4 ms·
> That's just from modulo math. A fifth is 7 semitones, which is relatively prime to 12. Thus 7x (mod 12) hits all the elements of the modulo 12 congruence for
by aidenn0 4y ago
> That's just from modulo math. A fifth is 7 semitones, which is relatively prime to 12. Thus 7x (mod 12) hits all the elements of the modulo 12 congruence for x in 0..11. We cover all notes in the first twelve steps.
> But say we are not assuming a twelve note system in the first place; how do we get twelve notes?
My diagram showed an (approximate) 12 note cycle assuming only a 3:2 ratio for a fifth. There are lots of good reasons to use a fifth as the basic interval[1]. In no way does this assume a 12-note system.
The 12 notes don't come from "filling in" between the 7 notes of the diatonic major scale, they come from continuing the pattern until a near-cycle happens; is your argument that the 1.2% error in the cycle is arbitrary? it's less than 1/4 the next largest difference and slightly more than the rule of thumb for how much "anybody" can hear. The next time we get closer to a cycle is at 41, and we don't get closer by an order of magnitude until 53.
1: And in fact the fifth is used as a basis for many other scales both western and otherwise (Note that the first 5 notes are the major Pentatonic scale and the first 7 are the major diatonic scale).
- kazinator 4y agoYes, the near cycle is a coincidence; it just comes from 1.5 ^ 12 ~= 129.746, which is close to the power-of-two 128. It's because 3^12 is close to 2^19, to about 1.36 percent. This is all abstract arithmetic; I don't believe it's exclusively how musicians discovered chromaticity. That likely has multiple origins, one of which is likely about filling in the five "missing" half step "slots" in a diatonic mode. The 3:2 perfect fifth being an important interval isn't a coincidence; that's rooted in how the frequencies blend together without any beats being heard. The second harmonic of a fundamental is a fifth above the octave, and all that. Speaking of which, the progression of harmonics, which is just multiples of a frequency rather than a geometric series like stacked fifths, can also derive diatonic scale notes.
- aidenn0 4y agoI'm not certain of this, but my understanding is that Pythagoras generated these notes (actually more than 12 because there was a distinction between flats and the matching sharps) circa 500 BCE, and this predates chromaticity in music in the west.
- kazinator 4y agoPythagoras' research is undeniable; but he wasn't some appointed gatekeeper, from whose desk sprang forth all western music. I don't suspect that very many musicians and instrument makers between 500 BCE and 1600-something (even the few that could actually read and write!) would have known about Pythagoras' work, and based their activities on his results.