My personal favorite, which did not make the list, is Anansi’s Goatman. The storytelling is solid, and it’s got the right amount of mystery to it along with th

My personal favorite, which did not make the list, is Anansi’s Goatman. The storytelling is solid, and it’s got the right amount of mystery to it along with the nostalgia of being a carefree teenager in a weird situation. I re-read it every few years when I think of it. https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Anansi%27s_Goatman_Story https://creepypasta.fandom.com/wiki/Anansi%27s_Goatman_Story