7 ms·
The locals in power have to want to do it too. As soon as enough don’t want it, it is over. I’m skeptical of the idea that you can impose Democracy.
by duxup 4y ago
The locals in power have to want to do it too. As soon as enough don’t want it, it is over.
I’m skeptical of the idea that you can impose Democracy.
- hotpotamus 4y agoRepublicans have long said that the federal government is structurally incompetent and unable to effectively administer a large country. They made a convincing argument with their performance in Iraq and Afghanistan, and I doubt Russia would have been much different.
- Apocryphon 4y agoThat was a very different situation, those were states that were militarily invaded and then occupied by American forces, who were involved in reconstructing countries devastated by war.
- codyb 4y agoYea, and most young democracies are very vulnerable. You can look at the Arab Spring for examples of failed democracies, and the early United States (it took us 20 years to get off the Articles of Confederation and work on the Constitution we use today). Myanmar's another one. India's been restricting its people's rights lately. Democracy takes a while to establish as a stable system and often fails. Alexander the Great was granting (non-representative) democracies to cities in Asia Minor 2400 years ago, I wonder what he'd think of Erdogan.
- AmpsterMan 4y agoThe Thirteen Colonies had a long history of democratic self governance. The revolution was mostly an independence movement. The revolutionary part was the Republican federation. This long history of democratic rule was not present in many modern attempts to establish democracies.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI'm not sure the average Russian would have seen the situation much differently. Look at the people today who decry chinese investment in the US economy? I'm not even saying those people are wrong. All it takes is for one person or group in the country to poke us enough to the point where we feel the need to strengthen our security posture there (read: add more troops) and then some terrible situation like Abu Ghraib completely destroys any credibility we have with the local population and it just spirals into disaster. I simply have no faith left in our government's ability to execute even a completely peaceful operation like the marshall plan (and similarly what we did in Japan).
- avmich 4y agoWhat's your proposition then? How it's best to go forward from where we are, if you don't trust the current organization abilities?
- hotpotamus 4y agoI used to find that drinking a lot helped but then my insides started to hurt. I'm thinking about maybe growing psilocybin mushrooms now.
- seanw444 4y agoRepublicans? Man, some people just can't get past the "my party vs your party" mindset.
- hotpotamus 4y agoFederalism is one of the core principles of the Republican party. I don't believe that's a controversial statement of fact, but I also didn't think vaccines or the shape of the Earth were controversial subjects, so I never know these days.
- nxm 4y agoPushing vaccines and forcing them onto people is (or they lose their jobs). Similarly, Democratic government forced many businesses to permanently close as they were deemed non-essential.
- hotpotamus 4y agoAs a child I was compelled to take vaccinations in order to attend school. My buddy in the military tells me he was "voluntold" to give blood for his fellow soldiers, nevermind all the vaccines they were required to take. Back then, vaccine denial was a loony left fringe thing, and now it seems to be a mainstream conservative position. Times change I suppose, but I do remember the old days.
- avmich 4y agoReading about successes fighting polio with vaccines, or just remembering a standard practice in American health system to routinely vaccinate people - with rather few exceptions - shows a big difference with COVID-related vaccine controversy. What's that different?..
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe biggest difference is Polio crippled kids and they were vaccinating kids, whereas COVID mostly kills grandparents and leaves most kids unscathed. Also, now we have facebook.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Republicans have long said that the federal government is structurally incompetent and unable to effectively administer a large country. To be fair, things probably work better when you don’t put people with that ideology in charge of said government. It’s like picking a flat-Earther as an astronaut.
- Maursault 4y agoRepublicans have long said any government is bad. They want Big Business to be unrestrained, unregulated, pure democracy, at the expense of individual civil rights. I can't tell the difference between Republicans and anarchists, other than the sad fact that nearly all Republicans vote adversely to their personal economic interests to stifle economic opportunity, in order to keep the very richest the very richest, for that one future day when they are the richest of the richest. It makes no sense, because that day will never come because they are voting to stifle their own personal economic advancement for the sake of issues skew to economics, such as abortion and 2nd Amendment issues. Really... if you earn less than $325K/year, as nearly all Republicans do, it is insane to keep voting that way. If everyone always ignored all other issues, and voted solely in their personal economic interests, we'd never see another Republican elected until nearly everyone was rich.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Republicans have long said any government is bad. Most republicans are not anarcho-libertarians. Asserting that any government is bad is fringe even among libertarians, and most republicans aren't even libertarians.
- hotpotamus 4y ago> “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are ‘I’m from the government and I’m here to help.'" -Ronald Reagan Perhaps you know that Reagan didn't really mean it, but it seems like many people believed him anyway.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Perhaps you know that Reagan didn't really mean it I think you surely know it too, Reagan was all too eager to use government power and his supporters were happy to see him do it.
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- Beltalowda 4y agoYou can't impose democracy, but if democracy and associated ideas such as the free market spectacularly fails the people – as it did in the 90s – then that certainly doesn't help. We probably could have done a thing or two to make it fail less. Would that have made a meaningful difference? Hard to say for sure, but it would have been worth to try.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoCertainly the west could have done more to prevent corruption and money laundering in western banks, but the opportunities were too lucrative and refusal too dangerous.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoNot "ideas" failed the people, but the implementers - which turned out to be straight up robbers, dividing past empire's industrial base amongst them, like western idol Khodorkovsky or Berezovsky. Where the politicians were less corrupt, the free market worked spectacularly well, like in Poland.
- ZoomerCretin 4y agoSo it wasn't real capitalism?
- Beltalowda 4y agoThere is no such thing as "real capitalism"; it's a broad and somewhat vague set of ideas with many possible implementations, none of which are more "real capitalism" than any other, although I'd argue that some implementations definitely better than others (and 90s Russia is a good example of that).
- ZoomerCretin 4y agoCapitalism is just an economic system with predominantly private ownership of the means of production. Whether a country's set of economically productive organizations are owned by shareholders via a stock exchange or by whomever was powerful enough to take control of them by corrupt means seems irrelevant, no?
- lapcat 4y ago> I’m skeptical of the idea that you can impose Democracy. We didn't need to impose democracy. Russia had democracy for a time. The Marshall Plan was about economic investment. The transition from communism to capitalism was a very rough one for the Soviet people, and that's a big part of why democracy failed.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Marshall Plan was about economic investment. The transition from communism to capitalism was a very rough one for the Soviet people, and that's a big part of why democracy failed. It was also about stabilising a war-torn continent’s economy. To keep them from going communist.
- munk-a 4y agoAnd it would've made a lot of sense to re-apply it here since Russia has clearly gone in a strongly authoritarian direction and is invading its neighbors. It's a pretty clear example of a destabilizing actor in the region.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it would've made a lot of sense to re-apply it here Absolutely agree with you. Long-term, I think the stable state for Russia is a deconstruction of the old empire and a global commitment to Marshall Plan the resulting republics into modernity.
- gernb 4y agoHow would you have applied it? Japan surrendered so they had a lot less say in how things where handled. No such thing happened with the USSR/Russia.
- KptMarchewa 4y agoThey had democracy of a Ryazan sugar flavor. Nothing compared to real one.
- jrochkind1 4y ago> As soon as enough don’t want it, it is over. Which worries me about the USA, it's pretty hit or miss at the moment. But there are also things that can affect who wants it, or what people think "it" is, or how they think you should get there. What people want is not an independent variable unaffected by anything else.
- hnhg 4y agoYou couldn’t impose democracy on many parts of the USA if it were suddenly removed, let’s face it.
- ghostwriter 4y agothat's good, as the US is a constitutional republic
- ZoomerCretin 4y agoDemocratic republic, which is what everyone means when we say democracy.
- ghostwriter 4y agoHardly everyone, but left zoomers who are unable to understand the key founding papers and who refuse descriptive comments of the founders on the matter most certainly do. [1]: "While often categorized as a democracy, the United States is more accurately defined as a constitutional federal republic. What does this mean? “Constitutional” refers to the fact that government in the United States is based on a Constitution which is the supreme law of the United States. The Constitution not only provides the framework for how the federal and state governments are structured, but also places significant limits on their powers. “Federal” means that there is both a national government and governments of the 50 states. A “republic” is a form of government in which the people hold power, but elect representatives to exercise that power." Federalist No_14 also had a lot to say on the matter: “In a democracy, the people meet and exercise the government in person; in a republic, they assemble and administer it by their representatives and agents. A democracy, consequently, will be confined to a small spot. A republic may be extended over a large region.” [1] https://ar.usembassy.gov/education-culture/irc/u-s-government/ https://ar.usembassy.gov/education-culture/irc/u-s-governmen...
- 8note 4y agoThe founders aren't very relevant anymore. Their system was bad, and the current one is better, though it keeps some of the old flaws they introduced as compromises for the time Based on your quote, they didn't understand that representative democracy is still democracy? The internet lessons the need for representatives, since we don't need to travel to talk to each other anymore.
- throw123123123 4y agoAll political systems are imposed, pragmatically and theoretically.