4 ms·
> While we believe we have an obligation to restrict the content that we host ourselves, we do not believe we have the political legitimacy to determine general
by mschuster91 4y ago
> While we believe we have an obligation to restrict the content that we host ourselves, we do not believe we have the political legitimacy to determine generally what is and is not online by restricting security or core Internet services. If that content is harmful, the right place to restrict it is legislatively.
Agreed, but realistically: for the near future there will be no legislative restriction in the US on harmful content. Congress is far too grid-locked for that, not to mention the question if meaningfully combatting hate speech and bullying can actually be done via laws or requires constitutional amendments - which are even more unrealistic.
Meanwhile, sites like KF (or rather: their users) will cause a lot of harm, including cyber-bullying people to suicide. At what point will you draw the line? Or clearer: how many dead people will it require?
The whole insistence on "we need a legislative solution" reminds me way too much of European inner politics on refugees: politicians all over the EU said "we won't deal with refugees on our own, we want an European solution" - all while knowing that thanks to the destructive-obstructionist Polish and Hungarian governments there was no chance of such an "European solution", and as a result nothing changed - and thousands paid with their life [1] as a result as they drowned in the Middle Sea.
In the end it's always the same: placing abstract morals over clear and provable actual harm to people's health and sometimes life.
[1] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/892249/umfrage/im-mittelmeer-ertrunkenen-fluechtlinge/ https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/892249/umfrag...
- tekla 4y ago> In the end it's always the same: placing abstract morals over clear and provable actual harm to people's health and sometimes life. Good.
- pjc50 4y ago?!
- nilespotter 4y agoIndeed. Plus these sites invariably come back online, it doesn't make a difference anyway. I just checked - The Daily Stormer and 8Chan are online today.
- immibis 4y agoIt will happen as soon as one of the dead people is a Republican politician or close friend thereof. Not a moment sooner.
- chmorgan 4y agoThis is a crazy take on responsibility. It isn't Europe's responsibility when people decide to take unsafe passage on the sea and drown. Could they do more? Yes, I'm sure they could, but are they directly responsible for drownings? No, this is too far. I'd argue the same for Kiwi Farms. If people are cyber-bullying (ie, reaching out to people and harassing them) then those people should be addressed. Arguing that any speech you or someone else deems "hurtful" or "hateful" should be banned is nuts, since no one has to go and read those words, its an opt-in process. AND, if people can disagree about whether something is really "hateful" then its even more difficult to justify taking action simply for communication of ideas that we find offensive. CloudFlare is in a tough spot that they put themselves in. If they'd like to avoid legislation then they've got to be the pipe, not the moderator. Once they switch to moderator they are responsible for all moderation. They can't pick and choose. Imo they'd be better served by acting as a utility and staying out of the moderation game. We've already seen a ton of attacks on free speech by powerful Internet companies, in the US at least the 1st amendment (freedom of speech) needs a defender like CF to help.
- mschuster91 4y ago> This is a crazy take on responsibility. It isn't Europe's responsibility when people decide to take unsafe passage on the sea and drown. Could they do more? Yes, I'm sure they could, but are they directly responsible for drownings? No, this is too far. "With great power comes great responsibility", a principle as old as civilized humanity. Germany alone is the fourth largest economy by BIP, and the entire EU as a whole the second largest. We have the capacity to help the people fleeing from the bullshit that was mostly caused by us in the first place, we actually have the rights to asylum in our constitutions, but we're not doing anywhere near what we actually could do.
- pjc50 4y ago> Yes, I'm sure they could, but are they directly responsible for drownings? No, this is too far. Several European states have chosen to prosecute volunteers rescuing the drowning, so they've definitely taken on responsibility for making sure that they drown.
- derefr 4y agoWhy does it have to be a US legislative solution? Any country CloudFlare serves could come up with a harmful-content policy for issuing takedown orders; and CloudFlare would likely have to obey that takedown order globally (not just to that country’s view) in order to be in compliance, such that their only other option would be to remove their POPs from that country and block all clients from that country.
- yanderekko 4y ago>Agreed, but realistically: for the near future there will be no legislative restriction in the US on harmful content. Congress is far too grid-locked for that, not to mention the question if meaningfully combatting hate speech and bullying can actually be done via laws or requires constitutional amendments - which are even more unrealistic. Alternatively, such restrictions would just be unpopular, especially if they were seen as likely to be enforced in a way that lacks due process. Asking for powerful private companies to effectively restrict people's rights as an end-run for democracy and due process is rightfully unsettling.