4 ms·
I don't know anyone who is well paid who goes on strike. I personally would gladly trade away any ability to strike for more money (which, in effect, I do). If
by roenxi 4y ago
I don't know anyone who is well paid who goes on strike. I personally would gladly trade away any ability to strike for more money (which, in effect, I do).
If striking looks like an effective path it means you are part of a system that is keeping you poor. The correct response is not to sit there fighting the system. We've seen how this game plays out, there are centuries of incidents to look back on. The system will win, and great efforts by the strikers will get, at best, a few crumbs while economic realities remain the reality.
Instead of playing a game they will lose, workers should adopt better strategies. Eg, grouping together and investing in capital, like what the winners of the game do. Trading away their ability to strike might be an accidental win on their part if it forces them to adopt economic strategies that work.
- epups 4y agoMate just look at labor laws and protections in the US vs Europe. Unionizing and striking is super effective for workers.
- roenxi 4y agoIf you try and connect those two sentences with a well laid out argument you might find it less clear than you think. There is a high correlation between people doing well and people who don't spend any time going on strike. Possibly in a world where the only difference between the US and EU was whether people went on strike that would be a workable position, but there are other differences. Quite a lot of them.
- epups 4y agoThere is a vast academic literature on the topic if you are truly interested. Here is just one such study [0]. The argument is in any case very simple. In countries where unions were historically powerful, especially in the post-war period, workers have collectively extracted several concessions, such as higher pay, better working hours and paid leave. In the United States itself, it is a demonstrable fact that unionized workers earn, on average, much better than nonunion ones, among other benefits [1]. [0] https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/ma.20.3585411 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/ma.20.3585... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/10/us-union-workers-report-congress https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/jun/10/us-union-wor...
- roenxi 4y agoIs that study even relevant? It just observes that Europeans work less than Americans. The question is hours vs pay. There are people on HN who can easily work 0 hours a week and thrash the earnings of the Europeans and Americans combined because they own capital. You're looking for these people to find a marginal tactical advantage by throwing away efforts to secure a meaningful strategic one. That is foolish. I'm telling you, I've read a lot of literature on the subject. There is no way I'm going to go on strike, it is ineffective and I'll end up worse off. Almost literally none of the people who are going to out-earn me are doing it by striking, and if anyone manages it that is one crazy fluke! It is a strategy for people who are already losing economically and may as well flail on the way down in case it helps. If people have time to organise they should organise to achieve good & sustainable results. Everyone could be a winner here.
- epups 4y agoIf you reduce the question to the narrow field of your own professional life, then of course you can make any claim whatsoever. Furthermore, I disagree strongly with your principles. We need to help people who are already losing economically, not the opposite. Doing otherwise leads to a broken society in which I have no desire to live in, even if I could personally earn 2x or 3x more there. I'm very glad the guy who picks up my trash has a union and leads a decent life, with access to education, healthcare and reasonable working hours.
- roenxi 4y ago> We need to help people who are already losing economically, not the opposite. We could try helping them by pointing out effective strategies and encouraging the ineffective to adopt them? You can't help someone who is adopting a failing strategy. If you push them ahead, their strategy will pull them behind. Someone who adopts an effective strategy in todays world is basically guaranteed to do well economically. Someone who adopts striking as a strategy is probably flipping a coin as to if they can even hold their wages steady. They've been trying for centuries, it doesn't work. If it worked there'd be evidence of it by now. Saving money and investing, angling to control capital works. The gap between the two strategies is overwhelming. Anyone who encourages striking as a strategy is undermining the welfare of the poor. It is a destructive strategy that wastes time with huge opportunity costs.
- medo-bear 4y ago> I don't know anyone who is well paid who goes on strike. I personally would gladly trade away any ability to strike for more money (which, in effect, I do) The salaries of Stevedores in the US range from $18,280 to $80,389 The salaries of Stevedores in Australia range from AU$110k to AU$129k Interestingly the Maritime Union of Australia has a reputation for being quite militant and left wing
- roenxi 4y agoI doubt you're comparing apples to apples, the difference in ranges is too big. Since 80k US ~= 130k Australia, maybe "Stevedore" in the US statistic is a wider category of worker? But regardless, that isn't an argument for anything. There is more at play in a salary than whether workers can strike - and you'll find strikes are largely a tool of people who are already losing at the get-well-paid game. Because it is a desperate and largely failing strategy. People in a good position don't strike because it isn't actually effective. If I thought striking worked, I'd go on strike. I don't. Note that I make a lot more money than the sort of people who go on strike. Not a coincidence. I'm not about to pass up on free money either.
- medo-bear 4y agoso adjusted for currency alone the lowest paid stevadore in Australia earns almost as much as the highest paid one in the US and five times more than the lowest paid one. to put this into perspective, australian stevedore gets paid as much as a mid-level senior developer in australia. australian economy very much depends on its ports. if these workers go on strike guess what happens to the rest of the economy. unions in this situation are then in a good position to argue for good rewards for their workers via collective bargaining. i dont think they would get anywhere near as much if salaries were negotiated on an individual basis
- roenxi 4y ago> so adjusted for currency alone the lowest paid stevadore in Australia earns almost as much as the highest paid one in the US and five times more than the lowest paid one. to put this into perspective, australian stevedore gets paid as much as a mid-level senior developer in australia. That isn't raising alarm bells for you that you've made an error in your reasoning? If strikes resulted in a 5x salary bump we'd see a lot of smart high-achievers striking. It is more likely you are comparing different categories that happen to be labelled the same here. 5x earning bumps for manual labour is more than hardball negotiating can achieve.
- Frost1x 4y agoThe writers actor guild strike comes to mind, although I admittedly don't know what writers tend to earn, so you might be right: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007%E2%80%9308_Writers_Guild_of_America_strike https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007%E2%80%9308_Writers_Guil... While I tend to agree that for individual optimization, fighting the system tends to be suboptimal, leaving and finding another system tends to be more optimal. The issue is that if everyone does this, over time, all systems will erode against labor rights and there will ultimately be no system to flee to. At some point people have to eat the cost and stand their ground to fight a given system, otherwise you will lose in the long run. We need people who stand up and fight.
- hospadar 4y agoI'm not sure if describe collective action as "a game they will lose." Labor laws and the 40 hour work week didn't just get handed down by well meaning capitalists. They happened because of decades of intense coordinated action, largely by unions. "Not playing the game" sounds a lot like a strike to me. Isn't "Grouping together and investing their capital" exactly what unions do? A lot of folk going on strike don't have the option to go elsewhere or find another job (which is probably the exact reason that a corporation feels they can underpay them). I agree that well paid workers don't strike, so i guess this corp should pony up some more money?
- drekk 4y agoThe "winners of the game" get a nice bailout from US taxpayers when they lose, so it's not particularly impressive. Striking is what got you a 5 day work week and an end to child labor. You may not appreciate the blood that was spilt for your cushy white collar desk job, but from there to tell people that collective bargaining is a waste and something only the poors do? Egregious.
- roenxi 4y agoIf only these large organised groups of citizens had some way to influence the political process? This is kind of the theme I'm getting at today. If they're organising and then spending all their efforts fighting their employer while the winning strategy is control of the legislature then... one might observe they've really screwed up their strategy? If there is one thing poor people have, it is lots of votes. The reason they don't get much value for them is they keep employing silly strategies (like striking). This is literally why these strategies get so much airplay despite it being obvious they don't get things done, they're divide-and-conqueror distractions because otherwise the effort might end up going in to meaningful politics or something. The organising part of the story is good, but after organising the next step needs to be going for useful outcomes that make people better off. Striking just does damage to everyone.
- chimprich 4y ago> I don't know anyone who is well paid who goes on strike. No, of course not. People usually strike for better pay or conditions. If you're well paid then you already have better pay, and are probably in demand enough that you will get good conditions or are in a position to negotiate. It doesn't really make sense for e.g. software engineers in the current economy to consider strike action. Workers don't want to strike in general. It's stressful and costly. It's not usually their preferred negotiating strategy; it has to be less worse than the alternative. > great efforts by the strikers will get, at best, a few crumbs It's easy to sneer at "a few crumbs" if you're in a state of privileged wealth. Sometimes small differences in pay can mean going from not being able to pay rent to having some disposable income. And, often, it's not "a few crumbs". > Eg, grouping together and investing in capital What did you have in mind? How does investing in capital help you with not being paid well enough to invest?
- roenxi 4y ago> People usually strike for better pay or conditions. I'm not following. What is your argument for why this is an effective strategy but employees only use it when they feel bad? It is more likely people always use the most effective strategies they have available to them. I want better pay and conditions right now, I don't care how good they are when I'm negotiating. I'm not trying to spare my employers feelings here, I quite like money. If striking works as a bargaining tool, we'd see it working for people who are economically effective too. My peers are more than capable of organising to strike if we thought that might get us an edge. I'm pretty cynical, I could make it happen. > It's easy to sneer at "a few crumbs" if you're in a state of privileged wealth. Sometimes small differences in pay can mean going from not being able to pay rent to having some disposable income. And, often, it's not "a few crumbs". I'm just saying, I'm not avoiding their tactics because I'm snobby. I'm avoiding them because I like money and the strategy may well lock in generational not-having-much-money. The proof is in the pudding for this one, people who plan on striking aren't the people who do well economically. > What did you have in mind? How does investing in capital help you with not being paid well enough to invest? If there are enough people for a strike that doesn't get laughed at, there are enough people to start investing in a better future rather than fighting and getting nowhere. Especially if they put their minds to making the future better rather than how to make life difficult for the employers.