4 ms·

Scheme in C++

25 points by mmisu 15y ago

VMG 15y ago
Code is unreadable (I have to scroll horziontally). Better paste it as a gist.
- ahy1 15y ago
  It is available at github (https://github.com/sol-prog/schm https://github.com/sol-prog/schm) and readable.
- mmisu 15y ago
  The first version of the code was assembled in a few hours and badly structured. The new code from github is more readable: https://github.com/sol-prog/schm https://github.com/sol-prog/schm
li-ch 15y ago
This was the OOP course project in my UG. Spent an entire semester on it. http://www.cse.ust.hk/~dekai/151H/ http://www.cse.ust.hk/~dekai/151H/
agentultra 15y ago
Scheme has a really simple syntax but wouldn't this code be a little more readable with separate lexing, parsing, and evaluating steps?
- mmisu 15y ago
  The code is open source (GPL3), feel free to fork it from github and modify it.
eliben 15y ago
There are a lot of Scheme implementations floating around the web, in any language you can imagine. I have one of my own (shameless plug: http://code.google.com/p/bobscheme/ http://code.google.com/p/bobscheme/) in Python & C++, and there are many others, at least some of which are better than mine in some respects. The implementation linked here is IMHO badly written - that's not good code to learn from. So if your goal is to learn how to implement Scheme, I suggest to look elsewhere. For example, one good resource is Scheme from Scratch: http://michaux.ca/articles/scheme-from-scratch-introduction http://michaux.ca/articles/scheme-from-scratch-introduction Note that this is nothing personal, I just frankly think this is not good code to learn from.
- bitcracker 15y ago
  Racket Scheme (http://racket-lang.org http://racket-lang.org) is a good Scheme implementation and provides plugins for other languages. C, for example: http://planet.racket-lang.org/package-source/jaymccarthy/c.plt/1/2/planet-docs/c/index.html http://planet.racket-lang.org/package-source/jaymccarthy/c.p... Plugin Database: http://planet.racket-lang.org http://planet.racket-lang.org
  - eliben 15y ago
    Racket is good, but I think the discussion here is more about educational implementations - small, simple to grasp. There are of course also a number of industrial-strength implementations of the Scheme language in C and C++, but those are hardly the best place to start this learning!
bhickey 15y ago
Guile is worth mentioning here. Mature, LGPL and widely used. It supports R5RS and most of R6. It has hygienic macros. If you're looking to use a Scheme in production, you probably want Guile. Stalin and Chicken Scheme might also be worth a look if you aren't faint of hearth. http://www.gnu.org/s/guile/ http://www.gnu.org/s/guile/

Scheme in C++

25 points by mmisu 15y ago

VMG 15y ago

Code is unreadable (I have to scroll horziontally). Better paste it as a gist.

ahy1 15y ago
It is available at github (https://github.com/sol-prog/schm https://github.com/sol-prog/schm) and readable.
mmisu 15y ago
The first version of the code was assembled in a few hours and badly structured. The new code from github is more readable: https://github.com/sol-prog/schm https://github.com/sol-prog/schm

li-ch 15y ago

This was the OOP course project in my UG. Spent an entire semester on it. http://www.cse.ust.hk/~dekai/151H/ http://www.cse.ust.hk/~dekai/151H/

agentultra 15y ago

Scheme has a really simple syntax but wouldn't this code be a little more readable with separate lexing, parsing, and evaluating steps?

mmisu 15y ago
The code is open source (GPL3), feel free to fork it from github and modify it.

eliben 15y ago

There are a lot of Scheme implementations floating around the web, in any language you can imagine. I have one of my own (shameless plug: http://code.google.com/p/bobscheme/ http://code.google.com/p/bobscheme/) in Python & C++, and there are many others, at least some of which are better than mine in some respects. The implementation linked here is IMHO badly written - that's not good code to learn from. So if your goal is to learn how to implement Scheme, I suggest to look elsewhere. For example, one good resource is Scheme from Scratch: http://michaux.ca/articles/scheme-from-scratch-introduction http://michaux.ca/articles/scheme-from-scratch-introduction Note that this is nothing personal, I just frankly think this is not good code to learn from.

bitcracker 15y ago
Racket Scheme (http://racket-lang.org http://racket-lang.org) is a good Scheme implementation and provides plugins for other languages. C, for example: http://planet.racket-lang.org/package-source/jaymccarthy/c.plt/1/2/planet-docs/c/index.html http://planet.racket-lang.org/package-source/jaymccarthy/c.p... Plugin Database: http://planet.racket-lang.org http://planet.racket-lang.org
- eliben 15y ago
  Racket is good, but I think the discussion here is more about educational implementations - small, simple to grasp. There are of course also a number of industrial-strength implementations of the Scheme language in C and C++, but those are hardly the best place to start this learning!

bhickey 15y ago

Guile is worth mentioning here. Mature, LGPL and widely used. It supports R5RS and most of R6. It has hygienic macros. If you're looking to use a Scheme in production, you probably want Guile. Stalin and Chicken Scheme might also be worth a look if you aren't faint of hearth. http://www.gnu.org/s/guile/ http://www.gnu.org/s/guile/