not doing the same for men. This is an ideological choice, driven by the idea that bad things that happen to men aren't worthy of social concern.
This would only be true if cities were largely sex-segregated, making it as easy both to target or ignore a particular sex as it is to target or ignore black people. Your ideology accusation is unnecessary, as there is a material difference between the specific situations of black people and males. In fact targeting aid towards black people consequently targeted aid toward black males (a subset of black people.)
And with that targeting, black people are still less likely to be vaccinated than white people, so black people clearly weren't targeted enough. Although it was nice to see white people having to come in from the suburbs for the first time in years to get a vaccination. It was like what black people in the city have to do to get to their "neighborhood" public school. It was sad that they set up networks to disproportionately take up early slots, though.
Take the likelihood of being vaccinated between black people and all males, against the disproportionate effects of covid on males vs women, the cost of specifically targeting men (by giving men a special app or something, or by prioritizing men over women?) vs the cost of specifically targeting black people (put the vaccination centers in or near black neighborhoods if possible.) Control for everything else. I'd bet if you calculated it out, you've saved a lot more person-years per dollar doing the plan they went with instead of your plan.
That's not even considering the fact that black people start in a median more precarious position than most other groups (other than maybe Native Americans and undocumented migrants), so between a black and non-black person, the median black person will have their mortality damaged more at the same severity of illness.
- scarmig 4y ago> In fact targeting aid towards black people consequently targeted aid toward black males (a subset of black people.) And decreased aid targeted toward white males (a subset of males.) > black people are still less likely to be vaccinated than white people, so black people clearly weren't targeted enough The same is true of men vs women, so men clearly weren't targeted enough either. Moreover, this entire comment thread is driven by the fact that men died a whole lot more than women due to COVID. That's ipso facto evidence that men were undertargeted. > the cost of specifically targeting black people (put the vaccination centers in or near black neighborhoods if possible.) Prioritizing who has access to a vaccine is cheaper than opening new vaccination centers in underprivileged areas (which fwiw I support). And it went further than this: in most localities, white men were explicitly deprioritized, having to wait a month or more longer to get access to the vaccine compared to e.g. black women, who were at lower risk. Also, by choosing not to apply a gender lens, public health authorities overinvested in black women and underinvested in black men. It's likely that if mens' higher vulnerability to COVID was allowed to be brought into consideration, fewer black people (and fewer people overall) would have died.