3 ms·
You also get the western[1] chromatic scale if you go up by a fifth (which is pleasant sounding for many reasons) ad infinitum. C -> G -> D -> A -> E -> B -> F
by aidenn0 4y ago
You also get the western[1] chromatic scale if you go up by a fifth (which is pleasant sounding for many reasons) ad infinitum.
C -> G -> D -> A -> E -> B -> F# -> C# -> G# -> D# -> A# -> E# -> B#(C)
Of course the B# you end up with at the end is 531441/4096 which is 1.3% higher frequency than 7 octaves above the starting C. If you want to generate flats as well, by traveling in the opposite direction, you end up with different notes for the flats. 12-TET is just the modern way of using a constant frequency ratio to divide the octave to match the 12 notes used by Pythagoras. The ancient greeks were unlikely to come up with it due to the reliance on irrational numbers.
1: Pythagoras is often credited with this scale, China also independently invented this scale and it's not clear which came first (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sh%C3%AD-%C3%A8r-l%C7%9C https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sh%C3%AD-%C3%A8r-l%C7%9C)
- kazinator 4y agoThat's just from modulo math. A fifth is 7 semitones, which is relatively prime to 12. Thus 7x (mod 12) hits all the elements of the modulo 12 congruence for x in 0..11. We cover all notes in the first twelve steps. But say we are not assuming a twelve note system in the first place; how do we get twelve notes? Going up a fifth and then down a fourth is very close to a tone. We can do that five times before we approximately hit an octave, yielding six notes. The fifths above those notes are six additional notes. We see that in your diagram: C -> G -> D -> A -> E -> B -> F# -> C# -> G# -> D# -> A# -> E# -> B#(C) in that we can interpret every other note as the whole tone scale: C -> D -> E -> F# -> G# -> A# -> B#(C) and their fifths: G -> A -> B -> C# -> D# -> E# -> Fx(G) Fifths fill the gaps in the whole tone scale to recover the other whole tone scale. Going back to the 12 tone math again, 2 and 12 have a common divisor, so steps of 2 modulo 12 cycle through 6 symbols. There are 6 others left out, reachable by some relatively prime step like 7 (perfect fifth).
- aidenn0 4y ago> That's just from modulo math. A fifth is 7 semitones, which is relatively prime to 12. Thus 7x (mod 12) hits all the elements of the modulo 12 congruence for x in 0..11. We cover all notes in the first twelve steps. > But say we are not assuming a twelve note system in the first place; how do we get twelve notes? My diagram showed an (approximate) 12 note cycle assuming only a 3:2 ratio for a fifth. There are lots of good reasons to use a fifth as the basic interval[1]. In no way does this assume a 12-note system. The 12 notes don't come from "filling in" between the 7 notes of the diatonic major scale, they come from continuing the pattern until a near-cycle happens; is your argument that the 1.2% error in the cycle is arbitrary? it's less than 1/4 the next largest difference and slightly more than the rule of thumb for how much "anybody" can hear. The next time we get closer to a cycle is at 41, and we don't get closer by an order of magnitude until 53. 1: And in fact the fifth is used as a basis for many other scales both western and otherwise (Note that the first 5 notes are the major Pentatonic scale and the first 7 are the major diatonic scale).
- kazinator 4y agoYes, the near cycle is a coincidence; it just comes from 1.5 ^ 12 ~= 129.746, which is close to the power-of-two 128. It's because 3^12 is close to 2^19, to about 1.36 percent. This is all abstract arithmetic; I don't believe it's exclusively how musicians discovered chromaticity. That likely has multiple origins, one of which is likely about filling in the five "missing" half step "slots" in a diatonic mode. The 3:2 perfect fifth being an important interval isn't a coincidence; that's rooted in how the frequencies blend together without any beats being heard. The second harmonic of a fundamental is a fifth above the octave, and all that. Speaking of which, the progression of harmonics, which is just multiples of a frequency rather than a geometric series like stacked fifths, can also derive diatonic scale notes.
- aidenn0 4y agoI'm not certain of this, but my understanding is that Pythagoras generated these notes (actually more than 12 because there was a distinction between flats and the matching sharps) circa 500 BCE, and this predates chromaticity in music in the west.
- kazinator 4y agoPythagoras' research is undeniable; but he wasn't some appointed gatekeeper, from whose desk sprang forth all western music. I don't suspect that very many musicians and instrument makers between 500 BCE and 1600-something (even the few that could actually read and write!) would have known about Pythagoras' work, and based their activities on his results.