3 ms·
Slippery slopes are a logical fallacy for a reason. We live in a society, I don’t see how giving out basic information to law enforcement with a court order is
by kaba0 4y ago
Slippery slopes are a logical fallacy for a reason.
We live in a society, I don’t see how giving out basic information to law enforcement with a court order is somehow a fault of the company - first of all, your mobile service provider knows orders of magnitude more info on you (and quite likely sells it as well), second of all, your employer will do the same without a second thought as well as your bank, etc.
- kleingeld 4y agoSlippery slope arguments should not be regarded as logical arguments. They are predictions. Calling it a logical fallacy is a strawman argument because in reality, slippery slopes have been observed.
- psyc 4y agoSomeone needs to coin the “We live in a society” fallacy already. We could call it the “Mark Renton Fallacy” for short. There’s no such thing as society, and even if there is I most certainly have nothing to do with it. Save for at tax time.
- greatgib 4y agoSlippery slope because the first step is hard to pass: share any data. Then, just share a few of them, not a big step but it starts the machine of making it easy to share more and more little by little. First IP, then IP and phone nb, then IP, phone nb, and connection log, then IP, phone, connection log, and geodata; then IP, phone nb, connection log, location data; then IP, phone nb, connection log, location data, contacts; Then IP, phone nb, connection lots, location data, contacts, chats ... If you look at the "because terrorism" reason, it can apply at any of these data. No one will say: we think they are terrorist, share their IP but not their location or their chat.