11 ms·
Global warming changes the probability distribution of weather. This is not an especially easy concept for the layperson to understand because a simple "caused
by pjc50 4y ago
Global warming changes the probability distribution of weather.
This is not an especially easy concept for the layperson to understand because a simple "caused by" isn't appropriate. Any reduction to global warming would result in different weather. There would still be storms. The best we can say is there would likely be fewer storms and less drastic storms if there was less global warming. But as with the pandemic, people like a nice clean binary cause/did not cause distinction to things that are fundamentally statistical processes.
- hackerlight 4y agoThis is the only statistically literate perspective.
- kurupt213 4y agoYou mean like how the Atlantic hurricane season is abnormally quiet?
- bumby 4y agoThere's a higher comment that addresses this. It can effect the overall range of events, meaning both ends of the spectrum. A clearer example is that is can increase the probability flooding as well as droughts; they don't have to be mutually exclusive.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoYes. It's always been about more extreme weather - more droughts, more floods, more tornadoes, more hurricanes, more extreme storms, heavier snow storms, and so on. Most areas will get warmer, some areas will get colder. Sometimes they'll alternate. Some years and seasons will be less extreme than others, some will seem normal, but the trend will be clear. Systems which were built for the old normal will fail more and more frequently, and at some point they'll stop working permanently.
- WorldMaker 4y agoSame with it can cause unseasonably cold days and unseasonably warm days, those aren't mutually exclusive and the range of extremes is expanding in many regions. Which remains a big reason to avoid "global warming" as a term anymore when discussing climate change. Even extreme winter storms are a consequence of climate change and the additional energy in the climate affecting all types of weather. Early climatologists phrased it as a growth in heat in the planet and that earned the nickname "global warming", which is correct enough on a long enough scale, but the real problem of climate change is that it is a ton of additional energy (per Thermodynamics Laws same thing, different side of the equation) in the climate. (For instance, additional energy in the case of winter storms meaning stronger winds which mean lower wind chill temperatures and more precipitation [snow].)
- gadders 4y agoAs you will find, climate change is unfalsifiable.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoClimate change is completely falsifiable. All you have to do to falsify it is prove this graph is inaccurate. Good luck. https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-global-temperature https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/...
- seti0Cha 4y agoComments like this do more harm than good. No, that's not all they have to do. Somebody will come along presently with another graph that shows how this graph is misleading and declare victory. This comment is harmful because it strawmans your own point and on top of that, it's smug. It's the opposite of convincing.
- anigbrowl 4y agoInterestingly, the greater the number and quality of our observations, the more casually such observations are dismissed on the basis that we didn't always have such observational capacity. It's alleged in turn that observed events have been taking place the whole time, but weren't measurable, at least not with such accuracy as to be useful.
- importantbrian 4y agoAs someone who lives in a hurricane prone area I hope you knocked on some wood after saying that. 75% of named storms occur after August 20th and NOAA still expects and above average season. There is some evidence that the high wind shear and dry air that has been impeding storm formation is starting to subside. I also think this comment makes the parent's point about probability distributions being difficult for people to understand. Global warming doesn't mean every hurricane season will be more intense than the one before it. Just that the probability distribution will shift. That might mean more intense seasons on average it might not. I'm not enough of an expert on it to know, but the consensus seems to be that they will become more intense on average. I could see a situation where a warming environment could lead to more of the wind shear and dry air that is keeping formation down this year though. Either way one below average hurricane season after 2 really active ones doesn't tell you that much.
- kurupt213 4y ago>doesn’t tell you that much I agree
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- taneliv 4y agoHow about framing it differently? To say something like: "of the five recent weather catastrophes (off the top of my head: this Pakistan monsoon, Europe drought, California drought, heatwave in India, heatwave in Spain), we can confidently say at least four were caused by climate change, and perhaps, perhaps one wasn't. Which one? It doesn't matter, and we don't even know if it wasn't." might be correct and understandable enough?
- jfim 4y agoTo the lay person, this sounds like "the scientists can't even figure out which ones were caused by climate change, how are we supposed to believe them." A better explanation is along the lines of "we haven't seen such a drought/flood in 100 years, and climate change makes these extreme events more likely to happen."
- GauntletWizard 4y agoJapanese Tsunami Stones wish to have a word with you about cycles and long-term probability. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/21/world/asia/21stones.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/21/world/asia/21stones.html
- verisimi 4y agoIf there was no climate change but you have the world to look at, you would still be able to find several extreme weather events every year. As we don't have a handle on _all_ weather events, we are prone to think these events are somehow exceptional, when all that is happening is that this is where the media focus is at present. If the media decided to focus on some other topic, eg siamese twins, or accidents in the military, or whatever, we would soon think we won't get a seat on the bus for conjoined twins, or imagine that every soldier is likely to be killed by friendly fire. It is impossible for us to faithfully discern truth from the media presentation.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYou're making two arguments here: that if we don't know everything, we don't know anything, and that we're incapable of deriving truth from media reports. Neither is true. We often have adequate priors and when individual perceptions aren't sufficient statistics offer a base of comparison. Media bias and cognitive biases exist, of course, but uncertainty and bias can also be measured and mitigated. It's notable that sometimes the loudest complaints of media bias come from competing media outlets with lesser or negative commitment to reliability.
- aeroman 4y agoI think there is one extra point though - that these events can be much, much more frequent. When an event is 100 times more likely, you are getting very close to a 'caused by' situation. Obviously, extreme events existed in the past. But something like the 2022 south Asia heatwave was so extraordinarily rare before, when climate change increased the frequency of similar events by more than 100 times, climate change was responsible (in most reasonable uses of the word). https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/press-office/news/weather-and-climate/2022/southern-asian-heatwave-attribution-study-2022 https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/press-office/news/weat...