8 ms·
Spat at, abused and run off the road: why do some people hate cyclists so much?
- dont__panic 4y ago> “I’ve been cycling in Manchester for the last 15 years and I’d say that in the last two years, I’ve noticed a definite decline not just in driving standards, but also an increase in aggression. Close passes. And not really giving a lot of consideration to cyclists,” she says. I've also noticed this anecdotally in my own experience across the USA. Is it really just the pandemic fraying social norms and mental health? I haven't heard any convincing explanations of why this is happening, but it seems like I'm not the only person who feels this way. It could, of course, just be confirmation bias on my part. What do others think?
- ars 4y agoI think it's basically recentisim, combined with your personal change in maturity. And I say this because no matter the era people always say the same thing. From 2004: https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=gO0fAAAAIBAJ&sjid=n9kEAAAAIBAJ&pg=3606%2C941577 https://news.google.com/newspapers?id=gO0fAAAAIBAJ&sjid=n9kE...
- bobbylarrybobby 4y agoI agree, in New York City there were those few months of car-free bliss (because there simply wasn't anyone in the city), but when they ended cars came back louder and meaner. The aggression has not yet subsided to pre-pandemic levels
- dont__panic 4y agoI noticed the same in Denver. Those car-free peak covid months were incredible, and only made the return of the car commuter more depressing in comparison.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoPedestrian injury rates from cars are up in a big way across several metro areas in the US since the start of the pandemic.
- ipnon 4y agoTheoretically the safer you are the riskier you behave. Then if you’re in a car meeting a cyclist, you will have a propensity for road rage because you’re in no danger of a fatal collision, you’re shielded from attacks, and you can speed off and end the conflict at a moment’s notice. You have an egotistical feeling of power in your car because it’s true, you have the power. Roll the numbers a few hundred times for every car you see on a typical trip, and you’ll be accosted every time you take your bike out the door. A bicyclist’s life is not always worth much. It is common in NYC for a bicyclist to be killed by an SUV or truck, it happens on average every other week. It is just as common for the driver to walk away without so much as a ticket, because the bicyclist will have been found to have violated a minor traffic regulation, nullifying the driver’s culpability. A sad state of affairs that leaves bicycling for only the daredevils in most American cities.
- BugsJustFindMe 4y agoThroughout reading this whole article, I just couldn't shake the feeling that the question is much more broadly applicable than this. The article works exactly the same down to the small details for so many groups. Spat at, abused, and run off the road: why do some people hate cyclists gay people black people trans people poor people secular humanists immigrants jews ... Why do some people have so much hate for people who aren't causing them any harm and are just trying to exist in the world? > "People can behave aggressively towards cyclists because they see them as dehumanised" Yeah, if that isn't the problem right there in a nutshell I don't know what is. And holy smokes, just like for all the other groups, the proposed solution is for victim to dress differently so they don't stand out. What about a movement to eradicate the cult of dehumanization? Where's that program?
- lake_vincent 4y agoI mean, at the end of the day, it's just yet another symptom of how entitled these people feel to...well, anything. The message is: "These are MY roads. How dare a cyclist force me to slow down for 10 seconds? I'm IMPORTANT! Don't you understand how valuable my time is, and how critical it is that I arrive at my destination without delay? Roads for me, but not for thee." They act with the urgency of an ER doctor en route to saving lives. While going grocery shopping. I suspect that people who hate cyclists may also hate other groups of people who are not like them, and may be politically aligned with a party that fosters and embraces fear-based tribalism. Just speculation, probably wrong...
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThis applies in all directions: as a cyclist I see car drivers who behave badly, as a car driver I see cyclists who behave badly, as a pedestrian I see cyclists and car drivers who behave badly. I definitely see many cyclists who behave badly and who think that both road and pavement belong to them while the law does not apply to them... especially as a pedestrian (perhaps there's an aspect of relative 'power' at play). But an important point, I think, is that the cycling infrastructure in the UK is wholly inadequate, which certainly does not help cordial relations.
- rantallion 4y ago> as a car driver I see cyclists behave badly > is that the cycling infrastructure in the UK is wholy inadequate I recently had a cyclist clumsily drift into the outside lane of a 40mph carriageway at around 10mph with one hand on the handlebar. A few metres to the side of the carriageway? An incredible stretch of smooth, fast, dedicated cycle path, separated from the road by a wide grass verge. While he's one of the worst examples I've seen in a while, and not representative of all cyclists, he's proof that even the best infrastructure in the world won't stop some people acting like they own the roads and putting themselves in harm's way in the process.
- seadan83 4y agoThis lack of understanding and emphathy goes a long way. - Perhaps the cycle way had issues that made it un-navigable. Maybe it got tacked, had a load of glass, perhaps it was not smooth. You don't really know how bad some off-road areas are until you are 2 feet away (then you notice, oh yeah, this is rooted to crap, or there are other issues). - Maybe the cyclist needed to make a turn that was coming up? - Maybe the cyclist had joined the road way not long ago and was going to hop over - Maybe the road way was just safe enough rather than go on a path that significantly reduces speed of travel. A 20% reduction in speed, every day, two ways, over distance - adds up. It's not quite enough for something to be "safe", needs to be functional as well. If you make a commute be an hour when it could be 20 minutes instead, that infrastructure is not "perfect" (that is a real example, some infrastructure I've seen wants you to ride on super crowded side-walks where you can do at best 3mph for 2 miles. On the road that goes by in about 5 minutes, can sustain 25mph on it and 2 miles is done in no time; and this is just one two mile stretch of a 6 mile distance). > he's proof that even the best infrastructure It turns out what looks like "the best infrastructure", is really often a sad joke when you try to ride in it. Protected lanes sound nice, but turning left (in the US) out of one is a nightmare and is super dangerous because nobody can see you or is expecting for you to cross lanes. This again goes back to perspective. Those protected lanes might seem lovely, but in practice can be totally useless. The far edge of the road might look ideal, but if you look at it you'll see it's uneven, full of debris, has grates, and places where the road crumbles away and is not even there. You won't notice these at all traveling faster than 20mph (let alone at 50mph) and from 20 feet away.
- winternett 4y agoI don't hate cyclists nor pedestrians at all, I am one at times. No ne should ever be assaulted in that manner... What perplexes me though is how hostile both bicyclists and car drivers are becoming towards each other lately, and the only thing I can imagine that is driving the ire is online partisanship or the "us versus them" ideals that the Internet creates, which in reality is really not sane. There is some kind of shadow campaign across Reddit right now ... r/fuckcars that threatens the very meaning of the right to own personal property in the world. It has also become kind of a brigade that lobbies and protests in many other online and real world places too, without any clear message or leadership. I may be wrong, but it seems like a lobby run by people who want bicycles and public transportation to be the norm for everyone worldwide. The logic seems highly unreasonable in a capitalist society at least, and as infectious disease threatens us all that these solutions could ever be imposed on a free society of people. That also being said, pedestrian, public transport, and bicyclist infrastructure is also majorly funded in part by car-related taxes, to which there is no alternate source of funding if cars completely go away, meaning that biking, public transport, and walking would all see new taxes... Just imagine having to pay a daily toll just to walk across every single bridge you use, and then another toll to be able to walk or bike through a residential neighborhood. It's very mysterious what the end game is for the r/fuckcars subreddit lobby, is it to sell bicycles? Or run by government employees that ride bicycles to work? I took some time to look into a few posters and found many of them spoke about the cars they own in other subreddits, so it's all very confusing to someone like me. Tons of money is being wasted on alternate bike, pedestrian, and public transport infrastructure that just doesn't work to improve safety and harmony on roads by cities every year, there needs to be some sort of accountability for whoever is driving those decisions. That being said, it's also quite hard to cart a newborn along with your grandparents to the hospital or to evacuate a city during crisis in snow, rain, tornadoes, and freezing cold weather on a Schwinn... I think we all need a better dose of reduced sensationalism and more rational thought in this world when it comes to public safety and transportation, without veiled political agendas pushed online for profit.
- acheron 4y agoReminder that reddit is basically all trolls. There is no “end game” for anything going on there.
- exabrial 4y agoA close friend works in the ER. Every time a cyclist comes in, it's very bad. I don't think road cycling is worth the risk without sticking to places with engineered barriers. I'll stick to gravel and mountain biking, where at least my risks are set by me.
- rngname22 4y agoSort of buried the lede in this one. Seems like the obvious answer is running of red lights, passing between cars or in gaps that feel dangerous to nearby drivers, going slowly such that those behind the rider are forced to drive way below speed limits, etc. Before I get pounced on, not saying those reasons justify the level of vitriol or the actions of unhinged drivers or pedestrians. Asking why the level of outrage towards cyclists is so disproportionate to the offenses committed by some cyclists is a good question, asking 'why would anyone ever be mad at bicyclists?' is not.
- seadan83 4y agoOn the flip side, can cyclists become reflexively mad at every car they see? Consider how many a-holes are out there when you drive, those a-holes are also dangers to cyclists and everyone else. Should confirmation bias then dominate how we interact with anyone at all? (The reason I point out those aggressive drivers, they actually do violate more road laws than your average cyclist. I know that sounds controversial, but the majority of cyclists are out of sight on paths/quiet roads, obeying traffic laws. Meanwhile those aggressive drivers are speeding 100% of the time, running stop signs, even blowing red lights. The cyclists that are often seen and running around blowing lights, are a vast minority, just as are the overly aggressive drivers).
- michaelcampbell 4y agoAgree 100%. In addition, bikes were legislated to be allowed on roads that were simply not built for them. Not their fault, but it creates a hazard for them AND drivers of vehicles for which they WERE built. I once had a colleague (an avid cyclist) rage, without a hint of irony, how "his" special built bike paths in and around our rural area were suddenly allowing inline skaters to partake.
- crmd 4y agoIt’s the egregious rate of moving violations that has turned me off to bicycle activism. I see maybe one car a week run a red light in my Brooklyn neighborhood, versus hundreds of bicycle riders. It’s been over a decade since I saw a car driving the wrong way down a one way street, versus a dozen bicycles per day. I’ve never seen a car drive on the sidewalk, but I see a few dozen bicycle riders per day drive on the sidewalk. And yet the bicycle activists in nyc are shouting for the police to crack down on cars, when bicycles are committing easily 100x more moving violations per mile driven.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoMy pet theory is that they stress drivers out, similarly to the bit they mention about the cyclist getting a rush of adrenaline when they're nearly killed by a car. Nearly hitting someone is still a shock, even if it's less of one. People don't respond rationally to stress, so you're not going to get someone shouting "you stressed me out there for a second, but I took a deep breath and got over it, no harm done" out of a window. But pretty much anything that stresses people will lead to angry outbursts which at that point will not be logically connected to the trigger.
- scohesc 4y agoNice of the Guardian to re-affirm its political biases by placing a blame jab to the "right wing media" in the subtitle of the article. Cyclists should be held to the same standard of traffic laws as vehicles are - full stop. Too many times I see cyclists: - Flying up on the right of a car when there's less than reasonable amount of room to squeeze between the car and the curbing. - Deciding to "run" red lights and choosing between the roadways or the sidewalks when it's more convenient for them. - Not wearing a helmet (subject to location but some places it's the law) - Not stopping at 4-way stops, not signaling their intent to turn/stop. - Multitudes of other illegalities/dangerous activity on the roadway. Bikes do not belong on roads. Like it or not society has decided that to get around in first-world countries (america centric here), you use a vehicle. It'll be a slow process to move towards bike-friendly traffic and more central walk-around locations to slowly wean us off using vehicles for everything. I'm not sure having cyclists weaving in and out of traffic made up of multi-ton death machines is a good idea either - I guess "rider beware" applies. The best thing would be to make sure any bikes and their riders that are on public roadways are licensed and train current law enforcement to fine/arrest any unsafe cycling habits. (we do this with cars and trucks already, why are cyclists seemingly exempt?) I don't have too much knowledge about current cyclist laws since I don't ride a bike and mainly drive, but I welcome more local traffic like bikes/walkers and less vehicles in urban centers.
- doublerebel 4y ago> Cyclists should be held to the same standard of traffic laws > I don't have too much knowledge about current cyclist laws Cyclists mostly put themselves in danger. Drivers mostly put others in danger. That's why traffic laws should be, and are, more enforced for drivers vs cyclists or pedestrians. There is plenty of historical precedent for cyclist laws and behavior -- including encouraging 'running' red lights and not stopping at 4-way stops -- if you look into it.
- scohesc 4y agoI wonder if it's an enforcement problem. I don't like this "enforce vehicles more than cyclists" when both types of traffic are using the road. Police know they can't get large fines out of people who ride bicycles - unfortunately it seems a lot of cyclists might not be able to afford a riders license, or registration for their bike - maybe that's why enforcement is so low? I don't know all the factors and everywhere in the world is different with their laws and enforcement avenues.
- prirun 4y agoI don't hate cyclists, but in our local cities, they (city officials) are doing incredibly stupid things to make it appear they are accommodating bicycles, when actually, they're endangering everyone. We have a heavily-trafficked, 2-lane (1 each direction), hilly, winding road that runs along the river and is part of the Ohio River Scenic Byway. This is an old road that doesn't even have a place for cars to pull over: you would be in someone's yard or on a recently-installed sidewalk if you did that. Widening this road would be a major undertaking because of all the houses and businesses involved. So rather than do that and add a real bike lane with barriers, our wise city officials put a big bicycle emblem in the middle of each lane to make cars and bicycles equal on this road. This is called the Ohio River Scenic Byway because you are supposed to be looking at the scenery. Doesn't seem like a good idea to be looking at scenery when there are bikers in your lane. In another city with similarly narrow roads, the city decided they would just paint a bike line on the road. These roads were barely wide enough for modern SUVs. In some places where the road narrows even further, the bike lane just "disappears", then starts back up a block or 2 later when the road widens a bit. While I don't hate cyclists, I do hate that cities are making stupid and unsafe traffic changes so they can say they have a bicycle-friendly city. Nothing could be further from the truth. When there is a bad-enough accident where people are killed, THEN the road will be widened and all that.
- doublerebel 4y agoThis Shared Lane Marking is also known as a 'sharrow' (a combination of the words "share" and "arrow"). Sharrows are generally regarded as a dangerous non-solution, as you describe. > Results suggest that not only are sharrows not as safe as bike lanes, but they could be more dangerous than doing nothing at all. https://macwright.com/2020/12/04/sharrows.html https://macwright.com/2020/12/04/sharrows.html
- kurupt213 4y agoI get stressed out when there are cyclists on narrow roads with blind turns and no shoulder. I don’t want to run anyone over but the odds that I will are definitely greater than 0 and it’s not my fault
- tomatotomato37 4y agoOne easy explanation I see is that people who are asshole drivers don't stop being assholes once they get on a bicycle. If you don't have the decency to use the blinker in your Audi I can't see you having the decency to also not cut across road traffic when wearing your Lance Armstrong lycra
- xnx 4y agoConsider how upset some drivers get when passed by a car, now multiply that by 10x when drivers see a bikes cruising past blocks of cars stuck in traffic or at a red light.
- xscott 4y agoMost of this discussion is a "cars are bad and drivers are evil" circle jerk, so I'm compelled to point out that when the tables are turned, cyclists are the bigger assholes. I routinely take walks on a "multi use" path. It's intended for walkers, joggers, roller bladers, skate boarders, and yeah cyclists. The cyclists are the only ones who yell at people they pass. It's a park, no cars in sight. And these Lance Armstrong wannabes wearing their logo covered shirts (as though they're sponsored) can't stand to be inconvenienced so they bark at everyone else. God forbid they should have to slow down and re-accelerate to avoid hitting someone who is walking, so they pretend that it's the walkers who are dangerous. Entitled fuckers. I've been yelled at and threatened by cyclist more times than I can count. I'm tempted to carry bear spray with me because these aggressive jerks frighten me. So yeah, fear breeds hatred, and I hate them. I have zero sympathy for cyclists on the roads, because I know how they act on the sidewalks in the parks. This isn't new, and I've seen this in multiple cities in different parts of the country where I've lived.
- josephcsible 4y ago> these Lance Armstrong wannabes wearing their logo covered shirts (as though they're sponsored) can't stand to be inconvenienced so they bark at everyone else. God forbid they should have to slow down and re-accelerate to avoid hitting someone who is walking The best part about this is that when these jerks are on the roads, they have no problem inconveniencing drivers in the exact same way that they complain about happening to them on the sidewalks.
- xscott 4y agoYes, the hypocrisy is so thick it's suffocating.
- Fricken 4y agoAnd Drivers are even worse than cyclists!
- josephcsible 4y agoDrivers generally don't drive their cars along sidewalks.
- rektide 4y agoSome % of drivers honk at each other any time they are even mildly inconvenienced. Someone trying to park? Honk. Someone waiting for pedestrians with right of way to cross? Honk. Someone slow rolling towards a red light?. Honk. A huge amount of this world is intensely short on scope, who dont really get beyond their first level emotional reactions. Very very very small & short OODA loop that they are mostly along for the ride on, hardly really deciding in. Cycylists are unexpected. They- rightfully- have their own different circumstances they travel by. People already barely handle the very basic situation of driving at all, are already trapped in their aperceptiveness, trapped uncomprehending the potential limits of observability about them. Theur willingness to ease off, relax, allow some floe around them from fadter moving better/less encumbered forms of transit is low.
- senectus1 4y agoin australia its because there is a pervasive and incredibly poorly informed belief that roads are for motor vehicles only. Australians have a "Darwinian" style to road usage. the bigger, louder faster or more agressive you are on the roads the more rights you have. I really enjoy disabusing people of this notion.