26 ms·
The problem is that it's cheap (in terms of time and cognitive effort) to raise objections, and expensive to address them (with explanation and demonstration of
by anigbrowl 4y ago
The problem is that it's cheap (in terms of time and cognitive effort) to raise objections, and expensive to address them (with explanation and demonstration of observational and modeling method).
Dishonest actors exploit this asymmetry to raise large numbers of shallow objections, in the hope that the audience will be excited by the drama of conflict and bored by the effort of overcoming the objections. Clever or charismatic actors can often win such conflicts at a rhetorical level, and are then naively imitated by people who are not acting in bad faith but want to copy a successful-appearing social strategy for their own benefit.
I got an early life lesson in this via a school debate. Assigned to refute the proposition that 'Brand X is the best cat food', I compared the ingredients from many different brands and noted that Brand X had a much higher percentage of 'Ash' - burnt matter following cooking. On the day of the debate I triumphantly presented my findings, and asked the audience why they would want to feed ash to their cats. My opponent then got up and said 'But maybe cats enjoy burning HASH' and got a huge laugh. Was it responsive or substantive? No, but I had said the word 'ash' too many times and his making a joke about that relieved the mild tension I had created with my overly-earnest argument. His team won the debate.