6 ms·
Age verification providers say don’t worry about California design code
- dane-pgp 4y ago> For some higher risk use cases, the age check may involve a liveness test where the user must ... record a short video saying phrases requested by the provider. How long before some profit-maximizing vice president suggests that the requested phrases should be advertising slogans, with these ad slots sold to the highest bidder? We're this close to literally building the "Drink verification can to continue" dystopia that we were warned of: https://www.reddit.com/r/copypasta/comments/fejdvl/drink_verification_can_to_continue/ https://www.reddit.com/r/copypasta/comments/fejdvl/drink_ver...
- collegeburner 4y agoI mean forget a hypothetical copypasta, somebody deadass patented forcing people to say ad slogans: https://preview.redd.it/ggwu7pq5h61y.jpg?auto=webp&s=7e12417ab7634ce6efcdb925723124a42375513e https://preview.redd.it/ggwu7pq5h61y.jpg?auto=webp&s=7e12417... If y'all remember those "solve media" captchas there were a few years back, forcing people to watch an ad then type a slogan? Yeah this would def happen.
- nemothekid 4y agoI'm pretty sure the origin of the copypasta was in response to that patent.
- collegeburner 4y agoOh lol didn't know that, thanks. Also jim_kreggis I cant reply to you bc dead but uhh what? Weird asf ngl.
- jim_kreggis 4y ago
- popcalc 4y agoThat someone is Sony (https://www.engadget.com/2012-08-24-sony-patent-wants-to-make-advertising-more-interactive.html https://www.engadget.com/2012-08-24-sony-patent-wants-to-mak...)
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> How long before some profit-maximizing vice president suggests that the requested phrases should be advertising slogans, with these ad slots sold to the highest bidder? Years ago I encountered a company that sought to do this with a CAPTCHA service; having people type out an advertising phrase to prove their humanity. I thought that was pretty gross, but making people actually say it is even worse. Making people habitually say "I love coca-cola" to access their online accounts seems likely to erode people's sense of self.
- captn3m0 4y agoIRCTC (Indian Railways' ticketing website) does this. Here's the brochure for their service: https://contents.irctc.co.in/en/Captcha_Advertisement.pdf https://contents.irctc.co.in/en/Captcha_Advertisement.pdf Product page from the vendor: https://nlpcaptcha.in/en/nlpcaptcha.html https://nlpcaptcha.in/en/nlpcaptcha.html >Simpli5d technologies makes Captcha an integral part of their products. They provide an engaging Captcha for brands wherein the user engages with the brand by filling the brand message or engaging with the brand across its publisher reach to ensure two way real human engagement with the brand. > Further, this is not just restricted to Captcha and Simpli5d also provides similar solutions on Video pre-roll to ensure there is two way engagement with the brand in the pre-roll as well and not just restricted to blind video views. In general in a video pre-roll campaign the brand is not sure if the video has in reality attracted the eyeballs of the consumer. All these solutions are also available on mobile.
- selfhoster11 4y ago> Making people habitually say "I love coca-cola" to access their online accounts seems likely to erode people's sense of self. I noticed a related effect after getting a Google Home. After a while, my first instinct if I wanted something, was to call out “Hey, Google!” into an empty room. I was literally reprogrammed, in the most disgusting sense possible, to have a brand embedded into my brain as an integral part of a frequent habit. I don’t want the future to look like this. It’s far too close to the “verification can” meme for my liking.
- wbillingsley 4y ago> For some higher risk use cases, the age check may involve a liveness test where the user must ... record a short video saying phrases requested by the provider. I guess that'll be just in time for OpenAI or Stability Diffusion to have an app for that. Somewhere inside a government department inspecting log-in videos "My goodness, have you seen how many websites Tom Cruise logs into each day!"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoWell, no, I won't. If that's the rules, and sites implement them, then I won't visit websites based in California. If there are enough people who won't on principle, or won't because they're fed up with the hassle, then it will be a competitive advantage to not be based in California.
- dane-pgp 4y agoYou say that, but what if Apple helpfully adds this feature to iPhones, like they added support for digital driver's licenses, Covid passes, and (almost) client side scanning for illegal material? For iPhone users who use Face ID, it could cache the result, and send it to sites (signed by a per-device certificate, issued by Apple's CA) in the background, so that most users wouldn't even know this law existed.
- walterbell 4y agoThat might explain the "on-device" claims. Does Apple have partnerships with age-verification companies, or would it become an age-verification company? Is there a connection between Passkeys (FIDO) and age-verification?
- dane-pgp 4y agoThese are the right questions to ask. I suspect that if one were to follow the money behind who is pushing for this law, those questions could be answered.
- walterbell 4y agoSince Apple recently added the ability to store state-level identity documents in Apple Wallet (IF a state/country is on board), it's not a big leap to combine this with Face ID. If Apple can perform a digital attestation of a derived attribute, e.g. "older than 18", rather that disclosing name, DoB, address to the visited website, it would likely be well received. But at that point, we're a hair's breadth away from state-corporate fusion.
- ohiovr 4y agoWe'll need uhauls for California websites.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoA station wagon should be sufficient.
- the_third_wave 4y agoThey're all rented out it seems? https://babylonbee.com/video/i-wish-we-all-could-leave-california-beach-boys-parody https://babylonbee.com/video/i-wish-we-all-could-leave-calif...
- hirundo 4y agoThis of course would lead to an instant red queen's race with face simulators. Given the quality of output we're seeing from Stable Diffusion, et al., it is not at all clear that the face scanners would have an advantage, or even a head start. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_you're_a_dog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_the_Internet,_nobody_knows_... Dear California legislators, please try to encode the above privacy ideal into law instead of the opposite.
- quantified 4y agoWe'll all have Brad Pitt or Olympia Dukakis photos at hand, no need to generate a fake.
- dane-pgp 4y agoThat race arguably started over a decade ago, when age verification cameras on Japanese cigarette vending machines were defeated by "a photo of an older person clipped from a magazine": https://hackaday.com/2008/07/02/age-verification-cameras-easily-fooled/ https://hackaday.com/2008/07/02/age-verification-cameras-eas...
- walterbell 4y agohttps://twitter.com/keir_lamont/status/1564417062532947974 https://twitter.com/keir_lamont/status/1564417062532947974 > Today AB 2273, the California Age-Appropriate Design Code passed the state senate by a vote of 30-0. The assembly unanimously passed an earlier version of the bill back in May ... there needs to be a concurrence step in the assembly in the next couple days. Then to Governor's desk. Bill text: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2273 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- akomtu 4y agoAll 30 members of The Party supported the party line?
- walterbell 4y agoUK/Hollywood lobbyist behind AB-2273, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32603337 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32603337 UK Safety Tech, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/safer-technology-safer-users-the-uk-as-a-world-leader-in-safety-tech/uk-safety-tech-sector-2022-analysis https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/safer-technology-... UK Online Safety bill, https://www.techradar.com/features/uk-online-safety-bill https://www.techradar.com/features/uk-online-safety-bill > Protecting children by ensuring they are not exposed to inappropriate content online. This include stricter age-verification processes to access certain websites - like pornography sites - and, in some cases, the need to monitor private chat for child sexual abuse materials > Securing adults from 'legal but harmful content' by removing such content from their platforms. This rule applies on major social media like Instagram (already in the spotlight for damaging mental health) and TikTok.
- scohesc 4y agoLovely - I guess the US is moving towards the idea that we _want_ the government telling us what we should and shouldn't see instead of creating and/or using tools like block lists to remove what we don't want to see.
- 4y ago
- _23sd 4y agoThe bill does not require face scans nor anything similar. The author of this article wrote another piece claiming that AB 2773 would boost companies that provide age verification products, and someone from a trade group representing age verification providers showed up in the comments to defend their products and used face scans as an example of a method that protects your identity (why they thought that was a good example is a mystery). This is the relevant text in the bill: >Estimate the age of child users with a reasonable level of certainty appropriate to the risks that arise from the data management practices of the business or apply the privacy and data protections afforded to children to all consumers https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2273 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...
- walterbell 4y agoHow do the legislation authors expect complying companies to "estimate the age" of internet visitors? Would driver's licenses and other state IDs be considered acceptable? Would website publishers be required to store those records? If so, does this practically mean that websites would contract with third party age-estimation services which do store state-identity records? What's the track record of such vendors with data protection? Can the state provide age verification services directly, since they are already trusted with the data?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- _23sd 4y agoFrom what I can see in the bill, storing personal information collected to determine age is specifically not allowed. The specifics of how to implement the actions specified are left up to a "California Children’s Data Protection Working Group" that would prepare a report on best practices. So probably it depends on whether the age verification providers get to influence that committee to the exclusion of the rest of the industry.
- cryptonector 4y ago
- joegibbs 4y agoWhat happens if you've got a young-looking face? Are you going to get blocked out until you upload your driver's licence or something? Similarly, what about people on the cusp? It's pretty hard to tell a 19-year-old from a 17-year-old, so won't there be a large population of people it simply won't work on?
- thaumasiotes 4y agoFortunately, the difficult cases like 17-year-olds aren't the primary target of age verification efforts. ;D
- thereisnospork 4y agoIf we look at other 'as implemented' age verification policies, say cigarettes or alcohol if you present as less than 35 or so access will be denied[0] absent ID. [0]In an entirely spurious and random manner at the relative whim of each establishment.
- maxk42 4y agoThis is 100% at odds with both GDPR and CCPA. Should be interesting to see how the laws battle it out.
- jkaplowitz 4y agoSince CCPA and this law are both California state legislation, wouldn't the newer law win if no conflict resolution is stated in either law? The conflict with the GDPR will be interesting indeed.
- jonahhorowitz 4y agoSince CCPA was superseded at the ballot box by CPRA (2020 Prop 24), that would probably govern (basically the reason CPRA exists). - https://www.insideprivacy.com/ccpa/californians-approve-ballot-initiative-modifying-the-california-consumer-privacy-act/ https://www.insideprivacy.com/ccpa/californians-approve-ball... - https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_24,_Consumer_Personal_Information_Law_and_Agency_Initiative_(2020) https://ballotpedia.org/California_Proposition_24,_Consumer_... - https://ballotpedia.org/Legislative_alteration https://ballotpedia.org/Legislative_alteration
- jkaplowitz 4y agoIt's good to highlight that CRPA changed CCPA, but there's a reason CCPA is still the widely used term. According to your first and second links, CRPA heavily amended CCPA and gave it the protection that voter initiatives have under California law, but it didn't repeal and replace CCPA with a different law, and it's still recognizably an evolution of CCPA. If we're being truly precise, CCPA and CRPA are just (acronyms for the) names for the laws which amended the California Civil Code, and the resulting sections of the Civil Code as amended don't officially have either name.
- maxk42 4y agoFor a while I had a phone with a broken camera. Got a new job. Company requires scanning a QR code to authenticate. "I can't - my phone's camera is broken." IT has no idea what to do. After two days of being locked out of services needed to do my job they finally manage to add an exemption for 24 hours to my account. The exemption somehow stands to this day. No, they did not provide a work phone.
- brian-armstrong 4y agoCouldn't you have drawn it in Paint, and then scanned the drawing on your computer?
- donkarma 4y agoyeah that's a reasonable thing to do every day
- 3np 4y agoWas it only on paper or did you get it digitally? If the latter, zbar should do the trick to decode it. If it requires iOS or Android, that'd be a cue to inform them how you currently don't own a device with either and ask how to make it work on your Pinephone running Mobian. More people need to be comfortable with being uncomfortable for this to start changing. Assuming employees will have personal Android/iOS devices and require registering and using them for work functions is something which needs to be mentioned in an employment contract to have any standing.
- NonEUCitizen 4y agoCan't this be repealed with a ballot initiative?
- cryptonector 4y agoCalifornia's legislature is gripping. What will they think of next?!
- im3w1l 4y agoFor how long will making a private website be viable? Like it seems you will need army of lawyers soon. Hobbyists can't and won't keep on top of all of these rules.
- wyager 4y agoThat is one of the goals. Many white-collar classes (lawyers, politicians, etc.) are unhappy with their share of the profits and level of influence over this high-value and high-status sector.
- inetsee 4y agoI wonder whether it would be possible to avoid all this bullsh*t by using Geo-Location to deny access to anyone trying to access a website from a location in California? I am not the least bit dependent on income from my private website, and I couldn't care less if Californians let their politicians block access to my website.
- im3w1l 4y agoI don't think that will be possible, it looks more like death by a thousand cuts as many different places want their own rules. California, UK, EU..
- outside1234 4y agoWe aren’t doing that
- radu_floricica 4y agoI only clicked the title because I was mildly intrigued as to why "China" is shortened to "CA". Now I'm solidly amused... and a bit more grateful for GDPR.
- gorgoiler 4y agoWhat is the ideal tool for managing children’s access to the internet? I always wondered whether local logging is an option. Everything little Johnny does in his iPhone gets recorded and sent to dad’s MacBook Pro for processing every night. A local process looks for anomalous content while also producing a report of all sites visited and apps used. Taking a screenshot every 5s is going to be ~1GB per day but maybe Johnny doesn’t get to use his phone until yesterday’s log has been processed? Perversely, to configure such a system you would have to actively prove you were doing so for a minor. You wouldn’t want to enable adults monitoring other adults. If I worked at Apple this is something I would actively want to build, if it wasn’t there already. Anything to undercut these thin-end-of-the-wedge big brother bills and take the wind out of the “think of the children!” content authoritarians.
- jibe 4y ago"What is the ideal tool for managing children’s access to the internet?" A parent.
- adrianN 4y agoCoincidentally also a good tool for managing the access to the meat space.
- selfhoster11 4y agoNot quite. If the parent manages a child’s access to the internet, then they are quite smart about their approach. That makes them no longer a tool.
- gorgoiler 4y agoRight, but this is what I’m asking. How do I, as a parent, use technology to better supervise my child when I can’t possibly monitor their screen constantly in person? Tech can help us find a middle ground between in my day we let them run free in the yard and now my child am become zombie screen addict, destroyer of childhoods.
- 10000truths 4y agoThere is no such tool that is a replacement for parenting. There’s nothing you can do but keep a watchful eye on what your children consume and discuss the dangers of the Internet with them proactively.
- joshe 4y agoThe super silly thing about this is that if you actually make everyone (in the whole world!) identify content for over 18s, you could just have a browser setting that a parent could set. It layers on to that non existent technology to perfectly identify age from video and with the bonus of a huge dataset matching faces to internet browsing.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoOr cookie preferences for that matter.
- bluebirdfirewin 4y agoMaybe a better solution than using face recognition would be to make a derivative claim from your identity documents issued by an authority (the state). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero-knowledge_proof
- thomassmith65 4y agoIt seems like techdirt articles have been ranking higher on HN lately as the claims in their articles get wilder. It's like watching a million years of evolution in two weeks (except the evolution is 'audience capture' https://gurwinder.substack.com/p/the-perils-of-audience-capture https://gurwinder.substack.com/p/the-perils-of-audience-capt...)
- kbelder 4y agoI used to read Techdirt weekly or more often, but they've really gone off the rails over the last several years. Wilder claims, more politically slanted, and more generally angry, unpleasant, and untrustworthy. Might be due to the original owner bringing in others to generate more content, or maybe they just found that loud shrieking gets more engagement.
- LinuxBender 4y agoWould it be enough to not host a server in California, or would the hosting provider also have to not be based in California, or more extreme would the hosting provider have to not do business in California? How many levels removed would a server renter, owner, operator have to be? As an example, Linode HQ is in Philadelphia, PA and Vultr is in West Palm Beach, FL. Linode have a colo in Fremont, CA and Vultr have a colo in Los Angeles, CA. Would having a colo in California bind them and their customers to this requirement? e.g. If I only use the colocation sites not in California would that suffice, or do I need to migrate to providers that do not have a presence in California?
- lazerl0rd 4y agoJust a thought, but what if all citizens over the age of 18 could use TOTP [with a randomly-assigned secret] to verify their age. If they don't have a mobile device, they could purchase one of those "calculator-like" TOTP devices. Sure, you could give yours to a friend but you could also scan a friend's face with the biometric suggestion or their ID with that suggestion. At least the TOTP suggestion would be quicker to verify, [can be] more privacy-friendly, and can be offloaded onto any devices (you already have one if you're going to need to verify yourself).